Atlas Energy Public Company LimitedSET: ATLAS🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2025

Internal Control — Board Opinion

Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control

The Company recognizes the critical importance of an internal control system. The Board of Directors has established an Audit Committee, an independent body to perform duties and provide support to the Company in order to ensure that there is an appropriate and adequate internal control system to supervise operations in accordance with the objectives, goals, strategies, laws, and related regulations effectively. Such a system can help prevent and manage risks or damages that may occur to the Company and stakeholders, protect assets from fraud or damage, as well as ensure that accounting and financial reports are prepared accurately and reliably, and that information is disclosed completely and sufficiently within an appropriate timeframe.

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO)

At the Board of Directors’ Meeting No. 6/2025 held on November 5, 2025, all three members of the Audit Committee, who are independent directors of the Company, were present. The meeting reviewed and assessed the adequacy of the Company’s internal control system by conducting inquiries with the management and internal auditors, as well as by evaluating the internal control assessment form. The Board of Directors evaluated the Company’s internal control system based on five components, in accordance with the framework of the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (“COSO”), which includes:

  1. Internal Control

  2. Risk Assessment

  3. Activity Control

  4. Information and Communication

  5. Monitoring Activities

The Board of Directors believes that the Company’s internal control system is both appropriate and in alignment with the Company’s business operations. The Company has implemented processes to ensure that its activities are conducted efficiently, in accordance with its goals, objectives, laws, and relevant regulations. The internal controls effectively safeguard assets from loss or unauthorized use, and the Company has sufficient personnel to manage and operate the internal control system effectively. Additionally, there is oversight in place to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the Company’s financial reporting. As a result, the Board of Directors has approved the evaluation form for assessing the adequacy of the Company’s internal control system. (Further details regarding the adequacy of the internal control system can be found in the attached documents, i.e., the Evaluation Form for the Adequacy of the Internal Control System and Attachment 6 – the Audit Committee Report.)

Internal Control Deficiencies

Introduction

The Company recognizes that a robust internal control system is essential for ensuring the efficient and effective operation of its business. To this end, the Board of Directors has appointed an Audit Committee to oversee and evaluate the adequacy of the internal control system. This system must comply with principles of good corporate governance, as well as relevant laws and regulations, including those set by the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) and the Stock Exchange of Thailand (“SET”). Additionally, the Audit Committee is responsible for reviewing the financial reporting process to ensure that the Company’s operations and disclosures are transparent, reliable, and credible. The Audit Committee meets at least once every quarter, with the internal auditor and the Company’s external auditor in attendance. These meetings allow the Audit Committee to review the results of internal control assessments and hear feedback on the Company’s audit process, all without the presence of management.

The Company appointed KPMG Phoomchai Business Advisory Limited (“KPMG Internal Auditor”) as its internal auditor on February 23, 2021. The internal audit function is led by Mr. Supachate Kunaluckkul, a qualified professional with expertise in auditing procedures and tools. His deep understanding of the Company’s business ensures that both risk assessments and internal control audits, conducted at the business and overall levels, are effective, comprehensive, and correct, aligned with best practices in risk evaluation and internal control auditing.

Additionally, the Company has established its own Internal Audit Department, which works in collaboration with KPMG's internal auditors to review the internal control system. During a meeting of the Audit Committee, it was resolved to appoint Ms. Jariya Sangumram as the Head of Internal Audit, effective February 23, 2021. Ms. Jariya Sangumram brings valuable experience in internal auditing within business fields/industries similar to the Company’s. She previously served as the internal auditor for PTG Energy Public Company Limited ("PTG") for four years and has participated in various training programs related to internal auditing. Notably, she completed the "Certified Professional Internal Auditor of Thailand (CPIAT)" program (CPIAT-20) and was awarded the CPIAT certification by the Institute of Internal Auditors of Thailand in 2012. The Audit Committee has therefore concluded that Ms. Jariya Sangumram, with her thorough understanding of the Company’s operations, is highly qualified to serve as the Head of Internal Audit.

In this regard, the information and related details of the person assigned to be directly responsible for the duties of the Head of Internal Audit appear in Attachment 3 “Information Regarding the Head of Internal Audit .”

The internal auditor, KPMG, conducted the first review of the internal control system of the Company and its subsidiaries during the period from March to May 2021 by examining all significant work processes. The internal auditor prepared the Internal Control Adequacy Assessment Report No. 1 dated 11 May 2021 and reported the audit results and recommendations of the internal auditor to the Audit Committee. The internal auditor, KPMG, identified a total of 11 significant observations, consisting of 5 observations with medium risk, 2 observations with low risk, and 4 observations classified as Opportunity for Improvement (OFI).

Subsequently, management implemented corrective actions based on the findings outlined in KPMG's internal audit report. KPMG’s internal auditors followed up on the implementation of these corrective actions between September and October 2021, issuing the second Internal Control System Adequacy Evaluation Report dated October 29, 2021. This report tracked the progress of the correction and included KPMG's findings and recommendations to the Audit Committee. Following this review, KPMG's internal auditors reported no significant issues.

In July 2022, the internal auditors conducted a comprehensive review of the Company’s internal control system, covering all key operational processes. They subsequently issued the third Internal Control System Adequacy Evaluation Report dated August 10, 2022. This report, which included the results of the KPMG’s audit and the auditors’ recommendations to the Audit Committee, found no significant issues.

However, to ensure ongoing confidence in the effectiveness of the internal control system, KPMG's internal auditors carried out another round of audits from July to September 2024, reviewing the internal control systems of the Company and its subsidiaries. This latest review covered 10 critical operational processes, as outlined below:

  1. Oil Sales Management Process

  2. Sales and Payment Collection Process

  3. Service Station and Gas Shop Management Process

  4. Procurement and Payment Process

  5. Inventory Management Process (Gas Filling Plants)

  6. Fixed Asset Management Process

  7. Human Resources Management Process

  8. Accounting and Financial Management Process

  9. Contract Management Process

  10. General Controls for Information Technology Systems

KPMG’s internal auditors identified no significant issues during the review. They issued the fourth Internal Control System Adequacy Evaluation Report, dated September 17, 2024, and presented their findings and recommendations to the Audit Committee Meeting No. 5/2024, as well as to the Board of Directors Meeting No. 5/2024, both held on September 17, 2024. Both the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors reviewed and acknowledged the internal audit report.

The Internal Audit Department of the Company conducted its first internal control audit of the Company and its subsidiaries in July 2021, focusing on the gas sales management process. The findings were compiled into an audit report, which was presented to the Audit Committee Meeting No. 3/2024 on August 10, 2021. On a quarterly basis, the Internal Audit Department continues to assess key operational processes and prepares audit reports for presentation to the Audit Committee. The audits cover the following areas:

  1. Gas sales management system

  2. Sales and payment System – Dealer Customer

  3. Sales and payment collection system – Industrial customers

  4. Sales and payment collection system – Commercial customers

  5. Gas filling plant management system

  6. Gas shop management system

  7. Service station management system

  8. Gas Shop Training System

  9. Supply chain management system

  10. Procurement and payment system

  11. Maintenance management system

  12. General IT management system

  13. Human resource management system

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)142824

Deficiency Details

Period TypeStart Period (YYYY-MM)End Period (YYYY-MM)DetailProgress StatusCorrective Action
month/year Range2023-012024-02
1. Sales and Payment Collection System – Dealer Customer 1.1) The Price List has not been approved in writing. The Company prepares the Price List in the form of an Excel file for sales representatives (Sales) to use as a reference; however, the Price List has not been proposed to the authorized person for written approval, and the effective date has not been specified in the Price List. Risk: Medium 1.2) In the process of revising the Check List for preparation for the opening of a new gas filling plant to cover important procedures in accordance with the actual operations. The Check List for preparation for becoming a new gas filling plant customer found that the procedures for preparation for new customers have not yet covered the actual operating procedures. Risk: Low 1.3) The workflow for preparing the Sales Price Memo has not yet been added in the Kissflow system to replace manual preparation. The Company prepares the Sales Price Memo and prints it for submission to the authorized person for approval and keeps it in a file. However, the Kissflow system used by the Company is able to support the preparation of various workflows to reduce manual operations. Risk: Opportunity for Improvement (OFI)
Incident no longer subject to action

1.1) The relevant officer proposed the Price List to the authorized person for signature approval on February 15, 2024.

1.2) The relevant officer prepared the Check List for preparation for the opening of a new gas filling plant to cover the recommendations on February 15, 2024.

1.3) The relevant officer has prepared the Sales Price Memo in the Kissflow system on May 7, 2024.

month/year Range2023-012024-02
2. Sales and Payment Collection System – Industrial Customers 2.1) The Price List has not been approved in writing. The Company prepares the Price List in the form of an Excel file for sales representatives (Sales) to use as a reference; however, the Price List has not been proposed to the authorized person for signature approval in writing, and the effective date has not been specified in the Price List. Risk: Medium 2.2) No register has been prepared to monitor the purchase status to comply with the minimum quantity according to the conditions in the contract. The Company’s industrial customer group places orders in accordance with the minimum quantity specified in the contract conditions. However, from the interview with the officer, it was found that no register has been prepared to monitor the purchase status to comply with the minimum quantity according to the conditions in the contract. Risk: Low 2.3) The workflow for preparing sales price memos has not yet been implemented in the Kissflow system, and is still being done manually. The Company prepares sales price memos and prints them for presentation to authorized approvers, with physical copies filed for record-keeping. However, the Kissflow system used by the Company is capable of supporting various workflows that could reduce reliance on manual processes. Risk: Opportunity for Improvement (OFI)
Incident no longer subject to action

2.1) The relevant officer proposed the Price List to the authorized person for signature approval on February 15, 2024.

2.2) The relevant officer prepared a register to monitor the purchase status according to the minimum quantity, completed on February 15, 2024, and designated it as a monthly agenda of the Sales Department meeting.

2.3) The relevant officer has prepared the Sales Price Memo in the Kissflow system on May 7, 2024.

month/year Range2023-062024-02
3. General IT management system 3.1) Annual review of LMS access rights is in progress. The Company is in the process of reviewing access rights in the LMS system annually and is in the process of following up with all departments to review and confirm the access rights. Risk: Medium 3.2) The LMS system has no configuration to suspend access rights if the password is entered incorrectly more than 3 times, no password age of 90 days is specified, and no Idle Time Session Time is configured. User accounts in the system group controlled by the LDAP system have been configured in the system to have controls in accordance with the Company’s regulations, except for the LMS system which has no configuration to suspend access rights if the password is entered incorrectly more than 3 times, no password age of 90 days is specified, and no Idle Time Session Time is configured. Risk: Medium 3.3 The penetration test project is in progress The Company is in the process of conducting the penetration test project (Penetration Test), which will be due for testing according to the Company’s policy in November 2024. Risk: OFI
Incident no longer subject to action

3.1) All departments have thoroughly reviewed and confirmed the rights in the LMS system on February 7, 2024.

3.2) The system was improved and implemented again on March 28, 2024 as follows:

  1. Session time set to 30 seconds

  2. Password age set to 90 days

  3. User account locked in case the password is entered incorrectly 3 times

3.3) The Company conducted the penetration test (Penetration Test) in May 2024 and has already improved the system according to the recommendations of the service provider.

month/year Range2023-102024-04
4. Sales and Payment Collection System – Commercial Customers 4.1) The preparation of the criteria for the payment of performance-based incentives for sales representatives (Incentive) for 2024 has not yet been completed. The Commercial Sales Department has already set sales targets and communicated them to the sales team; however, the incentive payment criteria are still under review by the Human Resources Committee. Risk: Medium 4.2) The preparation of the Price List for cooking gas and other products (such as vegetable oil, gas canisters, etc.) is in progress. The Commercial Sales Department has not yet established a formal price list to be used as a reference for sales documentation. Risk: Medium 4.3) No register has been prepared to monitor the purchase status to comply with the minimum quantity according to the conditions in the contract. The LPG sales contract specifies the minimum purchase quantity; however, the Commercial Sales Department has not yet prepared a register to monitor the minimum purchase status. Risk: Low
Incident no longer subject to action

4.1) The Personnel Committee has approved the criteria for the payment of Incentive already.

4.2) The relevant officer prepared the Price List and proposed it to the authorized person for signature approval already.

4.3) The relevant officer prepared a register to monitor the purchase status according to the minimum quantity, completed already, and designated it as a monthly agenda of the Sales Department meeting

month/year Range2024-012024-06
5. Gas Shop Management System 5.1) No register has been prepared for the steel racks used for placing LPG cylinders on motorcycles. One gas shop, which serves as a center for storing equipment (such as steel racks for placing LPG cylinders on motorcycles and LPG cylinder straps, etc.), has not prepared a register to control such equipment. Risk: Low 5.2) The register for preparation for the opening of a new branch does not cover important activities. The Company has prepared a register for preparation for the opening of a new gas shop branch; however, the register does not yet cover some important activities. Risk: Low
Incident no longer subject to action

5.1) The relevant officer has prepared an equipment control register, and counting is performed every time when the equipment is received and issued.


5.2) The relevant officer reviewed the register and revised and corrected the register to cover the important activities already.

month/year Range2024-012024-12
6. Oil and Gas Station Management System 6.1) The collection of manual receipt books from branches is in progress. The Company mainly prepares receipts through the POS system and the Max Station system, resulting in the manual receipt books stored at service station branches not being used. Therefore, the manual receipt books should be collected from the service station branches to prevent the use of receipt books that may be inappropriate. Risk: Low
Incident no longer subject to action

6.1) The Area Manager has collected the receipt books from all branches completely already.

month/year Range2024-012024-11
7. Human Resource Management System 7.1) The first aid cabinet at the head office does not have complete basic equipment and medicines as required by law. The first aid cabinet at the head office does not have complete basic equipment and medicines as required by law, totaling 4 items. Risk: Medium 7.2) No summary reports or analysis of utility and administrative expenses are currently prepared. The Company prepares a monthly telephone usage summary report; however, a summary report of utility expenses and administrative expenses (such as water supply expenses, electricity expenses, parking fees, parcel delivery fees, and office equipment expenses, etc.) has not yet been prepared for analysis and expense control to be appropriate. Risk: Low
Incident no longer subject to action

7.1) The relevant officer has procured the medicines and equipment completely in accordance with the legal requirements already.

7.2) The relevant officer has prepared the summary report of such utility expenses and administrative expenses already.

month/year Range2024-082025-02
8. Marketing and Sales Promotion Management System 8.1) No record has been made of the reasons for rejection by customers in the market segment. The Company conducts market surveys and presents promotional prices to customers in the market segment so that food vendors in the markets use the Company’s LPG, and prepares a register of market names and LPG shops responsible for supplying gas to food vendors in the markets. However, no record has been made of the reasons for rejection by customers in the market segment to be used as information for further improvement. Risk: Opportunity for Improvement (OFI) 8.2) No deactivation has been made in the Power BI system. The Company uses the Power BI system to review sales and promotion data. However, there are two reports in the Power BI system that are no longer in use, as new reports with more comprehensive details have been developed. The BI team has not yet been informed to deactivate these two reports in the Power BI system. Risk: Opportunity for Improvement (OFI)
Implemented

8.1) The relevant officer has recorded the reasons for rejection in the control register and presented them in the monthly meeting of the department starting from January 2025 onward.

8.2) The relevant officer opened a ticket to request the closure of the reports in the Power BI system, and the BI Department completed closing the reports on February 17, 2025.

month/year Range2024-102025-05
9. Supply Chain Management System 9.1) No signature has been made to certify the correction in the gas transportation delivery note of the gas service station. From the sampling review of the gas transportation delivery notes, it was found that the gas service station manager and the truck driver did not sign to certify the correction of the gas quantity in some gas transportation delivery notes. Risk: Low
Incident no longer subject to action

9.1) Coordination has been made with the Gas Service Station Operations Department to communicate and emphasize that the gas service station manager must sign together with the truck driver whenever there is a strike-through correction of the gas delivery quantity in the gas transportation delivery note.

month/year Range2024-012025-08
10. Gas Filling Plant Operations Management System 10.1) The process for handling product quality complaints is under revision. The Company has revised the forms related to product quality complaint management. The draft forms have been uploaded to the Kissflow system; however, they are currently pending approval in the system. Risk: Low
Incident no longer subject to action

10.1) The Company has proceeded to have the authorized person approve the forms in the system already.

month/year Range2025-012025-11
11. Gas Shop Operations Management System 11.1) Utility payments for Gas Shop branches outside service stations are not processed through the Accounting Department. Based on a sample interview with staff at the Wat Tonchuek Community Branch (Bang Yai), it was found that the staff have to pay the water supply and electricity expenses at the Waterworks Authority and the Electricity Authority by themselves, with a round-trip distance of approximately 20 kilometers. The relevant officer of the Accounting Department informed that the payment of water supply expenses to the Waterworks Authority and electricity expenses to the Electricity Authority can be made by the Accounting Department at the Head Office; however, the Gas Shop Sales Department did not notify the Accounting Department regarding the list of Gas Shop branches outside service stations informed by the Gas Shop Sales Department of the list of Gas Shop branches located outside service stations. Risk: Low
Incident no longer subject to action

11.1) The Gas Shop Support Department has proceeded as follows:

  • Coordinated with the Accounting Department to make payments for the water supply and electricity expenses of Gas Shop branches outside service stations already, starting from December 2025 onward.

  • Prepared a register for the lease agreements of Gas Shop branches outside service stations, specifying details of water supply and electricity payments and the coordination status with the Accounting Department for expense payment already.

month/year Range2025-012025-10
12. Human Resource Management System 12.1) No asset tag codes have been affixed to all assets of the Training Center, totaling 203 items, representing 100% From the sampling review of asset tag codes at the Training Center against the asset list from the Asset Accounting Department’s asset register on August 28, 2025, it was found that all 203 assets had not yet been affixed with asset tag codes, representing 100%, since the Training Center commenced operations on November 20, 2024. Risk: Medium
Implemented

12.1) The Human Resource Development Department coordinated with the Asset Accounting Department, and the asset tag codes were affixed completely on October 24, 2025.

month/year Range2025-012026-02
13. Sales and Payment Collection System – Commercial 13.1) Access rights in the LMS system were granted that are not related to the scope of job responsibilities From the review of access rights to information in the LMS system of employees related to Commercial Sales, it was found that 2 employees were granted access rights that are not related to the scope of their job responsibilities, with access rights equivalent to those of a Gas Shop Branch Manager. From the review of LMS system usage, it was not found that the 2 employees who were granted access rights had accessed the system in the above-mentioned menu. After being informed of the identified issue, the management of the CM Sales Department instructed the responsible person to open a ticket to request the removal of the unrelated access rights on February 10, 2026. Risk: Low
Incident no longer subject to action

13.1) The IT Department has removed the access rights according to the request of the Commercial Sales Department on February 18, 2026. When access rights in the LMS system are reviewed, if any access rights that are not consistent with the responsibilities of the person in charge are found, coordination with the IT Department will be made to remove such access rights immediately.

month/year Range2024-012025-12
In addition, the Company has engaged the Internal Audit Department of PTG to provide internal control system audit services for the COCO Service stations, gas shops, gas depots, and gas filling plants located across all regions. The Internal Audit Department of PTG conducted the first internal control system audit of the COCO Service stations and gas shops during July 2021 and prepared an audit report to be reported to the Audit Committee Meeting No. 3/2021 on August 10, 2021. After that, the Internal Audit Department of PTG conducted audits of the COCO Service stations, gas shops, gas depots, and gas filling plants according to the audit plan, which specifies that the audit plan must cover all stations within one year, and prepared audit reports to be reported to the Company’s management and the Audit Committee on a quarterly basis. During 2024 to 2025, the Internal Audit Department of PTG identified the following issues: 1. Service Stations 1.1) Outstanding petty cash receipts There are three outstanding petty cash reimbursement documents totaling THB 135. (1st Quarter/2024, 1 branch identified from a review of 131 branches, 4th Quarter/2024: 1 branch identified from a review of 427 branches, where outstanding petty cash reimbursement documents were found) Risk: Low 1.2) Petty cash was used exceeding the authorized limit by using personal funds. There was one case of petty cash expenditure exceeding the authorized limit, amounting to THB 288. (4th Quarter/2024: 1 branch identified from a review of 427 branches) Risk: Low 1.3) Petty cash was commingled with personal funds. A branch manager kept change from petty cash transactions together with personal funds. (2nd Quarter/2025: 1 branch identified from a review of 401 branches) Risk: Low 1.4) Failure to record fuel/LPG measurements in the logbook Service station staff performed daily stock checks for LPG & Oil but were not recorded in the designated logbook as required (1st Quarter/2024: 2 branches identified out of 131 branches inspected, 2nd Quarter/2024: 1 branch identified out of 213 branches inspected.) Risk: Low 1.5) Not printed fuel/LPG measurement report Service station staff did not print the fuel/LPG measurement report. (2nd Quarter/2024: 1 branch identified out of 213 branches inspected.) Risk: Low 1.6) Fuel withdrawals were not in compliance with the company's policy Service station staff withdrew Gasohol 95 for lawnmowers, while the Company policy specified the use of Gasohol 91, the least expensive option. (3 Quarter/2024: 2 branches identified out of 230 branches inspected.) Risk: Low 1.7) Complimentary water bottles were not arranged in an orderly manner. Service station staff arranged complimentary water bottles in a disorganized manner, making it difficult to perform inventory counting. (1st Quarter/2025: 2 branches identified from a review of 429 branches, 3rd Quarter/2025: 2 branches identified from a review of 583 branches) Risk: Low 1.8) Petty cash was commingled with personal funds. A branch manager withdrew cash from the safe to purchase chairs and had not yet returned the cash to the safe. (2nd Quarter/2025: 1 branch identified from a review of 401 branches) Risk: Low 1.9) Corrections to the Cash Remittance Amount in the Meter Logbook Were Not Acknowledged by Signature The branch manager corrected the total cash remittance amount at shift closing in the meter logbook by crossing out, rewriting, or overwriting the figures without signing to acknowledge the correction. (4th Quarter/2025:1 branch identified from a review of 545 branches) Risk: Low 2. LPG Gas shops 2.1) Delayed recording of inventory withdrawal The branch staff reported using 5 bottles of palm oil for a firefighting event but has not yet updated the inventory in the system. (1st Quarter/2024: 1 branch identified out of 85 branches inspected.) The Marketing Department also withdrew Cooking Gas from the gas shop for promotional activities, but the stock adjustments were not made. however, The branch staff has not yet recorded the transaction in the system. (2nd Quarter/2024: 1 branch identified out of 106 branches inspected.) Risk: Low 2.2) No change fund was provided to branch staff Some LPG Gas Shop are managed under a cluster system where a 1 manager oversees multiple branches. However, the cluster manager did not provide a change fund to the staff at the branches. (1st Quarter/2024: 1 branch identified out of 85 branches inspected.) Risk: Low 2.3) Mixing of sales revenue with personal funds Branch staff mixed sales revenue with their personal funds, resulting in a discrepancy of 87 baht when comparing cash against sales totals. (3rd Quarter/2024: 1 branch identified out of 284 branches inspected.) In addition, an excess amount of cash over sales totaling THB 109 was identified. (2nd Quarter/2025: 4 branches from a review of 366 branches. Risk: Low 2.4) Outstanding Petty Cash Receipts One petty cash receipt for brake pad replacement amounting to THB 70 remained pending reimbursement. (4th Quarter/2024: 1 branch identified out of 314 branches inspected.) Risk: Low 2.5) Recording of empty cylinder transfers back to the gas filling plant was delayed. The Assistant Branch Manager recorded the transfer of empty cylinders back to the gas filling plant with a one-day delay, resulting in a discrepancy on the date of the auditor’s physical count. (1st Quarter/2025: 1 branch identified from a review of 296 branches) Risk: Low 2.6) Sales cash was commingled with personal funds. (2nd Quarter/2025: this issue was identified at 4 branches from a review of 366 branches) Khlong Si (Thanyaburi) – April: excess sales cash of THB 24 Bang Pakong 4 – May: excess sales cash of THB 10 Vibhavadi Rangsit Rd. 1 (Soi 32) – May: excess sales cash of THB 50 Phra Thep Rd. 1 – May: excess sales cash of THB 25 Risk: Low 2.7) Branch names in the Max Card Plus gateway system were not updated to correctly reflect the actual branches accepting Max Card Plus. (Q3/2025: 2 branches identified from a review of 489 branches.) Tamod Branch: 2 cards out of a total of 7 cards Pa Bon Branch: 4 cards out of a total of 4 cards Risk: Low 2.8. Delayed Delivery of Petty Cash to Branches A Area Manager submitted requests to establish petty cash funds for branches later than scheduled. (4th Quarter/2025: 4 branches identified from a review of 499 branches.) Risk: Low
Incident no longer subject to action

1.1) The branch manager has submitted the reimbursement request through the PCCA system. In addition, the Station Operations Department organized a workshop to discuss approaches to reduce issues identified by Internal Audit and instructed Regional Managers to analyze branch audit reports so that Area Managers can focus on reviewing branches where issues were identified.

1.2) The branch manager performs a daily review of the remaining petty cash balance against expense receipts and sales cash receipts before the end of each business day.
1.3) The branch manager has already placed such change money in the safe, and the Service Station Operations Department has emphasized that the branch manager must keep the petty cash in the safe immediately if the money is not in use.
1.4) and 1.5) The station operations team conducted a workshop to discuss ways to resolve issues raised by internal auditors. Regional managers have been instructed to analyze the audit results and prioritize inspections at branches where issues have been identified.

1.6) Service station staff have been informed and will comply with the Company's policy during the next withdrawal.

1.7) Service station staff have arranged the complimentary water bottles in an orderly manner, and the Area Manager has rechecked and verified the inventory count.

1.8) The branch manager has separated petty cash from personal funds, and the Area Manager has emphasized compliance with the applicable regulations.

1.9) The Area Manager has instructed all branches to ensure that any corrections are jointly signed by the cashier and the branch manager each time a correction is made.

2.1) Branch staff have recorded and processed the inventory adjustments in the LMS system and have updated the stock accordingly.

2.2) The Cluster Manager has now transferred the change fund to the branch staff.
2.3) Branch staff have now separated the sales revenue from their personal funds. Additionally, the area manager conducted a follow-up visit to the branch, reinforcing the importance of keeping sales funds separate from personal money.

2.4) he Area Manager has rectified the issue by processing the petty cash reimbursement through the PCCA system.

2.5) The Assistant Branch Manager has completed the transfer recording in the system.

2.6) The Assistant Branch Manager has separated sales cash from personal funds, and the Area Manager has emphasized compliance with the applicable regulations.

2.7) The Area Manager explained that the Tamod and Pa Bon branches received transferred Max Card Plus cards from other branches. However, the Assistant Branch Manager at the transferring branch did not update the branch name in the Gateway system to correctly reflect the branch to which the Max Card Plus cards were handed over. After the issue was identified, the Area Manager updated the branch names in the Gateway system to the correct branch names.

2.8) All four branches have now received the petty cash funds in full.

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

Yes

Auditor's Observations

The Company appointed PriceWaterHouseCoopers ABAS Ltd. (“the Auditor”) as the external auditor for the Company and its subsidiaries for the fiscal year 2023 and 2024. In the course of auditing the financial statements, the Auditor identified several observations related to the Company’s internal control system. As a result of the audit of the financial statements for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2023, a total of three observations were noted. The Company has since addressed and resolved all of these observations. As for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2024, a total of ten observations were noted. The Company has since addressed and resolved one observation, while nine observations are in the process of being addressed. The details are as follows:


Identified Issues

Summary of Follow-Up Audit Results

  1. Information Technology 2024


1.1) Lack of Written Approval for User Access Modification

A user account’s access rights were modified without documented evidence of a formal request or written approval. The account belongs to a temporary outsourcing employee, and although the change was requested by the Director, no supporting documentation was retained.

Improved:

The Company has communicated the user account request process through the KACE workflow to the relevant departments and has emphasized the importance of complying with the established policies and procedures.

1.2) Non-Compliance with Compensating Controls Specified in the Policy Exception Document

It was noted that system and embedded accounts were reviewed; however, the review did not cover all user accounts due to an error encountered during data extraction. In addition, the Company did not review the access activities of system and embedded accounts as required by the policy exception document. Management explained that there is a high volume of activities associated with system and embedded accounts, and there are limitations in retaining the related logs.

Improved:

The Company revised the policy exception document in February 2025:

  • The revised document covers system accounts, embedded accounts, and privileged users for whom password policies cannot be enforced.

  • The compensating control has been implemented to ensure that the user access review covers all users.

In addition, the Company has completed a retrospective review of system users and privileged users.

1.3) Changes to Security Settings and Job Schedules Without Proper Testing and Approval

Changes were made to security settings and interface schedules, including modifications to password settings and interface job schedules. However, these changes were not processed in accordance with the established change management procedures.

No evidence of change request approval or testing was found to confirm that the changes had been properly authorized and that they would not impact system operations.

Improved:

The Company strictly complies with the change management process by submitting configuration change requests through Lotus Notes and has coordinated with relevant personnel to ensure that system configuration changes are properly implemented in accordance with the established procedures.

2. Information Technology Year 2025

2.1) Inappropriate Assignment of Elevated Privileges to Users

privileged access rights were inappropriately assigned to certain user accounts in the SAP system, LMS system, and Max Station system, as detailed below:

  • Inappropriate access rights include the ability to execute database commands and manage user accounts within the system.

    • SAP System (Application Level)

    • SAP System (Database Level)

  • Privileged access in the production instance was assigned to system developers.

    • Max Station System (Application Level)

    • LMS System (Application and Database Levels)

In the process of revision:

Action Plan:

  • SAP: Review user access rights and appropriateness in accordance with roles and responsibilities, and adjust access rights to comply with the established requirements.

  • LMS and Max Station: Due to current personnel constraints, a formal policy exception request has been submitted for approval. The associated risks have been assessed, and compensating controls have been established.

2.2) Absence of a Process to Verify the Completeness of User Account Listings Prior to Access Review

There is no process in place to verify the completeness of user account listings before submitting them for access review. As a result, the user access review may not cover all user accounts, leading to incomplete verification of user access rights.

In the process of revision:

Action Plan:

  • A retrospective user access review for the SAP system was conducted to cover previously incomplete user accounts and access rights (Completed – December 2025).

  • A retrospective user access review for the Max Station system and LMS system was conducted to cover previously incomplete user accounts and access rights (Completed – January 2026).

  • Emphasis will be placed on requiring Application Owners to verify the completeness and accuracy of user listings before submitting them for user access review.

2.3) Access control management lacks rigor, and there is insufficient evidence of authorization from appropriate authorities.

Based on sample testing, it was found that the documentation supporting access requests to the SAP system was incomplete, as follows:

  • No evidence of access request and approval was found for 3 items.

  • No approval from the business unit head of the requester was found for 1 item.

In the process of revision:

Action Plan:

Relevant departments will be reminded to ensure that all user access requests and supporting evidence are properly submitted and retained through the ticketing system only.

2.4) User Accounts of Resigned Employees Were Not Deactivated in a Timely Manner

the deactivation of system access for resigned employees was not performed within the required timeframe.

Root Cause: An error in the script caused a delay in notifying the IT team, resulting in untimely account deactivation.

In the process of revision:

Action Plan:

  • The remaining user accounts in Active Directory have been deactivated (Completed – December 2025).

  • The automated script used for deactivating user accounts of terminated employees will be reviewed and corrected to ensure it properly covers all scenarios.

  • User accounts of resigned employees will be reviewed as part of the semi-annual user access review process.

2.5) Privileged Access Granted to External Service Providers Without Adequate Monitoring Process

Privileged access rights in the SAP and MaxPOS systems were granted to external service providers (vendors) without a written service agreement in place. No formal contract was found specifying key terms and conditions such as roles and responsibilities, data confidentiality requirements, and service level agreements (SLA). As a result, there is no formal mechanism to regularly monitor and oversee the vendors’ system access activities.

In the process of revision:

Action Plan:

  • SAP: Configure access time restrictions for external service providers.

  • MaxPOS: Reduce the privileges of external service providers to only those necessary to support operational activities.

2.6) Password Configuration Not Compliant with Company Policy and Inappropriate Implementation of Compensating Controls

The Company has prepared an Exception Document for password configurations that cannot be aligned with the established password policy. However, the following issues were identified:

The Exception Document does not cover all password settings that are not compliant with the policy.

The compensating controls require periodic reviews of user accounts, but the review was not performed comprehensively.

However, accounts that cannot comply with the password policy are system user accounts and administrator accounts.

In addition, the Company’s password policy does not fully define all required password security parameters.

In the process of revision:

Action Plan:

  • As changes to password configurations may impact system operations, the Company has submitted a formal policy exception request and established compensating controls by conducting an annual review of user accounts with password policy exceptions during the first quarter.

  • Relevant departments will be reminded to verify the completeness of the list of user accounts that are exempted from the Company’s password policy settings.

2.7) Incomplete Monitoring and Review of Privileged Access Usage in the SAP System

The quarterly review of activity logs related to privileged access usage in the SAP system was not performed comprehensively.

Improved: (Corrective Action)

Action Plan:

Conduct a review of the activity logs related to privileged access usage that were omitted from the regular review cycle.

2.8) Lack of Segregation of Duties in Program Change Activities

Segregation of duties has not been implemented in program change activities. The same individual has been assigned multiple conflicting roles.

Root Cause: A lack of personnel and clearly defined roles and responsibilities has resulted in staff members being required to perform multiple roles within the program change management process.

In the process of revision:

Action Plan:

  • LMS: A policy exception document has been prepared and approved by the authorized approver. The responsible unit will log incidents each time a transaction is required on the Azure Server to maintain evidence for further audit review.

  • MaxStation: A policy exception document has been prepared. The responsible unit will review system logs as part of the periodic user access review cycle.

2.9) SAP System Configuration Not Aligned with International Standards

Certain SAP system configuration settings related to system change controls are not aligned with international practices.

In the process of revision:

Action Plan:

The Company is currently consulting with the service provider to test and adjust the relevant system configurations.

2.10) Inadequate Retention of Change Request and UAT Approval Evidence

Based on a sample review of 20 items, the following issues were identified: No evidence of Change requests and approvals from business unit users was found for 9 items. No evidence of UAT results or testing confirmation from users was found for 3 items.

However, for all sampled items, documentation of requests and approvals for deploying the changes to the production environment by the Change Advisory Board (CAB) was available.

In the process of revision:

Action Plan:

Establish guidelines for program changes and the required documentation for each type of change, and communicate these requirements to the relevant business unit users.

The auditor provided observations related to internal control, specifically concerning general IT controls regarding program access and program modifications. However, these observations do not have a material impact on the audit plan or the financial reports presented.

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3159

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

The company established its Internal Audit Department in 2021, with Ms. Jariya Sangumram appointed as Head of Internal Audit. The company has also engaged KPMG Phoomchai Business Advisory Ltd. in 2021, 2022, and 2024 to serve as an external consultant responsible for auditing internal controls across key operational processes. Please see other details in Attachment 3 : Details of the Heads of the Internal Audit and Compliance Units

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

The appointment, removal, and transfer of the Head of Internal Audit must be approved by the Audit Committee.

Related Party Transactions

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1000000

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
PTG Energy Public Company Limited (“PTG”)Juristic Person• Wholesale oil business for service stations under the “PT” brand, managed by the subsidiaries within the PTG Group. • Wholesale of fuel oil to: - Oil distributors within the PTG Group for sale at fuel stations - Other fuel traders - Industrial operators requiring fuel oil for business operations

• PTG is the major shareholder of the Company, holding 70.50% of the shares.

2025-12-31T00:00
Petroleum Thai Corporation Company Limited (“PTC”)Juristic Person• Fuel trader under Section 11 • Convenience store business at service stations

• PTC and the Company have a common major shareholder, PTG, with PTG holding 100.00% of PTC shares.

• PTC has director in common with the Company, Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul.

2025-12-31T00:00
PTG Logistics Company Limited (“PTGLG”)Juristic Person• Engaged in domestic transportation, consist of the transfer of fuel oil, LPG, petroleum products, and others.

• PTGLG and the Company have a common major shareholder, PTG, with PTG holding 100.00% of PTGLG shares.

• PTGLG has a director in common with the Company, Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul.

2025-12-31T00:00
Ama Marine Public Company Limited (“AMA”)Juristic Person• Engaged in maritime transportation services for liquid cargo via tanker ships and land transportation for liquid cargo via tanker trucks.

• AMA is an associate company of PTGLG, with PTGLG holding 24.00% of AMA shares, and PTGLG is a subsidiary of PTG, which is the major shareholder of the Company.

• AMA has Mr. Chusak Pooshutvanitshakul as a director, and Mr. Chusak Pooshutvanitshakul is the spouse of Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul, a director of the Company.

• AMA has Mr. Pisan Ratchakitprakarn as an executive and director, and Mr. Pisan Ratchakitprakarn is the younger brother of Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul, a director of the Company.

2025-12-31T00:00
Empire Service Solution Company Limited (“ESS”)Juristic Person• Engaged in the management and administration of equipment and machinery, as well as providing programs, instructions, and software related to these businesses.

• ESS and the Company have a common major shareholder, PTG, with holding 80.00% of ESS shares.

• ESS has a director in common with the Company, Ms. Watcharavee Chandraprakaikul.

2025-12-31T00:00
Innoligent Automation Company Limited (“INA”)Juristic Person• Engaged in the management of fuel dispenser control systems.

• INA and the Company have a common major shareholder, PTG, with holding 60.00% of INA shares.

2025-12-31T00:00
Punthai Coffee Company Limited (“PUN”)Juristic Person• Engaged in the sale of coffee, tea, beverages, and food under the “Punthai Coffee” brand.

• PUN and the Company have a common major shareholder, PTG, with holding 100.00% of PUN shares.

• PUN has a director in common with the Company, Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul.

2025-12-31T00:00
Siam Autobacs Company Limited (“SAB”)Juristic Person• Engaged in automotive service centers under the “Autobacs” brand.

• SAB and the Company have a common major shareholder, PTG, with holding 76.52% of SAB shares.

2025-12-31T00:00
Max Solution Service Company Limited (“MSS”)Juristic Person• Engaged in supporting issuers and receivers of electronic cards.

• MSS and the Company have a common major shareholder, PTG, with holding 99.96% of MSS shares.

2025-12-31T00:00
Max Card Company Limited (“MAX”)Juristic Person• Engaged in electronic financial services (E-Money), electronic money transfer (E-Money Transfer), payment facilitation services (Payment Facilitating), and bill payment services.

• MAX and the Company have a common major shareholder, PTG, with holding 100.00% of MAX shares.

2025-12-31T00:00
Jitramas Company Limited (“JTC”)Juristic Person• Engaged in the development of products for healthcare.

• JTC is a subsidiary of Alpine Oil Company Limited (“APO”), APO holds 100.00% of JTC shares. APO is a subsidiary of PTG, which is a major shareholder of the Company, and APO has a director in common with the Company, Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul.

• JTC has a director in common with the Company, Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul.

2025-12-31T00:00
PPP Green Complex Public Company Limited (“PPPGC”)Juristic Person• Engaged in palm oil extraction business, producing and selling crude palm oil, as well as producing latex concentrate, processed latex, and biomass power plants (Bio-gas) from palm oil production and latex processing waste.

• PPPGC and the Company have a common major shareholder, PTG, with holding 40.00% of PPPGC shares.

• PPPGC has one director in common with the Company, Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul.

2025-12-31T00:00
Max Me Corp Company Limited (“MMC”)Juristic Person• Engaged in electronic financial services (E-Money), electronic money transfer (E-Money Transfer), payment facilitation services (Payment Facilitating), and bill payment service.

• MMC and the Company have a common major shareholder, PTG, with holding 99.97% of MMC shares.

• MMC has a director in common with the Company, Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul.

2025-12-31T00:00
Tunchad Civil Company Limited (“TUNCHAD”)Juristic Person• Engaged in construction contracting business.

• TUNCHAD has Mr. Thanakrit Ratchakitprakarn as a director and major shareholder, holding 99.94%, brother of Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul, a director of the Company.

2025-12-31T00:00
PTG Green Energy Company Limited (“PGE”)Juristic Person• Fuel wholesaler under Section 10 • Engaged in the production and/or sale of renewable energy.

• PGE and the Company have a common major shareholder, PTG, with holding 100.00% of PGE shares.

• PGE has a director in common with the Company, Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul.

2025-12-31T00:00
Max Ventures Company Limited (“MVT”)Juristic Person• Engaged in investing in startups such as Sathanee-Nieowgai and Nexx Pharma.

• MVT is a subsidiary of PGE, where PGE holds 100.00% of MVT shares, and PGE is a subsidiary of PTG.

• MVT has a director in common with the Company, Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul.

2025-12-31T00:00
Threesixty Supply Chain Company Limited (“TSC”)Juristic Person• Engaged in managing transportation and storage facilities.

• TSC is a joint venture of MVT, with holding 20.00% of TSC shares, and MVT is a subsidiary of PGE, which is a subsidiary of PTG.

2025-12-31T00:00
GFA Corporation (Thailand) Company Limited (“GFA”)Juristic Person• Engaged in the sale of food and beverages.

• GFA is a subsidiary of PUN, with holding 99.99% of GFA shares, and PUN is a subsidiary of PTG.

• GFA has a director in common with the Company, Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul.

2025-12-31T00:00
BPTG Company Limited (“BPTG”)Juristic Person• Fuel trader under Section 11

• BPTG and the Company have a common major shareholder, PTG, with holding 60.00% of BPTG shares.

• BPTG has a director in common with the Company, Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul, and has one director in common with the Company's subsidiaries, Mr. Aek Apirakthanakorn.

2025-12-31T00:00
Maxbit Digital Asset Company Limited (“MAXBIT”)Juristic Person• Engaged in cryptocurrency exchange, digital asset trading, and foreign exchange trading.

• MAXBIT and the Company have a common major shareholder, PTG, with holding 35.00% of MAXBIT shares.

2025-12-31T00:00
Goluck Company Limited (“GL”)Juristic Person• Engaged in business of franchise management, including coffee, food, bakery, and beverage shops.

• GL is a subsidiary of GFA, with holding 70.00% of GL shares, and GFA is a subsidiary of PUN, which is a subsidiary of PTG.

• GL has a director in common with the Company, Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul.

2025-12-31T00:00
Go Subway Company Limited (“GS”)Juristic Person• Engaged in business of franchise management, leasing products with intellectual property assets, and similar products excluding copyrighted work.

• GS is a subsidiary of GL, with holding 99.80% of GS shares, and GL is a subsidiary of GFA, with GFA is a subsidiary of PUN, which is a subsidiary of PTG.

• GS has a director in common with the Company, Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul.

2025-12-31T00:00
Whole Gain Company Limited (“WG”)Juristic Person• Engaged in the business of manufacturing and distributing food products, bakery items, pastries, and other related products.

• WG is a subsidiary of JTC, with holding 55.00% of WG. JTC is a subsidiary of APO, and APO is a subsidiary of PTG.

2025-12-31T00:00
Max Alphabet Company Limited (“MAC”)Juristic Person• Engaging in the business of management and maintenance of information technology infrastructure via computer, internet, and electronic systems.

• MAC is a subsidiary of MMC, with holding 60.00% of MAC, and MMC is a subsidiary of PTG.

2025-12-31T00:00
Punthai Boat Noodle Company Limited (“PBN”)Juristic Person• Engaging in the restaurant business serving noodle dishes as the main menu.

• PBN is a subsidiary of PUN, which PUN holds a 80.00% stake, and PUN is a subsidiary of PTG.

• PBN has a director in common with the Company, Mrs. Sukwasa Pooshutvanitshakul.

2025-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
0.01 · Necessity: - The Group and PTG Group have agreed to offer employee benefits, including discounts for purchasing products and services from both groups. Each party is responsible for the actual expenses incurred by their employees on a monthly basis. - When determining the discount for employees, the Company considers the benefits employees will receive and the appropriateness of the discount. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from oil sales arising from employee benefits. - According to the agreement, each company is responsible for the discount based on employee usage. The prices of products and services sold by the Group to PTG Group employees will be the same as those sold to the general public. The Company group is only responsible for welfare expenses corresponding to discounts used by its own employees. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from the discounted on the retail prices of LPG and oil arising from LPG and oil refueling by employees of PTG group at OLP's service stations, which PTG Group is responsible for reimbursing OLP for these discounted amounts. · As of yesteryear: 0.08 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations) · Audit committee opinion: - After consideration, the Audit Committee believes that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Company group. Offering discounts to employees is a common form of employee welfare that most companies provide. It enables employees to purchase quality products and services at a price lower than that available to the public, and also fostering a sense of pride in the Company they work for. Additionally, since each company is responsible for the discount based on its employees' usage, the employee welfare costs reflect the extent of benefits provided within each company. As a result, this transaction is similar to dealings with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.13 · - OLP has agreed to allow vehicle users refueling with LPG and oil at its service stations to pay using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, both managed by PTC. This arrangement increases OLP’s sales opportunities, while PTC, as the card program operator, is responsible for collecting payments from cardholders and remitting the proceeds to OLP. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - Moreover, the Company sells LPG to PTGLG for its business operations, specifically for testing the gas tanks of transportation truck. The Company also sells cooking gas to WG, PUN, and PBN. - OLP sells LPG and oil to Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card holders at service station prices, which are the same rates offered to the general public. Moreover, the terms and conditions for accepting payments via these cards, as agreed between OLP and PTC, are consistent with those between PTG’s fuel service station dealers and PTC. - LPG prices at which the Group supplies PTGLG are in line with those charged to other customers. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from fuel purchases made by vehicles within the PTG Group at OLP’s service stations, with payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - The Company also reconised revenue from the sale of LPG products supplied to PTGLG, WG, PUN, and PBN for operational purposes. · As of yesteryear: 0.93 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and LPG Wholesale) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Accepting payments via the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card is consistent with normal business practices, whereby sellers provide multiple convenient payment options to customers. Additionally, the sale of LPG to PTGLG and sale of cooking gas to WG, PUN, PBN for internal operations are part of the Company’s ordinary course of business. The payment terms for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as well as the LPG pricing, are comparable to those offered to unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.91 · 8.71 · Necessity: - As part of its participation of the PT Max Card membership program, the Group has agreed to allow PT Max Card and PT Max Plus members to earn reward points when purchasing products from the Group. Members may redeem these points for discounts on Group products including exclusive promotions offered through the PT Max Card program. - The Group is responsible for funding the reward points earned by members who purchase its products. Conversely, the Group receives reimbursement for points redeemed and discounts used by members. These transactions are managed through PTG Group companies that oversee the loyalty program. (PTC performed this role until June 2021, followed by MAX from July 2021 to September 2022, and MMC from October 2022 onward.) - In addition, the Group receives compensation related to discounts and added benefits offered to card members from PTG Group companies that own the membership cards and oversee member privileges. (PTG served as the card issuer until June 2021, after which MAX assumed the role from July 2021 to September 2022, and MMC from October 2022 onward. Responsibility for managing additional member benefits rested with PTG until April 2021, then transferred to MSS from May 2021 onward. PTG further appointed MAX to manage these benefits from July 2021 to September 2022, followed by MMC from October to December 2022.) - Participation in the PT Max Card system enables the Group to expand its customer base by accessing cardholders who are already familiar with and loyal to the “PT” brand. It also allows the Group to leverage an existing membership platform for marketing and promotional activities without the need to invest in or manage the membership system internally. - The value of reward points provided to members of the Group (which the Group pays to the point system administrator) is equal to the value of points redeemed as discounts (which the administrator reimburses to the Group). For any additional benefits offered to members, the entity authorising those benefits is fully responsible for covering the related costs. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from fuel sales related to membership discounts and benefits. - The terms under which the Group participates in the Max Card program are aligned with the standard agreements PTG Group has in place with its petroleum dealers operating service stations. · Description: - The Group recognises revenue from sales through product discounts offered to loyalty card members, with PTC and/or MAX and/or MMC acting as program administrators. - Additional revenue is generated from value-added benefits provided to loyalty card members under programs managed by PTG and/or MSS. The Company charges the corresponding value of these benefits to PTC and/or MAX, as well as PTG and/or MSS and/or MMC, respectively. · As of yesteryear: 7.8 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and Gas shops) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. Participating in a loyalty program managed by a third party is a common and effective business strategy. It supports the Group’s marketing efforts by encouraging customer retention and repeat purchases. Furthermore, the participation terms are consistent with those applied to third-party petroleum dealers within the PTG network. As such, the nature of this transaction is comparable to transactions made with unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 3.52 · 0.88 · Necessity: - In November 2021, the Company launched its own line of gas catridge products, made available at its service stations and cooking gas retail outlets. This initiative was aimed at expanding the Company’s product portfolio and enhancing overall profitability. - To further broaden distribution channels, the Company began wholesale sales of gas catridge to third parties. This includes supplying the PTG Group for resale through its fuel service stations, Max Mart convenience stores, and Punthai Coffee outlets, as well as through PTG’s network of petroleum product dealers operating service stations. - The pricing and commercial terms offered to the PTG Group for these gas catridge products are determined using the same principles and methodology applied to third-party customers. · Description: - The Company recognised revenue through the sale of gas catridge to various entities within the PTG Group, including: • PTG distributes gas catridge to its network of dealers. • PTC distributes gas catridge at service stations and Max Mart convenience stores. • PUN distributes gas catridge at Punthai Coffee shops. • BPTG distributes gas catridge through its service station network. · As of yesteryear: 0.27 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - gas catridge · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and concluded that it is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The sale of gas catridge products helps generate additional revenue, while the pricing and commercial terms are aligned with those offered to external customers. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.28 · 1.44 · Necessity: - Certain OLP service stations have large advertising billboards installed within their premises. To optimize the use of these assets, OLP has leased the billboard to PTG. - This arrangement enables OLP to maximize the value of its existing service station properties by generating additional revenue beyond its core LPG sales operations. - The rental rates and terms for the billboard leases are in line with market prices, and comparable to those PTG has agreed upon with other advertising service providers. · Description: - OLP recognised income by leasing billboard advertising located within its service stations to PTG · As of yesteryear: 1.44 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from assets for lease and other services · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and concluded that it is appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. The lease of billboard provides OLP with an incremental income stream. Additionally, the rental rates and terms are consistent with those available in the open market. Therefore, the transaction is considered to be conducted on an arm’s-length basis and comparable to a transaction with an independent third party. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.44 · 190.89 · Necessity: - From “The We Will Get Through This Together” “Taxi Fights COVID” campaign is an initiative aimed at alleviating the financial burden on taxi drivers. As part of the program, participating drivers agree to display public awareness messaging on COVID-19 prevention, along with advertisements, both inside and outside their taxis. In return, each driver receives an E-voucher valued at Baht 1,200 and discount coupons totaling Baht 1,800 sponsored by OLP. The e-vouchers can be redeemed for fuel or LPG at PT service stations, or used to purchase products and services within the PTG Group network. The discount coupons are specifically designated for LPG refueling at PT service stations. - As part of the arrangement, the PTG Group leases advertising on the participating taxis to promote the PT brand and products within the PTG Group portfolio. OLP bears the cost of redemptions made through the e-vouchers and discount coupons used by participating drivers. - The advertising rental rates and conditions agreed upon with OLP are aligned with prevailing market rates offered by other advertising service providers. · Description: - OLP recognised the revenue by leasing advertising space on taxis participating in its program to companies within the PTG Group. · As of yesteryear: 151.87 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from assets for lease and other services · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. The leasing of advertising space on taxis forms part of a Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) initiative that not only supports the taxi driver community but also enhances the Company’s public image. Additionally, it serves to increase awareness and familiarity among drivers with the Company’s LPG service stations. Furthermore, by allowing the PTG Group to lease advertising space on participating taxis for brand awareness campaigns and the promotion of PTG Group’s products and services, the Company is able to maximize the value and utility of available advertising assets. The rental rates and terms for advertising space on taxis under this program are comparable to prevailing market rates offered by other advertising providers. Therefore, the transaction is considered to be conducted on an arm’s-length basis and comparable to a transaction with an independent third party. · As of year before yesteryear: 176.57 · 0.7 · Necessity: - PTG Group currently offers a diverse range of products under the PT brand, including fuel and LPG sold through PT service stations, PT Maxnitron, PT drink water, and PT LPG cylinders. Strengthening brand awareness among a wider consumer base will enhance the overall value of the PT brand, thereby enabling PTG Group to expand its portfolio of PT-branded products more effectively. - To support this objective, PTG has partnered with the Company in a co-marketing campaign aimed at encouraging household consumers who currently use non-PT branded LPG cylinders to become familiar with, and ultimately switch to, PT-branded LPG cylinders. - This joint marketing effort enhances brand visibility and equity for PT, while allowing the Company to maintain revenue levels comparable to those generated from its regular LPG cylinder sales. · Description: - The Company recognised amortised maintenance services for cylinder, which results from joint marketing initiatives aimed at enhancing PT brand awareness among household consumers. · As of yesteryear: 0.7 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from assets for lease and other services - amortised from maintenance services for cylinder · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Strengthening the PT brand’s recognition and equity contributes positively to the marketability of both current and future PT-branded products, including the Company’s PT-branded LPG cylinders. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.7 · 68.32 · Necessity: - OLP sells lubricant at its service stations to ensure the availability of related and essential automotive products for customers. However, engine oil sales are not OLP’s core business focus. At present, OLP exclusively offers PT Maxnitron lubricant and, therefore, procures the product from PTG, which manages delivery to OLP-operated service stations based on order quantities. - In the past, OLP also purchased a specific model of PT Maxnitron lubricant from PTC. This particular model is designed for vehicles that run on gas, which does not align with PTC’s primary customer base. As a result, PTC planned to discontinue the product, and the Group acquired the remaining inventory from PTC. - The purchase price and terms offered by PTG to OLP are comparable to those extended to PTG’s authorised petroleum product distributors operating service stations. The lubricant purchased from PTC was acquired at a discounted rate, consistent with common commercial practices used by suppliers to clear excess or slow-moving inventory. · Description: - OLP purchases PT Maxnitron lubricant for resale at service stations managed by OLP. OLP orders the lubricant from PTG and PTC, with PTG and PTC responsible for delivering the lubricant to the stations according to the purchase order. · As of yesteryear: 60.39 · Nature of transaction: Cost of goods sold - Lubricant · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transactions and is of the opinion that they are appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. The sale of lubricant at OLP service stations helps ensure that essential automotive products are available to meet customer needs. The purchase prices and conditions from PTG are consistent with those offered to independent petroleum distributors, indicating that the transactions were conducted on an arm’s-length basis. The discounted purchase from PTC aligns with standard commercial practices for inventory clearance and does not raise concerns regarding fairness or transparency. As of now, the Group no longer engages in similar transactions with PTC. · As of year before yesteryear: 45.51 · 17.33 · Necessity: - The Group distributes palm oil, purchased from PPPGC and PTG, to restaurant customers and service station patrons. This is to fulfill the needs of the Group’s customer base, specifically: the restaurant segment, which requires both gas cylinder and palm oil for business operations; and the service station customer segment, which requires palm oil for household cooking. - The purchase prices and terms offered to the Group by PPPGC and PTG are consistent with those provided to other customers. · Description: - The Group purchases palm oil from PPPGC and PTG for resale to restaurant customers and customers utilising the services at OLP’s service stations. · As of yesteryear: 18.44 · Nature of transaction: Cost of goods sold - palm oil · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transactions and considers them appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The sale of palm oil contributes to the Group’s revenue generation. Importantly, the purchase prices and conditions offered by PPPGC and PTG are equivalent to those extended to their other customers. · 17.71 · Necessity: - OLP is reliant on PTG for warehouse services, as it does not operate its own depots. This is primarily due to OLP’s lack of expertise in managing oil depots, combined with the fact that building and operating such facilities requires significant capital investment and a high utilisation rate to achieve cost efficiency. PTG, on the other hand, operates a well-established network of oil depots across all regions of Thailand, which greatly enhances the efficiency of fuel transportation and distribution to OLP’s service stations. - Additionally, the Group has engaged PTG to perform certain operational functions on an outsourced basis. This arrangement was made because the Group currently lacks sufficient expertise in those areas, while PTG has extensive experience and operational capabilities, having performed such functions for many years. Given the similarities between PTG’s business and that of the Group, PTG’s processes can be readily adapted to support the Group’s operations. Furthermore, outsourcing these functions to PTG is more cost-effective than establishing and managing them internally. - The service fees for warehouse and outsourced operational activities were mutually agreed upon by the Group and PTG. These fees are determined based on a cost-plus-margin pricing model, with the applied margin falling within a range deemed appropriate by the Group’s legal advisor on transfer pricing matters. - The Group utilises the “PT” brand for the distribution of its products, including PT service stations and PT-branded bottled LPG. Accordingly, the Group pays a brand usage fee to PTG. This fee is calculated based on the revenue generated from the sale of PT-branded products and is determined using a cost-plus-margin approach. The margin applied falls within the range deemed appropriate by the Group’s legal advisor on transfer pricing matters. - In connection with the purchase of PT Maxnitron lubricant, OLP pays PTG operational and delivery fees based on the monthly order volume. These fees are consistent with those PTG charges to other customers for similar services. - The Company engages PTG to transport gas cartridges to various distribution points, such as service stations and gas shops. This is because the Company already utilises PTG’s services for the transportation of other goods and equipment from the Distribution Center (DC) to various distribution points. The operational and delivery fees charged by PTG for this service are comparable to those charged to its other customers. - However, following the change in the business model to granting fuel distribution rights and providing management services for fuel distribution operations within service stations, OLP will no longer utilise fuel storage and quality inspection services. Furthermore, there will be no additional brand usage fees arising from fuel sales in the future. · Description: - OLP uses PTG’s oil services at PTG’s oil depot for reserves to be sold at OLP’s service stations. - The Company also outsources certain operations to PTG in areas where the Group lacks expertise (such as oil quality inspection, internal auditing, and information technology). - The Company pays PTG for the use of the PT brand according to the sales of PT-branded products. - OLP is required to pay for the operational costs and delivery charges for lubricant purchased from PTG. - In addition, the Company utilises transportation services from PTG to deliver gas cartridges to various distribution points, such as service stations and gas shops. · As of yesteryear: 34.55 · Nature of transaction: Service expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transactions and considers them appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Outsourcing to experienced third-party service providers for activities outside the Group’s core competencies is a standard business practice and supports operational efficiency. The service fees and conditions offered by PTG are aligned with those applied in comparable transactions with independent third parties, indicating that the arrangements were conducted on an arm’s-length basis. Furthermore, the use of the “PT” brand has accelerated consumer acceptance and strengthened product credibility in the market. The agreed brand usage fee is based on fair and supportable pricing principles, consistent with market-based practices. · As of year before yesteryear: 45.86 · - To ensure a unified standard of attire for employees working at service stations and gas shops operating under the "PT" brand, the Group has established a policy requiring all employees to wear uniforms that adhere to a single standard design. - Generally, OLP purchases employee uniforms directly from manufacturers. However, for certain types of uniforms (such as maternity dresses) or special sizes (e.g., extra-large or smaller than standard sizes), where the demand volume is relatively low unlike the PTG Group, which has a larger workforce and thus higher demand for all uniform types the Group is unable to purchase these specific items directly from manufacturers. Consequently, it is necessary for the Group to purchase such uniforms from PTC. - In this regard, the purchase price of uniforms from PTC is calculated based on cost plus administrative expenses to cover PTC's sourcing and operational costs. Such purchase price is considered comparable to the price at which OLP could source directly from the suppliers of said goods - Regarding employee welfare expenses arising from providing discounts on goods and services within the Group and the PTG Group, the transaction complies with a mutual agreement stipulating that each party shall be responsible for the actual discount amounts utilised by their respective employees on a monthly basis. - Additionally, a portion of employee welfare expenses arises from the purchase of food, beverages, and medical supplies for the Group’s employees. In this regard, the prices and commercial terms received by the Group from PTC, PUN, GS, and MVT are consistent with those PTC, PUN, GS, and MVT offer to other customers. · Description: - The Group incurs employee welfare expenses regarding the purchase of staff uniforms. - The Group also incurs employee welfare expenses arising from employees utilising discounts to purchase goods and services from the PTG Group. Consequently, the Group is required to reimburse the discount amounts to the PTG Group. - The Group incurs employee welfare expenses regarding the purchase of food and beverages for employees attending various training courses organized by the Company. - The Group also incurs employee expenses regarding the purchase of medical supplies for employees. · As of yesteryear: 1.92 · Nature of transaction: Employee Benefits Expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. This is because purchasing low-demand uniforms from PTC alleviates the Group’s burden of maintaining excess inventory. Furthermore, the purchase prices and conditions are comparable to those the Group would agree upon with suppliers. Therefore, the transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. - Additionally, providing discounts on goods and services is a standard form of employee welfare adopted by most companies. It enables employees to purchase quality goods and services at prices lower than the general public, while also fostering a sense of pride in the organization they work for. In this regard, the fact that each company assumes responsibility for the discount costs based on actual employee usage ensures that the welfare expenses of each entity accurately reflect the volume of benefits provided to its employees. Consequently, this transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. · - Previously, the Group utilised the Smart EDC system, which required the use of the Google API. However, MSS was the registered service provider, meaning the Group had to pay for the Google API usage through MSS. - Later, the Group transferred the rights to the Smart EDC system from MSS and directly registered the service. As a result, the Group became the direct payer of the service fees to the provider. The only exception is for the fees in January 2024, which are still in transition and being paid through PTG. - The Google API service fees paid by the Group to MSS and PTG are based on the amounts that MSS and PTG have paid to the service provider, proportionate to the Group's usage of the service. · Description: - The Group utilises Google API services on the Smart EDC system, and pays the service fees through MSS and PTG. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Service fees · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is both appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The Smart EDC system requires integration with the Google API to function effectively. The service fees paid by the Group to MSS and PTG are based on the fees that MSS and PTG have paid to the provider, in proportion to the Group’s usage. Therefore, this transaction is deemed comparable to transactions with external parties. · 3.34 · Necessity: - The Group commenced its LPG distribution business in Q4 of 2019, with OLP gradually acquiring assets necessary for operating LPG service stations, as well as combined LPG and fuel stations, from PTC from Q4 2019 through Q4 2020. This process required substantial capital investment. - Additionally, the Company initiated the distribution of LPG in cylinders to household users, which necessitated investment in LPG filling plants and gas cylinders, resulting in further significant capital expenditures. - During this period, the Company did not have credit facilities from financial institutions, making it essential to obtain both short-term and long-term loans from PTG to fund its investments and ongoing operations. - Currently, the Company has secured short-term loan facilities from financial institutions. For long-term financing, the Company borrows funds from financial institutions through PTG, which receives the loan from the financial institutions for the specific purpose of supporting the Company's business operations. The Company, in turn, borrows from PTG using these funds. - For loans obtained directly from PTG, the interest rates and loan terms provided to the Group are comparable to those that PTG receives from financial institutions. Similarly, for loans arranged by the Company through PTG with financial institutions, the interest rates and terms are comparable to those that PTG would receive from external lenders. · Description: - The Group pays interest expense on loans from PTG for both short-term and long-term. · As of yesteryear: 15.14 · Nature of transaction: Interest expenses to related party · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is beneficial to the Group. During the relevant period, the Group required significant capital to operate its business but was unable to obtain credit facilities from financial institutions. As a result, borrowing from PTG became necessary. The interest rates and loan terms that the Group received from PTG are in line with those typically offered by external financial institutions. · As of year before yesteryear: 25.13 · 0.0 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms regarding the discounts on LPG and fuel prices granted to PTG Group employees are comparable to those the Group extends to employees within the PTG Group. - However, following the change in the business model to granting the rights to distribute fuel and manage fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables resulting from fuel sales with employee discount benefits. · Description: - OLP has other receivables, part of which is accrued income from providing discounts on LPG and fuel sales to employees of PTG Group who refill and use their benefits at OLP service stations. PTG Group is required to reimburse OLP for these amounts. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Other Receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01 · 1.4 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for discounts arising from the redemption of PT Max Card points and the utilization of additional privileges granted by the PTG Group to PT Max Card members are comparable to those the PTG Group extends to its petroleum product dealers - However, following the change in the business model to granting rights for fuel distribution and managing fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables resulting from fuel sales with discounts and additional benefits for cardholders. · Description: - The Company has other receivables from accrued income arising from PT Max Card members redeeming accumulated points for discounts on product purchases and from providing benefits to PT Max Card members as part of the program managed by PT Max Card administrators. · As of yesteryear: 2.2 · Nature of transaction: Other receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and these commercial terms are consistent with those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.67 · - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for fuel sales to PTG Group vehicles utilising Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise cards are consistent with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. - The credit terms for outstanding receivables arising from the sale of fuel to PTG vehicles using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as provided by the Group to PTG, are similar to those established between PTG's petroleum product distributors at its gas stations and PTC, the card administrator. - However, following the change in the business model to granting rights for fuel distribution and managing fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables arising from fuel sales through the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. · Description: - OLP has trade receivables, part of which is accrued income from selling fuel to vehicles of PTG Group that refuel at OLP service stations using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.17 · 8.29 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the leasing of large billboards and advertising space on taxis, as agreed upon by OLP with PTG, are comparable to those the PTG Group receives from other providers of large billboards and taxi advertising space. · Description: - The Company also has other receivables arising from accrued income from renting out large billboard advertising area and advertising area on taxis to PTG Group. · As of yesteryear: 3.08 · Nature of transaction: Other receivables from related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.02 · 0.31 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of gas cylinder to PTC are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of LPG and Gas cartridges to the PTG Group are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. · Description: - The Company has trade receivables, which include outstanding revenues from the sale of LPG, bottled cooking gas, and gas cartridges, used in business operations and for retail purposes at cooking gas stores, fuel stations, Max Mart convenience stores, and Punthai Coffee Shop. · As of yesteryear: 0.04 · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 34.8 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of engine oil and PT Max Plus cards are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between OLP and the PTG Group. - The credit terms received by OLP from the PTG Group are similar to those offered by the PTG Group to other buyers. · Description: - OLP has trade payables, part of which consists of amounts due for the purchase of engine oil and PT Max Plus cards from PTG, intended for resale at OLP’s service stations and OLP reimbursing to PTG. · As of yesteryear: 7.62 · Nature of transaction: Trade payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.15 · 1.4 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from warehouse services with PTG, outsourcing PTG’s operations, the use of the PT brand, and the handling and delivery of lubricant purchased by OLP from PTG are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and PTG. - The credit terms received by the Group from PTG are similar to those PTG offers to other parties. · Description: - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the use of warehouse services with PTG, outsourcing operations to PTG, use of the PT brand, and the handling and delivery of lubricant purchased by OLP from PTG. · As of yesteryear: 1.35 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 2.1 · 1.65 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from the engagement of MSS and PTG to perform operations on an outsourcing basis are in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and MSS and PTG. - The credit terms received by the Group from MSS and PTG are comparable to those MSS and PTG extend to third parties. · Description: - The Group has a portion of other payables comprising accrued expenses arising from the engagement of MSS and PTG to carry out operations on an outsourcing basis. · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · 1.33 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of consumable materials used at the service stations, payment of utility expenses, transportation and communication costs on behalf of the Group, as well as the awarding of PT Max Card points to PT Max Card members purchasing products from the Group, the use of E-vouchers by participating taxis, fuel purchases and payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, and employee welfare discounts are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and PTG. - The credit terms received by the Group from PTG are similar to those offered by PTG to other parties under comparable conditions. · Description: - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the purchase of supply used at the service stations from PTC, as well as utility, transportation, and communication expenses. Moreover, there are expenses related to the PT Max points awarded when PT Max Card members purchase products from the Group, and expenses incurred from the use of E-vouchers for taxis participating in the “We will get through this together” “Taxi Fights COVID” program, which provide discounts for purchasing products or services from PTG - The Group also has other payables for fuel purchases and product payments made using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from employee discounts for purchasing products from PTG. · As of yesteryear: 5.37 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 3.85 · 0.03 · Necessity: - The Group will recognize accrued expenses from transactions that have occurred in the financial period but have not yet been invoiced by the service providers, in accordance with the Group's accounting policy. · Description: - The Group has accrued expenses, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet been invoiced by MSS, arising from the use of Google API services on the Smart EDC system. - Additionally, the Group has accrued expenses that have not yet been invoiced by PGE, arising from electricity usage at the service stations. - Furthermore, the Group has accrued expenses that have not yet been invoiced by PTG, arising from the transportation of gas catridge. - In addition, the Group has another portion of accrued expenses, which are unpaid charges from MMC related to the renewal fees for Max Card Plus. - In addition, the Group has another portion of accrued expenses comprising unbilled expenses from PTC, arising from electricity and water usage within service stations. · Nature of transaction: Accrued expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and believes that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group, as it is in line with the Group's accounting policies. Furthermore, the commercial terms are similar to those applied with external parties. · - In December 2023, the Company sold discount coupons for purchasing gas catridge to PTG as gifts for participants in PTG's seminar, with a total of 150 coupons, each valued at Baht 100. - The price of the discount coupon sold by the Company to PTG is equal to the discount value that the coupon holder can use when purchasing gas catridge from the Company. · Description: - The Company sells discount coupons for the purchase of gas catridge to PTG as gifts for participants in PTG’s seminar activities. · Nature of transaction: Advance revenue from gas cylinder sales · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and believes that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group, as the price of the discount coupon sold to PTG is equal to the discount value for purchasing gas catridge from the Company, making the net selling price of the gas catridge equivalent to the price sold to other customers. Therefore, this transaction is comparable to transactions with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01 · - The Group started its LPG business in the fourth quarter of the year ended 31 December 2019, with OLP gradually purchasing assets necessary for the operation of LPG service stations and oil and LPG stations from PTC during the fourth quarter of the year ended 31 December 2019 to the fourth quarter of the year ended 31 December 2020, requiring significant investment. - In addition, the Company started its business of selling gas cylinders to household LPG users, which required investment in LPG filling plants and gas cylinders, resulting in additional substantial investment. - However, during this period, the Company did not have any credit facilities from financial institutions, necessitating the borrowing of both short-term and long-term loans from PTG for investment and business operations. - Currently, the Company has secured short-term loans from financial institutions, and for long-term loans, the Company borrows funds from financial institutions through PTG, where the financial institutions grant credit to PTG with the specific purpose of investing in the Company's business. Therefore, the Company borrows funds from PTG using this facility. - As for the loans directly from PTG, the interest rate and loan terms the Group received from PTG are comparable to those PTG receives from financial institutions. Similarly, for the loans obtained from financial institutions via PTG, the interest rate and loan terms the Group received from PTG are comparable to those PTG receives from the financial institutions. · Description: - The Group has long-term loans from PTG to invest in fixed assets. The Group repays the long-term loans according to the principal repayment terms specified in the loan agreement. · As of yesteryear: 166.11 · Nature of transaction: Long-term loans from related party · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is beneficial to the Group, as the Company needed substantial capital during this period to operate the business but was unable to obtain credit facilities from financial institutions. Therefore, borrowing funds from PTG was necessary. The interest rate and loan terms the Group received from PTG are comparable to those that would have been applied to transactions with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 392.78 · 11.15 · Necessity: - Currently, the PTG Group markets a variety of products under the PT brand, such as the sale of fuel and LPG through PT service stations, PT Maxnitron lubricant, PT drink water, and PT gas cylinders. Increasing brand awareness of PT among household consumer base will enhance the value of the PT brand, allowing PTG to sell an even wider range of products under the PT brand. - PTG is therefore collaborating with the Company to create incentives for household consumers who currently use cooking gas cylinders from brands other than PT to recognise and switch to using PT-branded LPG gas cylinders. - This joint marketing effort with PTG helps increase recognition and brand value for PT, while the Company still maintains revenue levels comparable to its normal sales of gas cylinders. · Description: - The Company collects service fees for the maintenance of gas cylinders from PTG which arise from marketing efforts with the Company to increase brand awareness to household consumers. · As of yesteryear: 11.85 · Nature of transaction: Gas cylinder maintenance service fees · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Company. As the PT brand becomes more recognised and valuable, it will positively impact PT-branded products currently sold and in the future, including the Company's PT-branded gas cylinders. · As of year before yesteryear: 12.56 · 1341.0 · Necessity: - The guarantee of the credit line by the major shareholder to the financial institution is a standard condition for securing loans from financial institutions. - The financial institution has set a condition that it will consider releasing the shareholder guarantee after the Company is listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand (“SET”). However, the Company has already listed on the SET and the Company received the official letter from the financial institutions for releasing PTG from guarantor after the period ended 31 December 2025. · Description: - The Company has credit facilities with financial institutions, with PTG acting as the guarantor for the loan. · As of yesteryear: 1841.0 · Nature of transaction: Guarantee for short-term loans with financial institutions · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial for the Company. This guarantee by PTG is in accordance with the terms set by the financial institutions. It also enables the Group to access funding sources. Additionally, the Group does not incur any costs for providing this guarantee. Accordingly, the financial institutions have already released the shareholder's guarantee after the period ended 31 December 2025, the Company has already listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand. · As of year before yesteryear: 1520.0
0.02 · Necessity: - The Group and PTG Group have agreed to offer employee benefits, including discounts for purchasing products and services from both groups. Each party is responsible for the actual expenses incurred by their employees on a monthly basis. - When determining the discount for employees, the Company considers the benefits employees will receive and the appropriateness of the discount. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from oil sales arising from employee benefits. - According to the agreement, each company is responsible for the discount based on employee usage. The prices of products and services sold by the Group to PTG Group employees will be the same as those sold to the general public. The Company group is only responsible for welfare expenses corresponding to discounts used by its own employees. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from the discounted on the retail prices of LPG and oil arising from LPG and oil refueling by employees of PTG group at OLP's service stations, which PTG Group is responsible for reimbursing OLP for these discounted amounts. · As of yesteryear: 0.12 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations) · Audit committee opinion: - After consideration, the Audit Committee believes that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Company group. Offering discounts to employees is a common form of employee welfare that most companies provide. It enables employees to purchase quality products and services at a price lower than that available to the public, and also fostering a sense of pride in the Company they work for. Additionally, since each company is responsible for the discount based on its employees' usage, the employee welfare costs reflect the extent of benefits provided within each company. As a result, this transaction is similar to dealings with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.17 · - OLP has agreed to allow vehicle users refueling with LPG and oil at its service stations to pay using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, both managed by PTC. This arrangement increases OLP’s sales opportunities, while PTC, as the card program operator, is responsible for collecting payments from cardholders and remitting the proceeds to OLP. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - Moreover, the Company sells LPG to PTGLG for its business operations, specifically for testing the gas tanks of transportation truck. The Company also sells cooking gas to WG, PUN, and PBN. - OLP sells LPG and oil to Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card holders at service station prices, which are the same rates offered to the general public. Moreover, the terms and conditions for accepting payments via these cards, as agreed between OLP and PTC, are consistent with those between PTG’s fuel service station dealers and PTC. - LPG prices at which the Group supplies PTGLG are in line with those charged to other customers. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from fuel purchases made by vehicles within the PTG Group at OLP’s service stations, with payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - The Company also reconised revenue from the sale of LPG products supplied to PTGLG, WG, PUN, and PBN for operational purposes. · As of yesteryear: 0.14 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and LPG Wholesale) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Accepting payments via the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card is consistent with normal business practices, whereby sellers provide multiple convenient payment options to customers. Additionally, the sale of LPG to PTGLG and sale of cooking gas to WG, PUN, PBN for internal operations are part of the Company’s ordinary course of business. The payment terms for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as well as the LPG pricing, are comparable to those offered to unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.12 · 5.86 · Necessity: - For PTC’s service stations, the Company has opted not to lease space to operate its own gas shops, as it has assessed that the expected sales volume at those locations would be insufficient to justify the investment. - PTG has expressed interest in acting as a distributor of cooking gas products through small-scale gas shops (kiosks). These kiosks operate differently from the Company’s own gas shops. Specifically, PTC’s kiosks are setups with a limited number of gas cylinders on display, staffed by existing personnel at the service station (with no dedicated sales staff), and do not offer home delivery services (customers must collect and swap gas cylinders themselves). - Per the appointing to PTC as a distributor of cooking gas products through these kiosks allows the Company to increase its overall sales volume of gas cylinders. - The pricing and commercial terms for sales to PTC (including deposits and maintenance service fee for gas cylinders) are determined based on expected sales volume and the level of transported support the Company provides, such as delivering gas cylinders to PTC’s kiosks. These terms follow the same pricing principles and methodology used for other types of retail distributors. · Description: The Company sell cooking gas to small-scale retail gas shops (kiosk) operated under the management of PTC. · As of yesteryear: 4.01 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Kiosk) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Appointing PTC as a distributor of cooking gas through small-scale kiosks helps expand the Company’s revenue from bottled cooking gas sales and diversifies its distribution channels. Furthermore, the pricing and commercial terms applied are consistent with those offered to unrelated third-party distributors · As of year before yesteryear: 3.7 · - To clarity in its business operations, OLP restructured its operating model in June 2024 for service stations that offer both LPG and oil sales. Under this new model, OLP granted PTC the rights to distribute oil at these dual-purpose stations. As part of the arrangement, PTC is required to engage OLP to manage the oil sales operations on its behalf. Consequently, OLP sold the inventory stored in the reserve tanks at these stations to PTC as of the effective date of the business model transition. - However, this sale of oil inventory occurred solely as a result of the change in business model - from direct oil sales by OLP to a structure based on distribution rights and management services. Moving forward, OLP will no longer generate revenue from oil sales at these stations or from oil stored in reserve tanks. - The sale price of the oil was determined based on the average purchase cost incurred by OLP during the transition period. This pricing is in line with prevailing market rates and comparable to prices PTC would have obtained from other traders under Section 7 during the same period. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from the sale of fuel stored in reserve tanks at service stations, where OLP has granted PTC the distribution rights to sell the fuel. · As of yesteryear: 164.7 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and determined that it is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The revised business model provides greater operational clarity and eliminates the need for OLP to retain inventory of a product it no longer sells. The transaction also ensures uninterrupted operations for PTC. The sale price is benchmarked against market rates and is consistent with transactions conducted with unrelated third parties. · 10.79 · Necessity: - In November 2021, the Company launched its own line of gas catridge products, made available at its service stations and cooking gas retail outlets. This initiative was aimed at expanding the Company’s product portfolio and enhancing overall profitability. - To further broaden distribution channels, the Company began wholesale sales of gas catridge to third parties. This includes supplying the PTG Group for resale through its fuel service stations, Max Mart convenience stores, and Punthai Coffee outlets, as well as through PTG’s network of petroleum product dealers operating service stations. - The pricing and commercial terms offered to the PTG Group for these gas catridge products are determined using the same principles and methodology applied to third-party customers. · Description: - The Company recognised revenue through the sale of gas catridge to various entities within the PTG Group, including: • PTG distributes gas catridge to its network of dealers. • PTC distributes gas catridge at service stations and Max Mart convenience stores. • PUN distributes gas catridge at Punthai Coffee shops. • BPTG distributes gas catridge through its service station network. · As of yesteryear: 10.35 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - gas catridge · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and concluded that it is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The sale of gas catridge products helps generate additional revenue, while the pricing and commercial terms are aligned with those offered to external customers. · As of year before yesteryear: 8.07 · 41.25 · Necessity: - The leasing of commercial area within OLP’s service stations enhances OLP's revenue, allowing the Company to better utilize its existing assets at these locations. It also enables the service stations to better meet the needs of motorists. OLP provides the opportunity for the general public, including PTG Group, to lease commercial space within its service stations for business operations. - The rental rates and terms that OLP offers to PTG Group are identical to those provided to other tenants leasing commercial area in OLP’s service stations. Similarly, these rates and terms are consistent with those PTC offers to external parties leasing commercial space at PTC’s service stations. · Description: - OLP recognised the rental income from commercial areas within its service stations as follows: • PTC leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Max Mart convenience store). • PUN leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Punthai Coffee shop). • SAB leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Automotive service and maintenance center under the “Autobacs” brand). • PTGLG rents for truck parking and warehouse of medical oxygen cylinders at the Phutthabucha 4 service station. • GFA rents to operate a retail store and services within the service station (Coffee World shop). • GS rents to operate a retail store and services within the service station (food and beverage shop “Subway”). • PBN leases within service stations to operate retail shops for goods and services (Food and beverage shop “Punthai Boat Noodle”). - The revenue from assets for lease consisted of rental fee and service fees on commercial area ,as well as utilities charges. · As of yesteryear: 38.06 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from assets for lease and other services · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and determined that it is appropriate and beneficial for the Group. Leasing commercial space generates additional income for OLP and increases the opportunities for motorists to utilize the service stations. Furthermore, the rental rates and lease terms agreed upon between OLP and PTG Group are comparable to those offered to third-party tenants. · As of year before yesteryear: 37.49 · 1.99 · Necessity: - OLP entered into a lease agreement for a service station that was intended to operate as both an LPG and oil station. However, it was later discovered that due to legal restrictions, the station could not operate as an LPG service station (although it could still function as an oil station). To optimize the use of the asset, PTC subsequently subleased the station from OLP to use as an oil service station. - The sublease rental rate agreed between OLP and PTC is equivalent to the rate OLP originally agreed upon with the property owner. · Description: - OLP recognised income from sub-leasing land and building within its service stations to PTC. · As of yesteryear: 1.99 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from assets for lease and other services · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Since OLP’s core business focus is on operating LPG service stations, subleasing the station which is restricted to selling only oil to PTC helps reducing the burden of maintaining a non-income-generating asset. Moreover, the rental rate and lease conditions are comparable to those of a direct lease from the property owner. As such, the transaction is considered to be conducted on an arm’s-length basis, similar to a transaction with an external party. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.99 · 1131.88 · Necessity: - In June 2024, OLP implemented a change in its service station business model involving locations that include both LPG and oil retail components. Under the business changed, OLP granted PTC the rights to sell oil at service stations, with the condition that PTC must appoint OLP to manage the oil retail operations on its behalf. As a result, OLP recognised revenue from both the licensing of operating rights and the provision of oil retail management services, which are charged to PTC. With respect to inventory management, the agreement stipulates that any surplus resulting from operations will be reimbursed by PTC to OLP. Conversely, any shortage will be the responsibility of OLP. - Additionally, OLP assumed the operation of one service station transferred from PTC which comprises both NGV and oil sales. Previously, PTC operated the oil sales and managed the NGV sales on behalf of a Section 7 licensee. Following the transfer, OLP assumed the responsibility of managing the NGV segment on behalf of PTC. - The service fees and terms for managing the oil retail operations were jointly agreed between OLP and PTC, based on a cost-plus margin pricing model. The applied margin falls within the range deemed to reflect market conditions, as validated by a legal advisor specializing in transfer pricing. This ensures that the pricing structure complies with arm’s-length principles. - Similarly, the management fees and terms for operating the NGV station, as agreed between OLP and PTC, mirror those that PTC previously agreed upon with traders under Section 7 who originally engaged PTC to manage the station. · Description: - OLP recognised income from granting rights and providing management services for the oil management at service stations, with fees charged to PTC. - OLP also recognised income from providing management services for the NGV retail operations at service stations, with fees likewise charged to PTC. · As of yesteryear: 584.12 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from other services · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and deems it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Granting PTC the rights to sell oil, with the condition that PTC must appoint OLP to manage the oil retail operations at the relevant service stations, brings operational clarity to the Group’s business model. Importantly, the stations continue to offer both LPG and oil products, ensuring continued convenience and service continuity for motorists. Moreover, OLP’s management of NGV service operations alongside oil sales enhances the station’s value proposition by providing a broader range of petroleum products to better meet the needs of a diverse customer base. Managing the NGV operations also provides OLP with an opportunity to understand consumer behavior and demand related to NGV usage insights that could support the Company’s future business development in this segment. The fees received by OLP for licensing and management services are based on market pricing principles, ensuring the transaction is consistent with terms that would be offered to independent third parties. Similarly, the returns earned from managing the NGV station are comparable to those received directly from traders under Section 7. Therefore, the transaction is considered to be conducted on an arm’s-length basis and comparable to a transaction with an independent third party. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.7 · 0.27 · Necessity: - The Company requires all cooking gas product distributors who utilise its cooking gas cylinders for refilling and/or resale to place a deposit for the cylinders and to pay a cylinder maintenance service fee. Accordingly, PTC, which operates small-scale gas shops (kiosks) and is classified as one of the Company’s cooking gas product distributors, is subject to the same requirements namely, placing a cylinder deposit and paying the applicable maintenance service fee. The maintenance fee is recognised as revenue by the Company over the useful life of the cylinders, which is 20 years. - The pricing and commercial terms related to the sale of cylinders to PTC (including the deposit and maintenance service fee) are determined based on the volume of sales and the level of operational support required from the Company. This includes services such as the transportation of cylinders to PTC’s kiosks. The pricing methodology and commercial terms applied to PTC are consistent with those offered to other types of distributors, reflecting standard market practices. · Description: - The maintenance service of cylinders is charged by the Company to PTC, the Company amortised this maintenance service over a 20 year period, in line with the useful life of cylinders. · As of yesteryear: 0.24 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from amortised in maintenance service of cylinders · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. The collection of cylinder deposits and maintenance service fees from all categories of cooking gas product distributors allows the Company to ensure proper control over the usage and upkeep of its cooking gas cylinders. The deposit and maintenance fee the Company collects from PTC are consistent with those applied to external third-party distributors and reflect standard market practices. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.21 · - During the year ended 2023, OLP applied for an operating license for the use of solar panels at its Bangkapi 3 service station, where a solar energy system had already been installed. However, the majority of OLP’s service stations had not yet adopted solar panel systems. - To ensure efficient management and maintenance of solar equipment, and to establish a clear business structure, OLP entered into an agreement with PGE, a company specializing in solar power generation. Under the agreement, PGE would invest in the installation of solar panels across OLP’s service stations and sell the generated electricity directly to OLP. - Subsequently, in the year ended 2023, OLP transferred the operating license for the solar panels at the Bangkapi 3 station to PGE, assigning full responsibility for the operation and maintenance of the system to PGE. - In YE2024, the Boards of Directors of both the Company and PTG approved a business segregation plan to streamline the Group’s operational structure. As part of this plan, the PTG Group was designated to oversee the electric vehicle (EV) charging station business. Accordingly, OLP sold all EV charging-related assets located at its service stations to PTC, making PTC the designated EV charging station operator within the Group. - The transfer price of the solar panel operating license sold to PGE was based on OLP’s original acquisition cost. OLP recognised a gain on disposal equal to the difference between the sale price (equivalent to acquisition cost) and the net book value (NBV) after deducting accumulated depreciation. - The EV charging station-related assets sold by OLP to PTC were priced at their net book value (NBV) plus a 1% markup to cover associated administrative and operational costs. This pricing is consistent with the estimated cost that PTC would have incurred if it had acquired the assets independently. · Description: - OLP had gain on sales of an assets, an operating licenses for solar panel installation at the Bangkapi 3 service station to PGE. - OLP had gain on sales of an assets, related to the operation of the EV Charging Station located within OLP’s service stations to PTC. · As of yesteryear: 0.03 · Nature of transaction: Gain on sales of an assets · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transactions and is of the opinion that they are appropriate and in the best interests of the Group. The sale of the solar panel operating license to PGE, along with the transfer of EV charging station-related assets to PTC, serves to streamline the business structure between the Group and the PTG Group. These actions also alleviate the operational and maintenance burden on OLP with respect to solar panel equipment. Furthermore, the agreed sale prices for both the license and the EV-related assets are consistent with the costs that PGE and PTC would have incurred had they procured the assets independently. Therefore, the transactions are considered to be conducted on an arm’s-length basis and reflect terms that are fair and comparable to those that would apply in transactions with unrelated third parties. · - OLP sells lubricant at its service stations to ensure the availability of related and essential automotive products for customers. However, engine oil sales are not OLP’s core business focus. At present, OLP exclusively offers PT Maxnitron lubricant and, therefore, procures the product from PTG, which manages delivery to OLP-operated service stations based on order quantities. - In the past, OLP also purchased a specific model of PT Maxnitron lubricant from PTC. This particular model is designed for vehicles that run on gas, which does not align with PTC’s primary customer base. As a result, PTC planned to discontinue the product, and the Group acquired the remaining inventory from PTC. - The purchase price and terms offered by PTG to OLP are comparable to those extended to PTG’s authorised petroleum product distributors operating service stations. The lubricant purchased from PTC was acquired at a discounted rate, consistent with common commercial practices used by suppliers to clear excess or slow-moving inventory. · Description: - OLP purchases PT Maxnitron lubricant for resale at service stations managed by OLP. OLP orders the lubricant from PTG and PTC, with PTG and PTC responsible for delivering the lubricant to the stations according to the purchase order. · As of yesteryear: 0.16 · Nature of transaction: Cost of goods sold - Lubricant · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transactions and is of the opinion that they are appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. The sale of lubricant at OLP service stations helps ensure that essential automotive products are available to meet customer needs. The purchase prices and conditions from PTG are consistent with those offered to independent petroleum distributors, indicating that the transactions were conducted on an arm’s-length basis. The discounted purchase from PTC aligns with standard commercial practices for inventory clearance and does not raise concerns regarding fairness or transparency. As of now, the Group no longer engages in similar transactions with PTC. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.29 · 0.03 · Necessity: - Regarding the purchase of premium goods, such as Moto GP shirts and caps, the Company purchases these items from PTC for resale to customers exclusively at the NakhonChaiSi 11 service station, as this station is equipped with a designated product display area. - The purchase price from PTC is calculated based on cost. Such purchase price is considered comparable to the price at which OLP could source directly from the suppliers of said goods. · Description: - The Group purchases premium goods from PTC for sale to customers using service stations. · Nature of transaction: Cost of good sold - premium goods · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transactions and is of the opinion that they are appropriate and in the best interests of the Group. The engagement of PTGLG and AMA for oil transportation services was conducted under normal commercial terms. The service rates and conditions offered were comparable to those extended to OLP by independent third-party providers. · 15.41 · Necessity: - The Company has leased commercial area within PTC’s service stations to operate its gas shps. This strategic move enables the Company to quickly expand its sales channels and increase market reach. By locating its stores at PTC’s service stations frequented by customers who are already familiar with and loyal to the “PT” brand, the Company benefits from enhanced visibility and a greater opportunity to drive sales of gas cylinder. - The rental rates and terms offered by PTC are identical to those provided to other third-party tenants of its commercial areas. Additionally, these terms are consistent with the rates and conditions applied by OLP when leasing its own commercial areas to external parties. · Description: - The Company incurs rental expenses for leasing commercial area within PTC's service stations to operate its own gas shops. · As of yesteryear: 14.59 · Nature of transaction: Property rental expenses - gas shops · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and is of the opinion that it is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Leasing commercial areas within PTC’s service stations facilitates rapid market penetration by positioning the Company’s products in front of a customer base that already recognise and trusts the “PT” brand. The rental rates and lease conditions agreed upon with the PTG Group are in line with those offered to unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 14.44 · 213.0 · Necessity: - The majority of service stations transferred from PTC to OLP are located on properties where PTC holds lease agreements with third-party landowners. As a result, OLP must continue operations at these locations through sublease arrangements with PTC. However, PTC has no intention of renewing the lease agreements with the landowners upon their expiration. When those leases expire, OLP will enter into direct lease agreements with the respective property owners. - The sublease rental rates agreed between OLP and PTC are based on the rental rates PTC pays to the property owners, plus a 1% markup to cover administrative and related costs incurred by PTC. - Subsequently, OLP and PTC jointly reviewed the sublease arrangements to ensure fairness and appropriateness. As a result, the sublease rates have been gradually adjusted to reflect only the actual rental costs paid by PTC to the property owners, since these represent the primary expense associated with the leases. · Description: - OLP incurs expenses from leasing land and buildings at service stations that were transferred from PTC. · As of yesteryear: 218.42 · Nature of transaction: Property rental expenses - service stations · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and is of the opinion that it is appropriate and in the best interests of the Group. The subleasing of service stations from PTC ensures continued operations for OLP without disruption. Over time, the need for subleasing will diminish as existing leases expire and OLP transitions to direct lease agreements with the property owners. The rental rates and terms under the sublease agreements are comparable to those that would apply under direct lease arrangements with third-party property owners. · As of year before yesteryear: 220.52 · 4.41 · Necessity: - OLP follows a strategic policy of investing in service stations primarily through lease arrangements with existing property owners. This approach is intended to minimize upfront capital expenditure and provide greater flexibility in business operations. - The rental rates for land and buildings leased by OLP from PTC are within the same range as those of comparable service stations in nearby locations that PTC has leased directly from property owners. · Description: - OLP leases land and buildings directly from PTC at certain service stations (including direct land and buildings lease at “Chokchai 6” meanwhile sublease for land and direct lease for buildings at “Wangthonglang 3,” “Chiang Mai 7,” and “Wiang Pa Pao 5” stations). · As of yesteryear: 9.24 · Nature of transaction: Property rental expenses - service stations · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. OLP’s focus on leasing rather than owning service station properties supports its objective of maintaining operational agility and reducing investment burden. The rental rates and lease terms are consistent with those that would typically apply in direct lease agreements with third-party property owners. · As of year before yesteryear: 8.68 · 0.53 · Necessity: - To ensure a unified standard of attire for employees working at service stations and gas shops operating under the "PT" brand, the Group has established a policy requiring all employees to wear uniforms that adhere to a single standard design. - Generally, OLP purchases employee uniforms directly from manufacturers. However, for certain types of uniforms (such as maternity dresses) or special sizes (e.g., extra-large or smaller than standard sizes), where the demand volume is relatively low unlike the PTG Group, which has a larger workforce and thus higher demand for all uniform types the Group is unable to purchase these specific items directly from manufacturers. Consequently, it is necessary for the Group to purchase such uniforms from PTC. - In this regard, the purchase price of uniforms from PTC is calculated based on cost plus administrative expenses to cover PTC's sourcing and operational costs. Such purchase price is considered comparable to the price at which OLP could source directly from the suppliers of said goods - Regarding employee welfare expenses arising from providing discounts on goods and services within the Group and the PTG Group, the transaction complies with a mutual agreement stipulating that each party shall be responsible for the actual discount amounts utilised by their respective employees on a monthly basis. - Additionally, a portion of employee welfare expenses arises from the purchase of food, beverages, and medical supplies for the Group’s employees. In this regard, the prices and commercial terms received by the Group from PTC, PUN, GS, and MVT are consistent with those PTC, PUN, GS, and MVT offer to other customers. · Description: - The Group incurs employee welfare expenses regarding the purchase of staff uniforms. - The Group also incurs employee welfare expenses arising from employees utilising discounts to purchase goods and services from the PTG Group. Consequently, the Group is required to reimburse the discount amounts to the PTG Group. - The Group incurs employee welfare expenses regarding the purchase of food and beverages for employees attending various training courses organized by the Company. - The Group also incurs employee expenses regarding the purchase of medical supplies for employees. · As of yesteryear: 0.55 · Nature of transaction: Employee Benefits Expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. This is because purchasing low-demand uniforms from PTC alleviates the Group’s burden of maintaining excess inventory. Furthermore, the purchase prices and conditions are comparable to those the Group would agree upon with suppliers. Therefore, the transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. - Additionally, providing discounts on goods and services is a standard form of employee welfare adopted by most companies. It enables employees to purchase quality goods and services at prices lower than the general public, while also fostering a sense of pride in the organization they work for. In this regard, the fact that each company assumes responsibility for the discount costs based on actual employee usage ensures that the welfare expenses of each entity accurately reflect the volume of benefits provided to its employees. Consequently, this transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.23 · 5.1 · Necessity: - Leasing commercial areas within PTC service stations to operate the Company's gas shops allows the Company to rapidly and significantly expand its distribution channels. Furthermore, opening gas shops in PTC service stations, where visiting motorists are already aware of and loyal to the “PT” brand, increases opportunities for the sale of the Company's gas cylinder. - The rates for service fees for leasing commercial areas charged by PTC to the Company are the same rates that PTC charges to other parties leasing its commercial areas. Additionally, these rates and conditions are identical to those OLP offers to other parties leasing OLP’s commercial areas. · Description: - The Company incurs service fees arising from the lease of commercial areas within PTC’s service stations to operate its gas shops. · As of yesteryear: 1.87 · Nature of transaction: Other expenses - service fees for gas shops · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. This is because leasing commercial areas within PTC service stations enables the Company's products to rapidly reach a customer base that already recognise and accepts the “PT” brand. The rates for service fee arising from the lease of commercial areas, as agreed upon by the Company with the PTG Group, are comparable to transactions made with third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.77 · 1.13 · Necessity: - For the gas stations transferred to OLP from PTC, where the transfer of the electricity and water meter ownership from PTC to OLP is still pending, if the utility companies (electricity and water) bill PTC for these services, PTC must advance these costs and subsequently recover them from OLP. - However, in the second quarter of 2023, OLP successfully completed the transfer of the electricity and water meter registrations for all gas stations received from PTC. As a result, electricity and water bills will now be issued directly to OLP, and OLP will settle these payments directly with the utility companies. - The electricity and water charges that OLP pays to PTC are equal to the amounts that PTC has paid to the others. - For the gas shops leased from PTC, the Company pays electricity costs based on its consumption and the agreed-upon rates with PTC. The electricity rate OLP pays to PTC is the same as the rate PTC charges other commercial tenants using electricity. - Regarding the transport services for the gas shops located at PTC’s service stations, PTC is still required to pay for the services based on the LPG shop’s usage. The Company then reimburses PTC for these costs, as the postal service provider bills both the LPG shop's services and PTC’s own charges together. - Currently, the postal service provider bills the Company directly for the LPG shop’s transportation-related charges, except for the delivery of documents from the central office to the LPG shops, which PTC arranges on behalf of the Company. In this case, the Company reimburses PTC for the postage costs, equivalent to the amount PTC has paid to the postal service provider. · Description: - The Group incurs other expenses related to utilities and transportation at OLP’s service stations and the Company's gas shops, which the Group is required to reimburse to PTC. · As of yesteryear: 1.01 · Nature of transaction: Other expenses - utilities, transportation, and communication costs · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Specifically, payments for utility services at the gas stations on behalf of OLP are made only during the period when OLP is transferring the ownership of the electricity and water meters. Similarly, payments for transportation and communication services for the cooking gas retail outlets on behalf of the Company arise from the billing limitations of the service providers. The costs that the Group must reimburse to PTC are identical to the amounts PTC has paid to the service providers. As such, this transaction is comparable to those made with external parties. - Regarding electricity usage and payments for electricity at the gas shops to the commercial areas owners, this is a standard business practice. The electricity rates and payment terms are consistent with those applied to other commercial tenants. Therefore, this transaction is also similar to transactions conducted with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.09 · 19.39 · Necessity: - The Group requires employees who use company vehicles for work purposes to pay for fuel using a Corporate Card, as both the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card function similarly to Fleet Cards. These cards are primarily intended to control and monitor employees’ fuel usage in accordance with company policies. - Furthermore, since OLP has agreed to accept payment for products at its service stations via the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, employees using the Group's vehicles are able to refuel at OLP’s service stations. - The service fees and terms of use for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card agreed upon between the Group and PTC are the same as those offered to other users of these cards. · Description: - The Group incurs travel expenses arising from the Company’s vehicles refueling at PTC-operated service stations and paying for products using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. · As of yesteryear: 16.46 · Nature of transaction: Other expenses – travel expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and is of the opinion that it is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The use of the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, which are mainly intended for controlling employee fuel usage, is in line with normal business practices. These cards function similarly to Fleet Cards, which are commonly used for monitoring employee fuel consumption. - Moreover, the service fees and terms of use for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card are consistent with those applied to other users. Therefore, this transaction is considered to be on the same basis as transactions with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 11.94 · 8.51 · Necessity: - From “The We Will Get Through This Together” “Taxi Fights COVID” campaign is an initiative aimed at alleviating the financial burden on taxi drivers. As part of the program, participating drivers agree to display public awareness messaging on COVID-19 prevention, along with advertisements, both inside and outside their taxis. In return, each driver receives an E-voucher valued at Baht 1,200 and discount coupons totaling Baht 1,800 sponsored by OLP. The e-vouchers can be redeemed for fuel or LPG at PT service stations, or used to purchase products and services within the PTG Group network. The discount coupons are specifically designated for LPG refueling at PT service stations. - OLP is responsible for the costs incurred when the E-vouchers are used to purchase products or services at PTG’s retail outlets, including Punthai Coffee shops, Max Mart convenience stores, PTC serivce stations, and authorized petroleum product dealers at service stations. · Description: - OLP incurs other expenses from using E-vouchers for taxis participating in the “We will get through this together project” and “Taxi Fights COVID campaign”, allowing discounts for purchasing products or services at PTG stores. · As of yesteryear: 2.88 · Nature of transaction: Other expenses · Audit committee opinion: - After reviewing the matter, the Audit Committee concluded that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Providing E-vouchers to taxis participating in the “We Will Get Through This Together” “Taxi Fights COVID” campaign is a corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiative that helps enhance the Company’s public image. It also aids in raising awareness of the Company’s LPG service stations among taxi drivers. The expenses incurred by OLP from the use of E-vouchers for purchasing products or services from PTG outlets will be equal to the actual value of the E-vouchers used. · As of year before yesteryear: 4.19 · 0.01 · Necessity: - OLP has agreed to allow customers refueling with LPG or gasoline at OLP service stations to pay for products using the Max Enterprise card issued by MAX. This arrangement provides OLP with greater sales opportunities, as PTC will collect payments from Max Enterprise cardholders (specifically for Postpaid customers) and reimburse OLP. - Additionally, MAX, as the issuer of the Max Enterprise card, will collect payments from the cardholders and transfer the funds to OLP. - However, following the change in business operations to granting the rights to sell and manage fuel distribution at OLP service stations, OLP will no longer charge additional fees for customers paying for fuel with the Max Enterprise card in the future. - Both PTC and MAX charge a fee based on a percentage of the transaction amount, which is the same rate applied to petroleum product distributors at PTG’s fuel stations. · Description: - OLP pays fees for the use of the Max Enterprise Card to PTC and MAX for the sale of LPG and fuel at service stations to customers who pay for products using the Max Enterprise Card. · As of yesteryear: 0.17 · Nature of transaction: Other Financial Expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Accepting payments for products and services via the Max Enterprise card is a standard business practice, as it allows businesses to offer customers a variety of payment options for added convenience. Additionally, the fees associated with using the Max Enterprise card are consistent with those applied in similar transactions with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.18 · 0.0 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms regarding the discounts on LPG and fuel prices granted to PTG Group employees are comparable to those the Group extends to employees within the PTG Group. - However, following the change in the business model to granting the rights to distribute fuel and manage fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables resulting from fuel sales with employee discount benefits. · Description: - OLP has other receivables, part of which is accrued income from providing discounts on LPG and fuel sales to employees of PTG Group who refill and use their benefits at OLP service stations. PTG Group is required to reimburse OLP for these amounts. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Other Receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.02 · 0.93 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for discounts arising from the redemption of PT Max Card points and the utilization of additional privileges granted by the PTG Group to PT Max Card members are comparable to those the PTG Group extends to its petroleum product dealers - However, following the change in the business model to granting rights for fuel distribution and managing fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables resulting from fuel sales with discounts and additional benefits for cardholders. · Description: - The Company has other receivables from accrued income arising from PT Max Card members redeeming accumulated points for discounts on product purchases and from providing benefits to PT Max Card members as part of the program managed by PT Max Card administrators. · Nature of transaction: Other receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and these commercial terms are consistent with those applied to external parties. · 3.36 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. In this regard, the credit terms for the leasing of large billboards and advertising space on taxis, as agreed upon by OLP with PTG, are comparable to those the PTG Group receives from other providers of large billboards and taxi advertising area. · Description: - OLP has other receivables from accrued income arising from leasing commercial area, including water and electricity charges at OLP service stations. · As of yesteryear: 2.68 · Nature of transaction: Other receivables from related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 2.15 · 0.06 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. - The credit term for NGV service station management fees, as agreed upon by OLP with PTC, is equivalent to the term PTC agreed upon with the Section 7 fuel trader who engaged PTC to manage said NGV service stations. · Description: - OLP has another portion of other receivables comprising accrued income arising from service fees for the management of NGV service stations, which are due from PTC. · As of yesteryear: 0.07 · Nature of transaction: Other receivables from related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for fuel sales to PTG Group vehicles utilising Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise cards are consistent with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. - The credit terms for outstanding receivables arising from the sale of fuel to PTG vehicles using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as provided by the Group to PTG, are similar to those established between PTG's petroleum product distributors at its gas stations and PTC, the card administrator. - However, following the change in the business model to granting rights for fuel distribution and managing fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables arising from fuel sales through the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. · Description: - OLP has trade receivables, part of which is accrued income from selling fuel to vehicles of PTG Group that refuel at OLP service stations using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.03 · 0.0 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for fuel sales to PTG Group vehicles utilising Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise cards are consistent with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. - PTG The credit terms for outstanding receivables arising from the sale of fuel to PTG vehicles using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as provided by the Group to PTG, are similar to those established between PTG's petroleum product distributors at its gas stations and PTG. - However, after the business model transition to granting rights for fuel distribution and managing fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables from fuel sales made through the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. · Description: - OLP has trade receivables, part of which consists of accrued income from the sale of LPG and fuel to customers who paid using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, which is managed by PTC. - In addition, OLP has trade receivables, part of which consists of accrued income from the sale of LPG and fuel to customers who paid using the Max Enterprise Card issued by MAX. As the issuer of the Max Enterprise Card, MAX is responsible for collecting the payment from the Max Enterprise Cardholders and reimbursing OLP. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted. · As of year before yesteryear: 3.92 · 3.34 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of gas cylinder to PTC are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of LPG and Gas cartridges to the PTG Group are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. · Description: - The Company has trade receivables, which include outstanding revenues from the sale of LPG, bottled cooking gas, and gas cartridges, used in business operations and for retail purposes at cooking gas stores, fuel stations, Max Mart convenience stores, and Punthai Coffee Shop. · As of yesteryear: 2.01 · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted. · As of year before yesteryear: 2.88 · 65.95 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. - The credit terms for the remuneration for the granting of rights and management services, as agreed upon by OLP with PTC, are determined based on the operational processes associated with the management services required of OLP and PTC, which include the verification of data accuracy. · Description: - OLP has trade receivables that are not yet due, arising from remuneration for the granting of rights and management services for fuel distribution operations within service stations, which are due from PTC. · As of yesteryear: 57.8 · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted. · 43.67 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of consumable materials used at the service stations, payment of utility expenses, transportation and communication costs on behalf of the Group, as well as the awarding of PT Max Card points to PT Max Card members purchasing products from the Group, the use of E-vouchers by participating taxis, fuel purchases and payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, and employee welfare discounts are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and PTG. - The credit terms received by the Group from PTG are similar to those offered by PTG to other parties under comparable conditions. · Description: - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the purchase of supply used at the service stations from PTC, as well as utility, transportation, and communication expenses. Moreover, there are expenses related to the PT Max points awarded when PT Max Card members purchase products from the Group, and expenses incurred from the use of E-vouchers for taxis participating in the “We will get through this together” “Taxi Fights COVID” program, which provide discounts for purchasing products or services from PTG - The Group also has other payables for fuel purchases and product payments made using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from employee discounts for purchasing products from PTG. · As of yesteryear: 24.47 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.42 · 0.09 · Necessity: - The Group will recognize accrued expenses from transactions that have occurred in the financial period but have not yet been invoiced by the service providers, in accordance with the Group's accounting policy. · Description: - The Group has accrued expenses, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet been invoiced by MSS, arising from the use of Google API services on the Smart EDC system. - Additionally, the Group has accrued expenses that have not yet been invoiced by PGE, arising from electricity usage at the service stations. - Furthermore, the Group has accrued expenses that have not yet been invoiced by PTG, arising from the transportation of gas catridge. - In addition, the Group has another portion of accrued expenses, which are unpaid charges from MMC related to the renewal fees for Max Card Plus. - In addition, the Group has another portion of accrued expenses comprising unbilled expenses from PTC, arising from electricity and water usage within service stations. · Nature of transaction: Accrued expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and believes that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group, as it is in line with the Group's accounting policies. Furthermore, the commercial terms are similar to those applied with external parties. · 5.4 · Necessity: - The Company requires all LPG product distributors who use the Company’s gas cylinders for filling and/or distribution to deposit a cylinder deposit and pay for the maintenance services of the gas cylinders. Therefore, PTC, which operates small gas shops (Kiosks) and is considered one of the Company’s LPG product distributors, is also required to deposit the cylinder deposit and pay for the maintenance services of the gas cylinders to the Company. The service fees for the maintenance of the gas cylinders will be recognised as revenue over the cylinder’s useful life of 20 years. - The sale of LPG cylinders and the commercial terms (including the cylinder deposit and maintenance service fees) provided by the Company to PTC are determined based on the sales volume and the management services the Company is required to perform for PTC, such as the transportation of gas cylinders to PTC’s small gas shops (Kiosks). The pricing of the gas cylinders and these commercial terms are calculated in the same manner as those applied to other LPG product distributors, such as those operating other types of gas retail outlets. · Description: - The Company collects a gas cylinder deposit from PTC for the use of its gas cylinders, which are circulated for the sale of cooking gas in small kiosks at PTC's service stations. · As of yesteryear: 5.21 · Nature of transaction: Gas cylinder deposits · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and believes that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group, as charging the cylinder deposit and maintenance service fees from all LPG product distributors enables the Company to properly control the use and maintenance of the gas cylinders. Furthermore, the cylinder deposit and maintenance service fees collected from PTC are based on the same principles applied with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 5.1 · 5.0 · Necessity: - The Company requires all LPG product distributors who use the Company’s gas cylinders for filling and/or distribution to deposit a cylinder deposit and pay for the maintenance services of the gas cylinders. Therefore, PTC, which operates small gas shops (Kiosks) and is considered one of the Company’s LPG product distributors, is also required to deposit the cylinder deposit and pay for the maintenance services of the gas cylinders to the Company. The service fees for the maintenance of the gas cylinders will be recognised as revenue over the cylinder’s useful life of 20 years. - The sale of LPG cylinders and the commercial terms (including the cylinder deposit and maintenance service fees) provided by the Company to PTC are determined based on the sales volume and the management services the Company is required to perform for PTC, such as the transportation of gas cylinders to PTC’s small gas shops (Kiosks). The pricing of the gas cylinders and these commercial terms are calculated in the same manner as those applied to other LPG product distributors, such as those operating other types of gas retail outlets. · Description: - The Company also collects service fees for the maintenance of gas cylinders from PTC for the use of its gas cylinders, which are circulated for the sale of cooking gas in kiosks at PTC's service stations. · As of yesteryear: 4.6 · Nature of transaction: Gas cylinder maintenance service fees · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and believes that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group, as charging the cylinder deposit and maintenance service fees from all LPG product distributors enables the Company to properly control the use and maintenance of the gas cylinders. Furthermore, the cylinder deposit and maintenance service fees collected from PTC are based on the same principles applied with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 4.47 · 9.22 · Necessity: - OLP entered into an agreement to lease a service station, which sells both LPG and fuel, from the property owner. However, OLP later discovered that the station faced legal issues that prevented it from operating as an LPG service station (though it could still operate as a fuel service station). As a result, OLP decided to sublease the service station to PTC to reduce costs. The terms of this sublease are similar to those of the lease agreement OLP made with the property owner. · Description: - OLP has advance revenue from income derived from subleasing land and buildings at its service station to PTC. · As of yesteryear: 9.61 · Nature of transaction: Advance revenue – income from property rental and other services · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Company. Since OLP's primary focus is on operating an LPG service station, subleasing the service station, which can only sell fuel, to PTC helps reduce the cost burden of leasing a station that does not generate income. Furthermore, the rental rate and lease conditions are comparable to those of the direct lease from the property owner. Therefore, this transaction is consistent with agreements made with third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 10.0 · 266.18 · Necessity: - In the management agreement for the oil distribution at OLP's mixed stations, both parties have agreed that OLP will handle the collection of payments for fuel sales from customers on behalf of PTC. OLP is responsible for gathering these payments and ensuring the accuracy of the cash amounts that will be submitted to PTC. - The agreed-upon payment period for the funds collected from fuel sales is based on the operational requirements of both OLP and PTC, including the need to verify the accuracy of the data before the funds are transferred. · Description: - OLP has received cash from the sale of fuel at the oil distribution section of the mixed station managed on behalf of PTC. Under this management agreement, OLP is responsible for collecting payments on behalf of PTC, and OLP must gather and verify the accuracy of the amounts before remitting them to PTC. · As of yesteryear: 557.37 · Nature of transaction: Other current liabilities - cash received from oil management at service stations · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that this transaction is both appropriate and beneficial for the Company. The adjustment in the business operation structure provides greater clarity for the Company's operations. Assigning OLP the responsibility to collect fuel payment from customers on behalf of PTC, and establishing a reasonable timeline for submitting the funds-taking into account the necessary time for verifying accuracy-reflects a standard management practice.
0.02 · Necessity: - The Group and PTG Group have agreed to offer employee benefits, including discounts for purchasing products and services from both groups. Each party is responsible for the actual expenses incurred by their employees on a monthly basis. - When determining the discount for employees, the Company considers the benefits employees will receive and the appropriateness of the discount. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from oil sales arising from employee benefits. - According to the agreement, each company is responsible for the discount based on employee usage. The prices of products and services sold by the Group to PTG Group employees will be the same as those sold to the general public. The Company group is only responsible for welfare expenses corresponding to discounts used by its own employees. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from the discounted on the retail prices of LPG and oil arising from LPG and oil refueling by employees of PTG group at OLP's service stations, which PTG Group is responsible for reimbursing OLP for these discounted amounts. · As of yesteryear: 0.07 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations) · Audit committee opinion: - After consideration, the Audit Committee believes that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Company group. Offering discounts to employees is a common form of employee welfare that most companies provide. It enables employees to purchase quality products and services at a price lower than that available to the public, and also fostering a sense of pride in the Company they work for. Additionally, since each company is responsible for the discount based on its employees' usage, the employee welfare costs reflect the extent of benefits provided within each company. As a result, this transaction is similar to dealings with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.11 · 0.16 · Necessity: - OLP has agreed to allow vehicle users refueling with LPG and oil at its service stations to pay using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, both managed by PTC. This arrangement increases OLP’s sales opportunities, while PTC, as the card program operator, is responsible for collecting payments from cardholders and remitting the proceeds to OLP. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - Moreover, the Company sells LPG to PTGLG for its business operations, specifically for testing the gas tanks of transportation truck. The Company also sells cooking gas to WG, PUN, and PBN. - OLP sells LPG and oil to Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card holders at service station prices, which are the same rates offered to the general public. Moreover, the terms and conditions for accepting payments via these cards, as agreed between OLP and PTC, are consistent with those between PTG’s fuel service station dealers and PTC. - LPG prices at which the Group supplies PTGLG are in line with those charged to other customers. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from fuel purchases made by vehicles within the PTG Group at OLP’s service stations, with payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - The Company also reconised revenue from the sale of LPG products supplied to PTGLG, WG, PUN, and PBN for operational purposes. · As of yesteryear: 3.5 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and LPG Wholesale) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Accepting payments via the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card is consistent with normal business practices, whereby sellers provide multiple convenient payment options to customers. Additionally, the sale of LPG to PTGLG and sale of cooking gas to WG, PUN, PBN for internal operations are part of the Company’s ordinary course of business. The payment terms for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as well as the LPG pricing, are comparable to those offered to unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 6.63 · 0.31 · Necessity: - The leasing of commercial area within OLP’s service stations enhances OLP's revenue, allowing the Company to better utilize its existing assets at these locations. It also enables the service stations to better meet the needs of motorists. OLP provides the opportunity for the general public, including PTG Group, to lease commercial space within its service stations for business operations. - The rental rates and terms that OLP offers to PTG Group are identical to those provided to other tenants leasing commercial area in OLP’s service stations. Similarly, these rates and terms are consistent with those PTC offers to external parties leasing commercial space at PTC’s service stations. · Description: - OLP recognised the rental income from commercial areas within its service stations as follows: • PTC leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Max Mart convenience store). • PUN leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Punthai Coffee shop). • SAB leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Automotive service and maintenance center under the “Autobacs” brand). • PTGLG rents for truck parking and warehouse of medical oxygen cylinders at the Phutthabucha 4 service station. • GFA rents to operate a retail store and services within the service station (Coffee World shop). • GS rents to operate a retail store and services within the service station (food and beverage shop “Subway”). • PBN leases within service stations to operate retail shops for goods and services (Food and beverage shop “Punthai Boat Noodle”). - The revenue from assets for lease consisted of rental fee and service fees on commercial area ,as well as utilities charges. · As of yesteryear: 0.08 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from assets for lease and other services · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and determined that it is appropriate and beneficial for the Group. Leasing commercial space generates additional income for OLP and increases the opportunities for motorists to utilize the service stations. Furthermore, the rental rates and lease terms agreed upon between OLP and PTG Group are comparable to those offered to third-party tenants. · 0.02 · Necessity: - In the event that the Group incurs damages as a result of transportation services provided by PTGLG for example, damage to cooking gas cylinders during transit. The Group will seek compensation for such losses from the respective logistics providers. - The compensation charged is in accordance with the terms and conditions mutually agreed upon between the Group and each service provider. · Description: - The Group has other income from compensation collected from transportation service providers for damages incurred during transportation. · As of yesteryear: 0.14 · Nature of transaction: Other income · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and considers the arrangement to be appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. Transportation service providers have a duty to safeguard the goods entrusted to them throughout the delivery process. In cases where damage occurs during transit, it is appropriate that the service provider be held responsible. The compensation claimed by the Group is in line with the contractual terms and reflects standard commercial practice, under which logistics providers are liable for any damage arising from their services. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01 · - OLP currently does not own any oil transport trucks, as it lacks the expertise in fuel logistics and has no intention of investing in such assets. Given the availability of numerous qualified oil transport service providers, OLP has opted to outsource these services rather than manage transportation operations internally. - While there are many providers in the market, fuel transportation requires specialized knowledge, strict adherence to safety standards, and the capacity to accommodate OLP’s increasing delivery needs in line with business growth. The selection of PTGLG and AMA as transport service providers was based on their proven expertise and the scale of their fleets, which are well-suited to support OLP’s operational requirements. - However, following a shift in OLP’s business model transitioning to a licensing and station management arrangement OLP will no longer require oil transport services in the future. - The service fees and contractual terms offered by PTGLG and AMA were in line with those provided by other transport service providers engaged by OLP during the same period. · Description: - OLP uses transportation services from PTGLG and AMA to transport oil from refineries or designated oil receiving points to OLP’s service stations. · As of yesteryear: 50.86 · Nature of transaction: Cost of services – oil transportation · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transactions and is of the opinion that they are appropriate and in the best interests of the Group. The engagement of PTGLG and AMA for oil transportation services was conducted under normal commercial terms. The service rates and conditions offered were comparable to those extended to OLP by independent third-party providers. · As of year before yesteryear: 102.05 · 181.05 · Necessity: - The Company does not currently own LPG tank trucks or large-capacity vehicles for transporting LPG, as it lacks the necessary expertise in handling and transporting LPG products. As such, the Company has no intention of investing in its own LPG transport fleet. Given the availability of numerous qualified LPG transport providers in the market, the Company has opted to outsource transportation services rather than manage logistics internally. - Although many transport providers exist, the nature of cylinder and bulk LPG transportation requires service providers with specialised knowledge, the ability to meet stringent safety standards, and sufficient fleet capacity to support the Company’s growing operational needs. PTGLG was selected as the Company’s transport partner due to its proven expertise in LPG logistics and the scale of its fleet, which is capable of meeting the Company’s current and future delivery requirements. - The service rates and contractual terms offered by PTGLG are consistent with those provided by other LPG transport providers engaged by the Company during the same period. · Description: - The Company uses PTGLG, who provided the transportation services to deliver gas cylinders from the LPG filling plant to gas shops and delivery points for commercial customers. - The Company also uses PTGLG, who provided the transportation services to deliver LPG from the terminal to delivery points for customers. · As of yesteryear: 102.79 · Nature of transaction: Transporation charge - cylinder and bulk Transportation · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transactions and is of the opinion that they are appropriate and in the best interests of the Group. The engagement of PTGLG for the transportation of cylinder and bulk LPG constitutes a normal commercial arrangement. The service rates and terms offered are comparable to those extended by independent third-party providers. · As of year before yesteryear: 58.69 · 0.0 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms regarding the discounts on LPG and fuel prices granted to PTG Group employees are comparable to those the Group extends to employees within the PTG Group. - However, following the change in the business model to granting the rights to distribute fuel and manage fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables resulting from fuel sales with employee discount benefits. · Description: - OLP has other receivables, part of which is accrued income from providing discounts on LPG and fuel sales to employees of PTG Group who refill and use their benefits at OLP service stations. PTG Group is required to reimburse OLP for these amounts. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Other Receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01 · 0.02 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for discounts arising from the redemption of PT Max Card points and the utilization of additional privileges granted by the PTG Group to PT Max Card members are comparable to those the PTG Group extends to its petroleum product dealers - However, following the change in the business model to granting rights for fuel distribution and managing fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables resulting from fuel sales with discounts and additional benefits for cardholders. · Description: - The Company has other receivables from accrued income arising from PT Max Card members redeeming accumulated points for discounts on product purchases and from providing benefits to PT Max Card members as part of the program managed by PT Max Card administrators. · As of yesteryear: 0.14 · Nature of transaction: Other receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and these commercial terms are consistent with those applied to external parties. · - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for fuel sales to PTG Group vehicles utilising Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise cards are consistent with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. - The credit terms for outstanding receivables arising from the sale of fuel to PTG vehicles using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as provided by the Group to PTG, are similar to those established between PTG's petroleum product distributors at its gas stations and PTC, the card administrator. - However, following the change in the business model to granting rights for fuel distribution and managing fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables arising from fuel sales through the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. · Description: - OLP has trade receivables, part of which is accrued income from selling fuel to vehicles of PTG Group that refuel at OLP service stations using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.64 · 0.02 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of gas cylinder to PTC are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of LPG and Gas cartridges to the PTG Group are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. · Description: - The Company has trade receivables, which include outstanding revenues from the sale of LPG, bottled cooking gas, and gas cartridges, used in business operations and for retail purposes at cooking gas stores, fuel stations, Max Mart convenience stores, and Punthai Coffee Shop. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted. · - The outstanding liabilities arising from the use of oil transportation services are in line with the credit terms agreed upon by the Company with PTGLG and AMA. - The credit terms the Company receives from PTGLG and AMA are similar to those applied with other parties under comparable conditions. - However, following the shift in the business model to granting rights for fuel distribution and managing fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future trade payables arising from the use of oil transportation services. · Description: - The Company has trade payables, part of which consists of amounts not yet due for transportation services related to the delivery of fuel to its service stations. · Nature of transaction: Trade payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 8.83 · 37.71 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from the use of LPG transportation services for delivering gas cylinder to gas shops, distribution points for commercial customers, and LPG deliveries to customers are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between the Company and PTGLG. - The credit terms received by the Company from PTGLG are similar to those the Company applies with other parties under comparable conditions. · Description: - The Company has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the transportation services for delivering gas cylinder gas to gas shops and delivery points for commercial customers, as well as LPG transportation services to customers. · As of yesteryear: 17.84 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 5.9
0.0 · Necessity: - The Group and PTG Group have agreed to offer employee benefits, including discounts for purchasing products and services from both groups. Each party is responsible for the actual expenses incurred by their employees on a monthly basis. - When determining the discount for employees, the Company considers the benefits employees will receive and the appropriateness of the discount. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from oil sales arising from employee benefits. - According to the agreement, each company is responsible for the discount based on employee usage. The prices of products and services sold by the Group to PTG Group employees will be the same as those sold to the general public. The Company group is only responsible for welfare expenses corresponding to discounts used by its own employees. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from the discounted on the retail prices of LPG and oil arising from LPG and oil refueling by employees of PTG group at OLP's service stations, which PTG Group is responsible for reimbursing OLP for these discounted amounts. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations) · Audit committee opinion: - After consideration, the Audit Committee believes that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Company group. Offering discounts to employees is a common form of employee welfare that most companies provide. It enables employees to purchase quality products and services at a price lower than that available to the public, and also fostering a sense of pride in the Company they work for. Additionally, since each company is responsible for the discount based on its employees' usage, the employee welfare costs reflect the extent of benefits provided within each company. As a result, this transaction is similar to dealings with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 101.9 · Necessity: - As part of its participation of the PT Max Card membership program, the Group has agreed to allow PT Max Card and PT Max Plus members to earn reward points when purchasing products from the Group. Members may redeem these points for discounts on Group products including exclusive promotions offered through the PT Max Card program. - The Group is responsible for funding the reward points earned by members who purchase its products. Conversely, the Group receives reimbursement for points redeemed and discounts used by members. These transactions are managed through PTG Group companies that oversee the loyalty program. (PTC performed this role until June 2021, followed by MAX from July 2021 to September 2022, and MMC from October 2022 onward.) - In addition, the Group receives compensation related to discounts and added benefits offered to card members from PTG Group companies that own the membership cards and oversee member privileges. (PTG served as the card issuer until June 2021, after which MAX assumed the role from July 2021 to September 2022, and MMC from October 2022 onward. Responsibility for managing additional member benefits rested with PTG until April 2021, then transferred to MSS from May 2021 onward. PTG further appointed MAX to manage these benefits from July 2021 to September 2022, followed by MMC from October to December 2022.) - Participation in the PT Max Card system enables the Group to expand its customer base by accessing cardholders who are already familiar with and loyal to the “PT” brand. It also allows the Group to leverage an existing membership platform for marketing and promotional activities without the need to invest in or manage the membership system internally. - The value of reward points provided to members of the Group (which the Group pays to the point system administrator) is equal to the value of points redeemed as discounts (which the administrator reimburses to the Group). For any additional benefits offered to members, the entity authorising those benefits is fully responsible for covering the related costs. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from fuel sales related to membership discounts and benefits. - The terms under which the Group participates in the Max Card program are aligned with the standard agreements PTG Group has in place with its petroleum dealers operating service stations. · Description: - The Group recognises revenue from sales through product discounts offered to loyalty card members, with PTC and/or MAX and/or MMC acting as program administrators. - Additional revenue is generated from value-added benefits provided to loyalty card members under programs managed by PTG and/or MSS. The Company charges the corresponding value of these benefits to PTC and/or MAX, as well as PTG and/or MSS and/or MMC, respectively. · As of yesteryear: 71.04 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and Gas shops) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. Participating in a loyalty program managed by a third party is a common and effective business strategy. It supports the Group’s marketing efforts by encouraging customer retention and repeat purchases. Furthermore, the participation terms are consistent with those applied to third-party petroleum dealers within the PTG network. As such, the nature of this transaction is comparable to transactions made with unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 61.59 · 4.67 · Necessity: - In addition to the PT Max Card, PTG Group has launched the PT Max Plus Card, which offers enhanced privileges compared to the standard PT Max Card (unlike the PT Max Card, which is available free of charge), customers who wish to enroll in the PT Max Plus program are required to pay a membership fee. Therefore the Group entered into an agreement to serve as a distributor of PT Max Plus Cards on behalf of PTG MAX and MMC. (Following PTG Group’s internal restructuring, the Group acted as a card distributor for PTG from March 2021 to June 2021, for MAX from July 2021 to September 2022, and for MMC from October 2022 onward.) - Additionally, when customers choose to renew their PT Max Plus membership upon expiry, the Group receives a renewal service fee of Baht 5 per card from PTG Group. - Given the Group’s extensive retail network comprising gas shops and service stations that serve as key customer touchpoints it is well-positioned to offer related products (such as lubricants and accessories for LPG cylinders) alongside its core petroleum offerings. In this context, the sale of PT Max Plus cards is treated as part of the Group’s regular product distribution activities, similar to the sale of other related consumer goods. - The return generated by the Group from distributing PT Max Plus cards to PTG Group falls within the same range as the returns earned from the sale of other non-petroleum products. - Additionally, the service fee for PT Max Plus card renewals is aligned with the rate offered to PTG’s authorised fuel distribution partners. · Description: - The Group recognised other income from service fees related to the PT Max Plus card, as follows: • Service fees for the sale and renewal of PT Max Plus cards to MMC. · As of yesteryear: 26.27 · Nature of transaction: Other income · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and concluded that it is appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. The distribution of PT Max Plus cards to PTG Group contributes to incremental revenue for the Group. Moreover, the return from this activity is consistent with that of other non-petroleum product sales, indicating that the transaction reflects market-based terms. Therefore, the transaction is considered to be conducted on an arm’s-length basis and comparable to a transaction with an independent third party. · As of year before yesteryear: 4.16 · - PT Max Card members are entitled to special privileges under the “Birthday Special” campaign, receiving complimentary drinking water during their birth month. Additionally, under the e-Stamp promotion, members can redeem e-Stamps for drinking water at OLP service stations. This also includes privileges for PT Prestige cardholders to receive complimentary drinking water. In this regard, OLP receives reimbursement for the cost of drinking water associated with such promotions from MSS and MMC. - The terms and conditions for participating as a merchant in the Max Card membership system, as agreed upon by the Group with MSS and MMC, are identical to those agreed upon by PTG’s petroleum dealers (service station type) with MSS and MMC. · Description: - OLP has other income from the “Birthday Special” activity and e-Stamp promotion for drinking water redemption with MSS, as well as from Prestige Card privileges for drinking water redemption with MMC. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Other income · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. The promotional activities under the PT Max Card program enhance customer loyalty by offering tangible member benefits such as complimentary bottled water through the Birthday Special, e-Stamp redemptions at OLP stations, and Prestige member privileges. Importantly, the associated costs are reimbursed to OLP by MSS and MMC. Furthermore, the commercial terms under which the Group participates in the Max Card program mirror those offered to PTG’s other retail petroleum partners. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.21 · 2.98 · Necessity: - ATL utilizes sales system equipment (Smart EDC) services from MMC, which is a provider of sales system equipment (Smart EDC), including equipment repair and maintenance services. - The service rates and conditions received by ATL from MMC are comparable to those ATL receives from other service providers.- The Google API service fees paid by the Group to MSS and PTG are based on the amounts that MSS and PTG have paid to the service provider, proportionate to the Group's usage of the service. · Description: - The Group utilizes Smart EDC device services, with the service fees paid through MMC. · Nature of transaction: Service fees · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is both appropriate and beneficial to the Group. This is because utilising sales system equipment (Smart EDC) services from MMC constitutes a general commercial transaction. The service rates and conditions received by ATL from MMC are comparable to transactions made with third parties. · - The Group purchased various products from PTG Group to be given as New Year gifts to its customers and business partners. These products include Pavitree items, Premium Max Card luggage, and Punthai gift baskets, among others. - The prices and terms offered to the Group by its affiliated companies are consistent with those provided to other customers of the affiliated companies. · Description: - The Group purchases products from PTG Group to use as New Year gifts for its customers and business partners. · Nature of transaction: Other Expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and concluded that it is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Providing New Year gifts to customers and partners is a standard business practice that fosters strong relationships with the Group’s clients and partners. The prices and terms received by the Group from the affiliated companies align with those offered to other customers. Therefore, this transaction is consistent with transactions conducted with third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.03 · 0.0 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms regarding the discounts on LPG and fuel prices granted to PTG Group employees are comparable to those the Group extends to employees within the PTG Group. - However, following the change in the business model to granting the rights to distribute fuel and manage fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables resulting from fuel sales with employee discount benefits. · Description: - OLP has other receivables, part of which is accrued income from providing discounts on LPG and fuel sales to employees of PTG Group who refill and use their benefits at OLP service stations. PTG Group is required to reimburse OLP for these amounts. · Nature of transaction: Other Receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · 42.17 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for discounts arising from the redemption of PT Max Card points and the utilization of additional privileges granted by the PTG Group to PT Max Card members are comparable to those the PTG Group extends to its petroleum product dealers - However, following the change in the business model to granting rights for fuel distribution and managing fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables resulting from fuel sales with discounts and additional benefits for cardholders. · Description: - The Company has other receivables from accrued income arising from PT Max Card members redeeming accumulated points for discounts on product purchases and from providing benefits to PT Max Card members as part of the program managed by PT Max Card administrators. · As of yesteryear: 20.9 · Nature of transaction: Other receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and these commercial terms are consistent with those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 8.03 · - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of engine oil and PT Max Plus cards are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between OLP and the PTG Group. - The credit terms received by OLP from the PTG Group are similar to those offered by the PTG Group to other buyers. · Description: - OLP has trade payables, part of which consists of amounts due for the purchase of engine oil and PT Max Plus cards from PTG, intended for resale at OLP’s service stations and OLP reimbursing to PTG. · Nature of transaction: Trade payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 6.35 · 0.94 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of consumable materials used at the service stations, payment of utility expenses, transportation and communication costs on behalf of the Group, as well as the awarding of PT Max Card points to PT Max Card members purchasing products from the Group, the use of E-vouchers by participating taxis, fuel purchases and payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, and employee welfare discounts are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and PTG. - The credit terms received by the Group from PTG are similar to those offered by PTG to other parties under comparable conditions. · Description: - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the purchase of supply used at the service stations from PTC, as well as utility, transportation, and communication expenses. Moreover, there are expenses related to the PT Max points awarded when PT Max Card members purchase products from the Group, and expenses incurred from the use of E-vouchers for taxis participating in the “We will get through this together” “Taxi Fights COVID” program, which provide discounts for purchasing products or services from PTG - The Group also has other payables for fuel purchases and product payments made using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from employee discounts for purchasing products from PTG. · As of yesteryear: 0.45 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · 15.14 · Necessity: - As part of joining the PT Max Card system, the Group has agreed that PT Max Card members who purchase products from the Group will earn loyalty points. Additionally, PT Max Card members will be able to redeem these points for discounts on the Group's products. - The Group is responsible for paying PTG for awarding loyalty points to PT Max Card members who purchase the Group's products. In turn, the Group will receive payments from PTG for points redeemed for discounts and for the benefits provided to PT Max Card members, as per the terms set by the cardholders. - The credit terms received by the Group from PTG are similar to those PTG offers to other parties under comparable conditions. - However, following the changed in the business model to granting rights for managing at OLP service stations, there will be no future trade payables related to awarding loyalty points to purchasing fuel at OLP service stations. · Description: - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the PT Max Card points awarded when PT Max Card members purchase products from the Group. · As of yesteryear: 6.83 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.99 · - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of products from the PTG Group for New Year gifts are in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. - The credit terms received by the Company from the PTG Group are similar to those the Group provides to other customers. · Description: - The Group has other payables for expenses related to purchasing products from PTG Group to be used as New Year gifts for the Company's customers and business partners. · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.03 · 0.39 · Necessity: - The Group will recognize accrued expenses from transactions that have occurred in the financial period but have not yet been invoiced by the service providers, in accordance with the Group's accounting policy. · Description: - The Group has accrued expenses, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet been invoiced by MSS, arising from the use of Google API services on the Smart EDC system. - Additionally, the Group has accrued expenses that have not yet been invoiced by PGE, arising from electricity usage at the service stations. - Furthermore, the Group has accrued expenses that have not yet been invoiced by PTG, arising from the transportation of gas catridge. - In addition, the Group has another portion of accrued expenses, which are unpaid charges from MMC related to the renewal fees for Max Card Plus. - In addition, the Group has another portion of accrued expenses comprising unbilled expenses from PTC, arising from electricity and water usage within service stations. · As of yesteryear: 0.39 · Nature of transaction: Accrued expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and believes that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group, as it is in line with the Group's accounting policies. Furthermore, the commercial terms are similar to those applied with external parties.
0.0 · Necessity: - The Group and PTG Group have agreed to offer employee benefits, including discounts for purchasing products and services from both groups. Each party is responsible for the actual expenses incurred by their employees on a monthly basis. - When determining the discount for employees, the Company considers the benefits employees will receive and the appropriateness of the discount. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from oil sales arising from employee benefits. - According to the agreement, each company is responsible for the discount based on employee usage. The prices of products and services sold by the Group to PTG Group employees will be the same as those sold to the general public. The Company group is only responsible for welfare expenses corresponding to discounts used by its own employees. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from the discounted on the retail prices of LPG and oil arising from LPG and oil refueling by employees of PTG group at OLP's service stations, which PTG Group is responsible for reimbursing OLP for these discounted amounts. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations) · Audit committee opinion: - After consideration, the Audit Committee believes that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Company group. Offering discounts to employees is a common form of employee welfare that most companies provide. It enables employees to purchase quality products and services at a price lower than that available to the public, and also fostering a sense of pride in the Company they work for. Additionally, since each company is responsible for the discount based on its employees' usage, the employee welfare costs reflect the extent of benefits provided within each company. As a result, this transaction is similar to dealings with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · - During the year ended 2023, OLP applied for an operating license for the use of solar panels at its Bangkapi 3 service station, where a solar energy system had already been installed. However, the majority of OLP’s service stations had not yet adopted solar panel systems. - To ensure efficient management and maintenance of solar equipment, and to establish a clear business structure, OLP entered into an agreement with PGE, a company specializing in solar power generation. Under the agreement, PGE would invest in the installation of solar panels across OLP’s service stations and sell the generated electricity directly to OLP. - Subsequently, in the year ended 2023, OLP transferred the operating license for the solar panels at the Bangkapi 3 station to PGE, assigning full responsibility for the operation and maintenance of the system to PGE. - In YE2024, the Boards of Directors of both the Company and PTG approved a business segregation plan to streamline the Group’s operational structure. As part of this plan, the PTG Group was designated to oversee the electric vehicle (EV) charging station business. Accordingly, OLP sold all EV charging-related assets located at its service stations to PTC, making PTC the designated EV charging station operator within the Group. - The transfer price of the solar panel operating license sold to PGE was based on OLP’s original acquisition cost. OLP recognised a gain on disposal equal to the difference between the sale price (equivalent to acquisition cost) and the net book value (NBV) after deducting accumulated depreciation. - The EV charging station-related assets sold by OLP to PTC were priced at their net book value (NBV) plus a 1% markup to cover associated administrative and operational costs. This pricing is consistent with the estimated cost that PTC would have incurred if it had acquired the assets independently. · Description: - OLP had gain on sales of an assets, an operating licenses for solar panel installation at the Bangkapi 3 service station to PGE. - OLP had gain on sales of an assets, related to the operation of the EV Charging Station located within OLP’s service stations to PTC. · Nature of transaction: Gain on sales of an assets · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transactions and is of the opinion that they are appropriate and in the best interests of the Group. The sale of the solar panel operating license to PGE, along with the transfer of EV charging station-related assets to PTC, serves to streamline the business structure between the Group and the PTG Group. These actions also alleviate the operational and maintenance burden on OLP with respect to solar panel equipment. Furthermore, the agreed sale prices for both the license and the EV-related assets are consistent with the costs that PGE and PTC would have incurred had they procured the assets independently. Therefore, the transactions are considered to be conducted on an arm’s-length basis and reflect terms that are fair and comparable to those that would apply in transactions with unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.03 · 1.8 · Necessity: - OLP has agreed to allow PGE, the operator of the solar power business, to invest in the installation of solar panels at OLP's service stations and sell the electricity generated to OLP. - The electricity rate that OLP purchases from PGE is discounted from the standard rates of the Metropolitan Electricity Authority (MEA) and the Provincial Electricity Authority (PEA). This discount rate is in line with those offered by other service providers. · Description: - OLP incurs other expenses in the form of electricity costs generated from solar panels installed by PGE at OLP's service stations. · As of yesteryear: 0.75 · Nature of transaction: Other expenses - electricity costs · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and concluded that it is both appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Specifically, entrusting PGE with the investment and installation of solar panels alleviates OLP's investment burden and management responsibilities, including maintenance and upkeep. Moreover, the electricity rate OLP pays to PGE, which is discounted compared to the MEA and PEA rates, is consistent with the terms OLP has with other service providers. Therefore, this transaction is comparable to those made with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.06 · 0.0 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms regarding the discounts on LPG and fuel prices granted to PTG Group employees are comparable to those the Group extends to employees within the PTG Group. - However, following the change in the business model to granting the rights to distribute fuel and manage fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables resulting from fuel sales with employee discount benefits. · Description: - OLP has other receivables, part of which is accrued income from providing discounts on LPG and fuel sales to employees of PTG Group who refill and use their benefits at OLP service stations. PTG Group is required to reimburse OLP for these amounts. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Other Receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. · Description: - OLP has other receivables from accrued income arising from the sale of assets, specifically the license to operate solar panels at Bangkapi 3 service station, which was sold to PGE. · Nature of transaction: Other receivables from related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.29 · 0.04 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of consumable materials used at the service stations, payment of utility expenses, transportation and communication costs on behalf of the Group, as well as the awarding of PT Max Card points to PT Max Card members purchasing products from the Group, the use of E-vouchers by participating taxis, fuel purchases and payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, and employee welfare discounts are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and PTG. - The credit terms received by the Group from PTG are similar to those offered by PTG to other parties under comparable conditions. · Description: - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the purchase of supply used at the service stations from PTC, as well as utility, transportation, and communication expenses. Moreover, there are expenses related to the PT Max points awarded when PT Max Card members purchase products from the Group, and expenses incurred from the use of E-vouchers for taxis participating in the “We will get through this together” “Taxi Fights COVID” program, which provide discounts for purchasing products or services from PTG - The Group also has other payables for fuel purchases and product payments made using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from employee discounts for purchasing products from PTG. · As of yesteryear: 0.37 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · 1.95 · Necessity: - The Group will recognize accrued expenses from transactions that have occurred in the financial period but have not yet been invoiced by the service providers, in accordance with the Group's accounting policy. · Description: - The Group has accrued expenses, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet been invoiced by MSS, arising from the use of Google API services on the Smart EDC system. - Additionally, the Group has accrued expenses that have not yet been invoiced by PGE, arising from electricity usage at the service stations. - Furthermore, the Group has accrued expenses that have not yet been invoiced by PTG, arising from the transportation of gas catridge. - In addition, the Group has another portion of accrued expenses, which are unpaid charges from MMC related to the renewal fees for Max Card Plus. - In addition, the Group has another portion of accrued expenses comprising unbilled expenses from PTC, arising from electricity and water usage within service stations. · Nature of transaction: Accrued expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and believes that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group, as it is in line with the Group's accounting policies. Furthermore, the commercial terms are similar to those applied with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.06
0.0 · Necessity: - The Group and PTG Group have agreed to offer employee benefits, including discounts for purchasing products and services from both groups. Each party is responsible for the actual expenses incurred by their employees on a monthly basis. - When determining the discount for employees, the Company considers the benefits employees will receive and the appropriateness of the discount. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from oil sales arising from employee benefits. - According to the agreement, each company is responsible for the discount based on employee usage. The prices of products and services sold by the Group to PTG Group employees will be the same as those sold to the general public. The Company group is only responsible for welfare expenses corresponding to discounts used by its own employees. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from the discounted on the retail prices of LPG and oil arising from LPG and oil refueling by employees of PTG group at OLP's service stations, which PTG Group is responsible for reimbursing OLP for these discounted amounts. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations) · Audit committee opinion: - After consideration, the Audit Committee believes that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Company group. Offering discounts to employees is a common form of employee welfare that most companies provide. It enables employees to purchase quality products and services at a price lower than that available to the public, and also fostering a sense of pride in the Company they work for. Additionally, since each company is responsible for the discount based on its employees' usage, the employee welfare costs reflect the extent of benefits provided within each company. As a result, this transaction is similar to dealings with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01 · - As part of its participation of the PT Max Card membership program, the Group has agreed to allow PT Max Card and PT Max Plus members to earn reward points when purchasing products from the Group. Members may redeem these points for discounts on Group products including exclusive promotions offered through the PT Max Card program. - The Group is responsible for funding the reward points earned by members who purchase its products. Conversely, the Group receives reimbursement for points redeemed and discounts used by members. These transactions are managed through PTG Group companies that oversee the loyalty program. (PTC performed this role until June 2021, followed by MAX from July 2021 to September 2022, and MMC from October 2022 onward.) - In addition, the Group receives compensation related to discounts and added benefits offered to card members from PTG Group companies that own the membership cards and oversee member privileges. (PTG served as the card issuer until June 2021, after which MAX assumed the role from July 2021 to September 2022, and MMC from October 2022 onward. Responsibility for managing additional member benefits rested with PTG until April 2021, then transferred to MSS from May 2021 onward. PTG further appointed MAX to manage these benefits from July 2021 to September 2022, followed by MMC from October to December 2022.) - Participation in the PT Max Card system enables the Group to expand its customer base by accessing cardholders who are already familiar with and loyal to the “PT” brand. It also allows the Group to leverage an existing membership platform for marketing and promotional activities without the need to invest in or manage the membership system internally. - The value of reward points provided to members of the Group (which the Group pays to the point system administrator) is equal to the value of points redeemed as discounts (which the administrator reimburses to the Group). For any additional benefits offered to members, the entity authorising those benefits is fully responsible for covering the related costs. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from fuel sales related to membership discounts and benefits. - The terms under which the Group participates in the Max Card program are aligned with the standard agreements PTG Group has in place with its petroleum dealers operating service stations. · Description: - The Group recognises revenue from sales through product discounts offered to loyalty card members, with PTC and/or MAX and/or MMC acting as program administrators. - Additional revenue is generated from value-added benefits provided to loyalty card members under programs managed by PTG and/or MSS. The Company charges the corresponding value of these benefits to PTC and/or MAX, as well as PTG and/or MSS and/or MMC, respectively. · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and Gas shops) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. Participating in a loyalty program managed by a third party is a common and effective business strategy. It supports the Group’s marketing efforts by encouraging customer retention and repeat purchases. Furthermore, the participation terms are consistent with those applied to third-party petroleum dealers within the PTG network. As such, the nature of this transaction is comparable to transactions made with unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 11.68 · - PT Max Card members are entitled to special privileges under the “Birthday Special” campaign, receiving complimentary drinking water during their birth month. Additionally, under the e-Stamp promotion, members can redeem e-Stamps for drinking water at OLP service stations. This also includes privileges for PT Prestige cardholders to receive complimentary drinking water. In this regard, OLP receives reimbursement for the cost of drinking water associated with such promotions from MSS and MMC. - The terms and conditions for participating as a merchant in the Max Card membership system, as agreed upon by the Group with MSS and MMC, are identical to those agreed upon by PTG’s petroleum dealers (service station type) with MSS and MMC. · Description: - OLP has other income from the “Birthday Special” activity and e-Stamp promotion for drinking water redemption with MSS, as well as from Prestige Card privileges for drinking water redemption with MMC. · Nature of transaction: Other income · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. The promotional activities under the PT Max Card program enhance customer loyalty by offering tangible member benefits—such as complimentary bottled water through the Birthday Special, e-Stamp redemptions at OLP stations, and Prestige member privileges. Importantly, the associated costs are reimbursed to OLP by MSS and MMC. Furthermore, the commercial terms under which the Group participates in the Max Card program mirror those offered to PTG’s other retail petroleum partners. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01 · 0.55 · Necessity: - The Group agreed to engage MSS which has been appointed by MAX, the owner of the PT Max Card to act as the manager for PT Max Card members. In this capacity, MSS is responsible for handling operations regarding Customer Relations, Database Management, and Business Partnerships for the Group. · Description: - The Company also engages MSS to handle operations related to PT Max Card members (such as Customer Relations, Database Management, and Business Partnerships) on an outsourcing basis. · As of yesteryear: 0.66 · Nature of transaction: Service expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and in the best interests of the Group. Engaging a qualified third-party service provider with proven expertise to handle functions outside the Group’s core capabilities is consistent with common business practices. The service fees and terms provided by MSS are aligned with market standards and are comparable to those that would be applied in transactions with independent third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.4 · - Previously, the Group utilised the Smart EDC system, which required the use of the Google API. However, MSS was the registered service provider, meaning the Group had to pay for the Google API usage through MSS. - Later, the Group transferred the rights to the Smart EDC system from MSS and directly registered the service. As a result, the Group became the direct payer of the service fees to the provider. The only exception is for the fees in January 2024, which are still in transition and being paid through PTG. - The Google API service fees paid by the Group to MSS and PTG are based on the amounts that MSS and PTG have paid to the service provider, proportionate to the Group's usage of the service. · Description: - The Group utilises Google API services on the Smart EDC system, and pays the service fees through MSS and PTG. · Nature of transaction: Service fees · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is both appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The Smart EDC system requires integration with the Google API to function effectively. The service fees paid by the Group to MSS and PTG are based on the fees that MSS and PTG have paid to the provider, in proportion to the Group’s usage. Therefore, this transaction is deemed comparable to transactions with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.15 · 0.0 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms regarding the discounts on LPG and fuel prices granted to PTG Group employees are comparable to those the Group extends to employees within the PTG Group. - However, following the change in the business model to granting the rights to distribute fuel and manage fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables resulting from fuel sales with employee discount benefits. · Description: - OLP has other receivables, part of which is accrued income from providing discounts on LPG and fuel sales to employees of PTG Group who refill and use their benefits at OLP service stations. PTG Group is required to reimburse OLP for these amounts. · Nature of transaction: Other Receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.0 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for discounts arising from the redemption of PT Max Card points and the utilization of additional privileges granted by the PTG Group to PT Max Card members are comparable to those the PTG Group extends to its petroleum product dealers - However, following the change in the business model to granting rights for fuel distribution and managing fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables resulting from fuel sales with discounts and additional benefits for cardholders. · Description: - The Company has other receivables from accrued income arising from PT Max Card members redeeming accumulated points for discounts on product purchases and from providing benefits to PT Max Card members as part of the program managed by PT Max Card administrators. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Other receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and these commercial terms are consistent with those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 2.0 · 0.05 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from the engagement of MSS and PTG to perform operations on an outsourcing basis are in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and MSS and PTG. - The credit terms received by the Group from MSS and PTG are comparable to those MSS and PTG extend to third parties. · Description: - The Group has a portion of other payables comprising accrued expenses arising from the engagement of MSS and PTG to carry out operations on an outsourcing basis. · As of yesteryear: 0.02 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.04 · - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of consumable materials used at the service stations, payment of utility expenses, transportation and communication costs on behalf of the Group, as well as the awarding of PT Max Card points to PT Max Card members purchasing products from the Group, the use of E-vouchers by participating taxis, fuel purchases and payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, and employee welfare discounts are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and PTG. - The credit terms received by the Group from PTG are similar to those offered by PTG to other parties under comparable conditions. · Description: - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the purchase of supply used at the service stations from PTC, as well as utility, transportation, and communication expenses. Moreover, there are expenses related to the PT Max points awarded when PT Max Card members purchase products from the Group, and expenses incurred from the use of E-vouchers for taxis participating in the “We will get through this together” “Taxi Fights COVID” program, which provide discounts for purchasing products or services from PTG - The Group also has other payables for fuel purchases and product payments made using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from employee discounts for purchasing products from PTG. · As of yesteryear: 0.02 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.12 · - The Group will recognize accrued expenses from transactions that have occurred in the financial period but have not yet been invoiced by the service providers, in accordance with the Group's accounting policy. · Description: - The Group has accrued expenses, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet been invoiced by MSS, arising from the use of Google API services on the Smart EDC system. - Additionally, the Group has accrued expenses that have not yet been invoiced by PGE, arising from electricity usage at the service stations. - Furthermore, the Group has accrued expenses that have not yet been invoiced by PTG, arising from the transportation of gas catridge. - In addition, the Group has another portion of accrued expenses, which are unpaid charges from MMC related to the renewal fees for Max Card Plus. - In addition, the Group has another portion of accrued expenses comprising unbilled expenses from PTC, arising from electricity and water usage within service stations. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Accrued expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and believes that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group, as it is in line with the Group's accounting policies. Furthermore, the commercial terms are similar to those applied with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.03
0.0 · Necessity: - The Group and PTG Group have agreed to offer employee benefits, including discounts for purchasing products and services from both groups. Each party is responsible for the actual expenses incurred by their employees on a monthly basis. - When determining the discount for employees, the Company considers the benefits employees will receive and the appropriateness of the discount. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from oil sales arising from employee benefits. - According to the agreement, each company is responsible for the discount based on employee usage. The prices of products and services sold by the Group to PTG Group employees will be the same as those sold to the general public. The Company group is only responsible for welfare expenses corresponding to discounts used by its own employees. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from the discounted on the retail prices of LPG and oil arising from LPG and oil refueling by employees of PTG group at OLP's service stations, which PTG Group is responsible for reimbursing OLP for these discounted amounts. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations) · Audit committee opinion: - After consideration, the Audit Committee believes that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Company group. Offering discounts to employees is a common form of employee welfare that most companies provide. It enables employees to purchase quality products and services at a price lower than that available to the public, and also fostering a sense of pride in the Company they work for. Additionally, since each company is responsible for the discount based on its employees' usage, the employee welfare costs reflect the extent of benefits provided within each company. As a result, this transaction is similar to dealings with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · - OLP has agreed to allow vehicle users refueling with LPG and oil at its service stations to pay using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, both managed by PTC. This arrangement increases OLP’s sales opportunities, while PTC, as the card program operator, is responsible for collecting payments from cardholders and remitting the proceeds to OLP. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - Moreover, the Company sells LPG to PTGLG for its business operations, specifically for testing the gas tanks of transportation truck. The Company also sells cooking gas to WG, PUN, and PBN. - OLP sells LPG and oil to Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card holders at service station prices, which are the same rates offered to the general public. Moreover, the terms and conditions for accepting payments via these cards, as agreed between OLP and PTC, are consistent with those between PTG’s fuel service station dealers and PTC. - LPG prices at which the Group supplies PTGLG are in line with those charged to other customers. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from fuel purchases made by vehicles within the PTG Group at OLP’s service stations, with payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - The Company also reconised revenue from the sale of LPG products supplied to PTGLG, WG, PUN, and PBN for operational purposes. · As of yesteryear: 0.03 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and LPG Wholesale) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Accepting payments via the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card is consistent with normal business practices, whereby sellers provide multiple convenient payment options to customers. Additionally, the sale of LPG to PTGLG and sale of cooking gas to WG, PUN, PBN for internal operations are part of the Company’s ordinary course of business. The payment terms for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as well as the LPG pricing, are comparable to those offered to unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01 · 0.52 · Necessity: - The leasing of commercial area within OLP’s service stations enhances OLP's revenue, allowing the Company to better utilize its existing assets at these locations. It also enables the service stations to better meet the needs of motorists. OLP provides the opportunity for the general public, including PTG Group, to lease commercial space within its service stations for business operations. - The rental rates and terms that OLP offers to PTG Group are identical to those provided to other tenants leasing commercial area in OLP’s service stations. Similarly, these rates and terms are consistent with those PTC offers to external parties leasing commercial space at PTC’s service stations. · Description: - OLP recognised the rental income from commercial areas within its service stations as follows: • PTC leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Max Mart convenience store). • PUN leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Punthai Coffee shop). • SAB leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Automotive service and maintenance center under the “Autobacs” brand). • PTGLG rents for truck parking and warehouse of medical oxygen cylinders at the Phutthabucha 4 service station. • GFA rents to operate a retail store and services within the service station (Coffee World shop). • GS rents to operate a retail store and services within the service station (food and beverage shop “Subway”). • PBN leases within service stations to operate retail shops for goods and services (Food and beverage shop “Punthai Boat Noodle”). - The revenue from assets for lease consisted of rental fee and service fees on commercial area ,as well as utilities charges. · Nature of transaction: Revenue from assets for lease and other services · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and determined that it is appropriate and beneficial for the Group. Leasing commercial space generates additional income for OLP and increases the opportunities for motorists to utilize the service stations. Furthermore, the rental rates and lease terms agreed upon between OLP and PTG Group are comparable to those offered to third-party tenants. · 0.1 · Necessity: - To ensure a unified standard of attire for employees working at service stations and gas shops operating under the "PT" brand, the Group has established a policy requiring all employees to wear uniforms that adhere to a single standard design. - Generally, OLP purchases employee uniforms directly from manufacturers. However, for certain types of uniforms (such as maternity dresses) or special sizes (e.g., extra-large or smaller than standard sizes), where the demand volume is relatively low unlike the PTG Group, which has a larger workforce and thus higher demand for all uniform types the Group is unable to purchase these specific items directly from manufacturers. Consequently, it is necessary for the Group to purchase such uniforms from PTC. - In this regard, the purchase price of uniforms from PTC is calculated based on cost plus administrative expenses to cover PTC's sourcing and operational costs. Such purchase price is considered comparable to the price at which OLP could source directly from the suppliers of said goods - Regarding employee welfare expenses arising from providing discounts on goods and services within the Group and the PTG Group, the transaction complies with a mutual agreement stipulating that each party shall be responsible for the actual discount amounts utilised by their respective employees on a monthly basis. - Additionally, a portion of employee welfare expenses arises from the purchase of food, beverages, and medical supplies for the Group’s employees. In this regard, the prices and commercial terms received by the Group from PTC, PUN, GS, and MVT are consistent with those PTC, PUN, GS, and MVT offer to other customers. · Description: - The Group incurs employee welfare expenses regarding the purchase of staff uniforms. - The Group also incurs employee welfare expenses arising from employees utilising discounts to purchase goods and services from the PTG Group. Consequently, the Group is required to reimburse the discount amounts to the PTG Group. - The Group incurs employee welfare expenses regarding the purchase of food and beverages for employees attending various training courses organized by the Company. - The Group also incurs employee expenses regarding the purchase of medical supplies for employees. · Nature of transaction: Employee Benefits Expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. This is because purchasing low-demand uniforms from PTC alleviates the Group’s burden of maintaining excess inventory. Furthermore, the purchase prices and conditions are comparable to those the Group would agree upon with suppliers. Therefore, the transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. - Additionally, providing discounts on goods and services is a standard form of employee welfare adopted by most companies. It enables employees to purchase quality goods and services at prices lower than the general public, while also fostering a sense of pride in the organization they work for. In this regard, the fact that each company assumes responsibility for the discount costs based on actual employee usage ensures that the welfare expenses of each entity accurately reflect the volume of benefits provided to its employees. Consequently, this transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. · 0.02 · Necessity: - The Group set up a Punthai Coffee booth at an event for its customers and business partners. The pricing and commercial terms provided by PUN to the Group are consistent with those offered to other customers. - The Group distributes coupons to customers during events to serve as discounts for product purchases. - The prices and commercial terms received by the Group from PUN, GFA, and GS are consistent with those PUN, GFA, and GS offer to other customers. · Description: - The Group set up a Punthai Coffee booth at events for customers and business partners of the Group. - The Group distributes discount coupons to customers during events held at oil and LPG service stations, to be used as discounts for the purchase of products from PUN, GFA, and GS. · Nature of transaction: Other expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is both appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The setup of the Punthai Coffee booth and distributing discount coupons for product purchases at events for the Group’s customers and business partners help foster good relationships with said customers and business partners. Furthermore, the prices and commercial terms received by the Group from PUN, GFA, and GS are consistent with those PUN, GFA, and GS offer to other customers. Therefore, the transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. · 0.02 · Necessity: - The Group purchased various products from PTG Group to be given as New Year gifts to its customers and business partners. These products include Pavitree items, Premium Max Card luggage, and Punthai gift baskets, among others. - The prices and terms offered to the Group by its affiliated companies are consistent with those provided to other customers of the affiliated companies. · Description: - The Group purchases products from PTG Group to use as New Year gifts for its customers and business partners. · As of yesteryear: 0.04 · Nature of transaction: Other Expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and concluded that it is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Providing New Year gifts to customers and partners is a standard business practice that fosters strong relationships with the Group’s clients and partners. The prices and terms received by the Group from the affiliated companies align with those offered to other customers. Therefore, this transaction is consistent with transactions conducted with third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.06 · 0.0 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms regarding the discounts on LPG and fuel prices granted to PTG Group employees are comparable to those the Group extends to employees within the PTG Group. - However, following the change in the business model to granting the rights to distribute fuel and manage fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables resulting from fuel sales with employee discount benefits. · Description: - OLP has other receivables, part of which is accrued income from providing discounts on LPG and fuel sales to employees of PTG Group who refill and use their benefits at OLP service stations. PTG Group is required to reimburse OLP for these amounts. · Nature of transaction: Other Receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · 0.04 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. In this regard, the credit terms for the leasing of large billboards and advertising space on taxis, as agreed upon by OLP with PTG, are comparable to those the PTG Group receives from other providers of large billboards and taxi advertising area. · Description: - OLP has other receivables from accrued income arising from leasing commercial area, including water and electricity charges at OLP service stations. · Nature of transaction: Other receivables from related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for fuel sales to PTG Group vehicles utilising Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise cards are consistent with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. - The credit terms for outstanding receivables arising from the sale of fuel to PTG vehicles using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as provided by the Group to PTG, are similar to those established between PTG's petroleum product distributors at its gas stations and PTC, the card administrator. - However, following the change in the business model to granting rights for fuel distribution and managing fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables arising from fuel sales through the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. · Description: - OLP has trade receivables, part of which is accrued income from selling fuel to vehicles of PTG Group that refuel at OLP service stations using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.05 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of consumable materials used at the service stations, payment of utility expenses, transportation and communication costs on behalf of the Group, as well as the awarding of PT Max Card points to PT Max Card members purchasing products from the Group, the use of E-vouchers by participating taxis, fuel purchases and payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, and employee welfare discounts are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and PTG. - The credit terms received by the Group from PTG are similar to those offered by PTG to other parties under comparable conditions. · Description: - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the purchase of supply used at the service stations from PTC, as well as utility, transportation, and communication expenses. Moreover, there are expenses related to the PT Max points awarded when PT Max Card members purchase products from the Group, and expenses incurred from the use of E-vouchers for taxis participating in the “We will get through this together” “Taxi Fights COVID” program, which provide discounts for purchasing products or services from PTG - The Group also has other payables for fuel purchases and product payments made using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from employee discounts for purchasing products from PTG. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of products from the PTG Group for New Year gifts are in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. - The credit terms received by the Company from the PTG Group are similar to those the Group provides to other customers. · Description: - The Group has other payables for expenses related to purchasing products from PTG Group to be used as New Year gifts for the Company's customers and business partners. · As of yesteryear: 0.05 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.07
- The Group and PTG Group have agreed to offer employee benefits, including discounts for purchasing products and services from both groups. Each party is responsible for the actual expenses incurred by their employees on a monthly basis. - When determining the discount for employees, the Company considers the benefits employees will receive and the appropriateness of the discount. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revnue from oil sales arising from employee benefits. - According to the agreement, each company is responsible for the discount based on employee usage. The prices of products and services sold by the Group to PTG Group employees will be the same as those sold to the general public. The Company group is only responsible for welfare expenses corresponding to discounts used by its own employees. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from the discounted on the retail prices of LPG and oil arising from LPG and oil refueling by employees of PTG group at OLP's service stations, which PTG Group is responsible for reimbursing OLP for these discounted amounts. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations) · Audit committee opinion: - After consideration, the Audit Committee believes that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Company group. Offering discounts to employees is a common form of employee welfare that most companies provide. It enables employees to purchase quality products and services at a price lower than that available to the public, and also fostering a sense of pride in the Company they work for. Additionally, since each company is responsible for the discount based on its employees' usage, the employee welfare costs reflect the extent of benefits provided within each company. As a result, this transaction is similar to dealings with external parties.
1.15 · Necessity: - The leasing of commercial area within OLP’s service stations enhances OLP's revenue, allowing the Company to better utilize its existing assets at these locations. It also enables the service stations to better meet the needs of motorists. OLP provides the opportunity for the general public, including PTG Group, to lease commercial space within its service stations for business operations. - The rental rates and terms that OLP offers to PTG Group are identical to those provided to other tenants leasing commercial area in OLP’s service stations. Similarly, these rates and terms are consistent with those PTC offers to external parties leasing commercial space at PTC’s service stations. · Description: - OLP recognised the rental income from commercial areas within its service stations as follows: • PTC leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Max Mart convenience store). • PUN leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Punthai Coffee shop). • SAB leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Automotive service and maintenance center under the “Autobacs” brand). • PTGLG rents for truck parking and warehouse of medical oxygen cylinders at the Phutthabucha 4 service station. • GFA rents to operate a retail store and services within the service station (Coffee World shop). • GS rents to operate a retail store and services within the service station (food and beverage shop “Subway”). • PBN leases within service stations to operate retail shops for goods and services (Food and beverage shop “Punthai Boat Noodle”). - The revenue from assets for lease consisted of rental fee and service fees on commercial area ,as well as utilities charges. · Nature of transaction: Revenue from assets for lease and other services · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and determined that it is appropriate and beneficial for the Group. Leasing commercial space generates additional income for OLP and increases the opportunities for motorists to utilize the service stations. Furthermore, the rental rates and lease terms agreed upon between OLP and PTG Group are comparable to those offered to third-party tenants. · 0.02 · Necessity: - To ensure a unified standard of attire for employees working at service stations and gas shops operating under the "PT" brand, the Group has established a policy requiring all employees to wear uniforms that adhere to a single standard design. - Generally, OLP purchases employee uniforms directly from manufacturers. However, for certain types of uniforms (such as maternity dresses) or special sizes (e.g., extra-large or smaller than standard sizes), where the demand volume is relatively low unlike the PTG Group, which has a larger workforce and thus higher demand for all uniform types the Group is unable to purchase these specific items directly from manufacturers. Consequently, it is necessary for the Group to purchase such uniforms from PTC. - In this regard, the purchase price of uniforms from PTC is calculated based on cost plus administrative expenses to cover PTC's sourcing and operational costs. Such purchase price is considered comparable to the price at which OLP could source directly from the suppliers of said goods - Regarding employee welfare expenses arising from providing discounts on goods and services within the Group and the PTG Group, the transaction complies with a mutual agreement stipulating that each party shall be responsible for the actual discount amounts utilised by their respective employees on a monthly basis. - Additionally, a portion of employee welfare expenses arises from the purchase of food, beverages, and medical supplies for the Group’s employees. In this regard, the prices and commercial terms received by the Group from PTC, PUN, GS, and MVT are consistent with those PTC, PUN, GS, and MVT offer to other customers. · Description: - The Group incurs employee welfare expenses regarding the purchase of staff uniforms. - The Group also incurs employee welfare expenses arising from employees utilising discounts to purchase goods and services from the PTG Group. Consequently, the Group is required to reimburse the discount amounts to the PTG Group. - The Group incurs employee welfare expenses regarding the purchase of food and beverages for employees attending various training courses organized by the Company. - The Group also incurs employee expenses regarding the purchase of medical supplies for employees. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Employee Benefits Expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. This is because purchasing low-demand uniforms from PTC alleviates the Group’s burden of maintaining excess inventory. Furthermore, the purchase prices and conditions are comparable to those the Group would agree upon with suppliers. Therefore, the transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. - Additionally, providing discounts on goods and services is a standard form of employee welfare adopted by most companies. It enables employees to purchase quality goods and services at prices lower than the general public, while also fostering a sense of pride in the organization they work for. In this regard, the fact that each company assumes responsibility for the discount costs based on actual employee usage ensures that the welfare expenses of each entity accurately reflect the volume of benefits provided to its employees. Consequently, this transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. · 0.03 · Necessity: - The Group set up a Punthai Coffee booth at an event for its customers and business partners. The pricing and commercial terms provided by PUN to the Group are consistent with those offered to other customers. - The Group distributes coupons to customers during events to serve as discounts for product purchases. - The prices and commercial terms received by the Group from PUN, GFA, and GS are consistent with those PUN, GFA, and GS offer to other customers. · Description: - The Group set up a Punthai Coffee booth at events for customers and business partners of the Group. - The Group distributes discount coupons to customers during events held at oil and LPG service stations, to be used as discounts for the purchase of products from PUN, GFA, and GS. · Nature of transaction: Other expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is both appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The setup of the Punthai Coffee booth and distributing discount coupons for product purchases at events for the Group’s customers and business partners help foster good relationships with said customers and business partners. Furthermore, the prices and commercial terms received by the Group from PUN, GFA, and GS are consistent with those PUN, GFA, and GS offer to other customers. Therefore, the transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. · 0.07 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. In this regard, the credit terms for the leasing of large billboards and advertising space on taxis, as agreed upon by OLP with PTG, are comparable to those the PTG Group receives from other providers of large billboards and taxi advertising area. · Description: - OLP has other receivables from accrued income arising from leasing commercial area, including water and electricity charges at OLP service stations. · Nature of transaction: Other receivables from related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · 0.0 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of consumable materials used at the service stations, payment of utility expenses, transportation and communication costs on behalf of the Group, as well as the awarding of PT Max Card points to PT Max Card members purchasing products from the Group, the use of E-vouchers by participating taxis, fuel purchases and payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, and employee welfare discounts are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and PTG. - The credit terms received by the Group from PTG are similar to those offered by PTG to other parties under comparable conditions. · Description: - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the purchase of supply used at the service stations from PTC, as well as utility, transportation, and communication expenses. Moreover, there are expenses related to the PT Max points awarded when PT Max Card members purchase products from the Group, and expenses incurred from the use of E-vouchers for taxis participating in the “We will get through this together” “Taxi Fights COVID” program, which provide discounts for purchasing products or services from PTG - The Group also has other payables for fuel purchases and product payments made using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from employee discounts for purchasing products from PTG. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties.
0.16 · Necessity: - OLP has agreed to allow vehicle users refueling with LPG and oil at its service stations to pay using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, both managed by PTC. This arrangement increases OLP’s sales opportunities, while PTC, as the card program operator, is responsible for collecting payments from cardholders and remitting the proceeds to OLP. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - Moreover, the Company sells LPG to PTGLG for its business operations, specifically for testing the gas tanks of transportation truck. The Company also sells cooking gas to WG, PUN, and PBN. - OLP sells LPG and oil to Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card holders at service station prices, which are the same rates offered to the general public. Moreover, the terms and conditions for accepting payments via these cards, as agreed between OLP and PTC, are consistent with those between PTG’s fuel service station dealers and PTC. - LPG prices at which the Group supplies PTGLG are in line with those charged to other customers. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from fuel purchases made by vehicles within the PTG Group at OLP’s service stations, with payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - The Company also reconised revenue from the sale of LPG products supplied to PTGLG, WG, PUN, and PBN for operational purposes. · As of yesteryear: 0.03 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and LPG Wholesale) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Accepting payments via the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card is consistent with normal business practices, whereby sellers provide multiple convenient payment options to customers. Additionally, the sale of LPG to PTGLG and sale of cooking gas to WG, PUN, PBN for internal operations are part of the Company’s ordinary course of business. The payment terms for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as well as the LPG pricing, are comparable to those offered to unrelated third parties. · - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of gas cylinder to PTC are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of LPG and Gas cartridges to the PTG Group are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. · Description: - The Company has trade receivables, which include outstanding revenues from the sale of LPG, bottled cooking gas, and gas cartridges, used in business operations and for retail purposes at cooking gas stores, fuel stations, Max Mart convenience stores, and Punthai Coffee Shop. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted.
0.0 · Necessity: - The Group and PTG Group have agreed to offer employee benefits, including discounts for purchasing products and services from both groups. Each party is responsible for the actual expenses incurred by their employees on a monthly basis. - When determining the discount for employees, the Company considers the benefits employees will receive and the appropriateness of the discount. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from oil sales arising from employee benefits. - According to the agreement, each company is responsible for the discount based on employee usage. The prices of products and services sold by the Group to PTG Group employees will be the same as those sold to the general public. The Company group is only responsible for welfare expenses corresponding to discounts used by its own employees. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from the discounted on the retail prices of LPG and oil arising from LPG and oil refueling by employees of PTG group at OLP's service stations, which PTG Group is responsible for reimbursing OLP for these discounted amounts. · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations) · Audit committee opinion: - After consideration, the Audit Committee believes that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Company group. Offering discounts to employees is a common form of employee welfare that most companies provide. It enables employees to purchase quality products and services at a price lower than that available to the public, and also fostering a sense of pride in the Company they work for. Additionally, since each company is responsible for the discount based on its employees' usage, the employee welfare costs reflect the extent of benefits provided within each company. As a result, this transaction is similar to dealings with external parties. · 0.0 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms regarding the discounts on LPG and fuel prices granted to PTG Group employees are comparable to those the Group extends to employees within the PTG Group. - However, following the change in the business model to granting the rights to distribute fuel and manage fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables resulting from fuel sales with employee discount benefits. · Description: - OLP has other receivables, part of which is accrued income from providing discounts on LPG and fuel sales to employees of PTG Group who refill and use their benefits at OLP service stations. PTG Group is required to reimburse OLP for these amounts. · Nature of transaction: Other Receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties.
- OLP has agreed to allow vehicle users refueling with LPG and oil at its service stations to pay using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, both managed by PTC. This arrangement increases OLP’s sales opportunities, while PTC, as the card program operator, is responsible for collecting payments from cardholders and remitting the proceeds to OLP. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - Moreover, the Company sells LPG to PTGLG for its business operations, specifically for testing the gas tanks of transportation truck. The Company also sells cooking gas to WG, PUN, and PBN. - OLP sells LPG and oil to Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card holders at service station prices, which are the same rates offered to the general public. Moreover, the terms and conditions for accepting payments via these cards, as agreed between OLP and PTC, are consistent with those between PTG’s fuel service station dealers and PTC. - LPG prices at which the Group supplies PTGLG are in line with those charged to other customers. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from fuel purchases made by vehicles within the PTG Group at OLP’s service stations, with payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - The Company also reconised revenue from the sale of LPG products supplied to PTGLG, WG, PUN, and PBN for operational purposes. · As of yesteryear: 0.06 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and LPG Wholesale) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Accepting payments via the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card is consistent with normal business practices, whereby sellers provide multiple convenient payment options to customers. Additionally, the sale of LPG to PTGLG and sale of cooking gas to WG, PUN, PBN for internal operations are part of the Company’s ordinary course of business. The payment terms for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as well as the LPG pricing, are comparable to those offered to unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.09 · 3.42 · Necessity: - The leasing of commercial area within OLP’s service stations enhances OLP's revenue, allowing the Company to better utilize its existing assets at these locations. It also enables the service stations to better meet the needs of motorists. OLP provides the opportunity for the general public, including PTG Group, to lease commercial space within its service stations for business operations. - The rental rates and terms that OLP offers to PTG Group are identical to those provided to other tenants leasing commercial area in OLP’s service stations. Similarly, these rates and terms are consistent with those PTC offers to external parties leasing commercial space at PTC’s service stations. · Description: - OLP recognised the rental income from commercial areas within its service stations as follows: • PTC leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Max Mart convenience store). • PUN leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Punthai Coffee shop). • SAB leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Automotive service and maintenance center under the “Autobacs” brand). • PTGLG rents for truck parking and warehouse of medical oxygen cylinders at the Phutthabucha 4 service station. • GFA rents to operate a retail store and services within the service station (Coffee World shop). • GS rents to operate a retail store and services within the service station (food and beverage shop “Subway”). • PBN leases within service stations to operate retail shops for goods and services (Food and beverage shop “Punthai Boat Noodle”). - The revenue from assets for lease consisted of rental fee and service fees on commercial area ,as well as utilities charges. · As of yesteryear: 1.8 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from assets for lease and other services · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and determined that it is appropriate and beneficial for the Group. Leasing commercial space generates additional income for OLP and increases the opportunities for motorists to utilize the service stations. Furthermore, the rental rates and lease terms agreed upon between OLP and PTG Group are comparable to those offered to third-party tenants. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.56 · 1.29 · Necessity: - For the repair and maintenance of vehicles used to transport gas cylinders from distribution stations to customers, the Company requires a service provider with specialised expertise in this area. - The service fees and terms offered by SAB to the Company are similar to those SAB provides to other repair and maintenance clients, and are comparable to what the Company receives from other service providers. · Description: - The Company uses repair and maintenance services for vehicles transporting gas cylinders from gas shops to customers. · As of yesteryear: 0.77 · Nature of transaction: Repair and maintenance Fees · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed and concluded that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The repair and maintenance services for the vehicles provided by SAB are standard business practices. The fees and terms the Company receives from SAB align closely with those offered to third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.53 · 0.03 · Necessity: - The Group purchased various products from PTG Group to be given as New Year gifts to its customers and business partners. These products include Pavitree items, Premium Max Card luggage, and Punthai gift baskets, among others. - The prices and terms offered to the Group by its affiliated companies are consistent with those provided to other customers of the affiliated companies. · Description: - The Group purchases products from PTG Group to use as New Year gifts for its customers and business partners. · Nature of transaction: Other Expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and concluded that it is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Providing New Year gifts to customers and partners is a standard business practice that fosters strong relationships with the Group’s clients and partners. The prices and terms received by the Group from the affiliated companies align with those offered to other customers. Therefore, this transaction is consistent with transactions conducted with third parties. · 0.05 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. In this regard, the credit terms for the leasing of large billboards and advertising space on taxis, as agreed upon by OLP with PTG, are comparable to those the PTG Group receives from other providers of large billboards and taxi advertising area. · Description: - OLP has other receivables from accrued income arising from leasing commercial area, including water and electricity charges at OLP service stations. · As of yesteryear: 0.3 · Nature of transaction: Other receivables from related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.03 · 0.31 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from services related to the repair and maintenance of vehicles are in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Company and SAB. - The credit terms received by the Company from SAB are similar to those provided to other service recipients. · Description: - The Company has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from vehicle repair and maintenance services provided by SAB. · As of yesteryear: 0.18 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01
- OLP has agreed to allow vehicle users refueling with LPG and oil at its service stations to pay using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, both managed by PTC. This arrangement increases OLP’s sales opportunities, while PTC, as the card program operator, is responsible for collecting payments from cardholders and remitting the proceeds to OLP. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - Moreover, the Company sells LPG to PTGLG for its business operations, specifically for testing the gas tanks of transportation truck. The Company also sells cooking gas to WG, PUN, and PBN. - OLP sells LPG and oil to Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card holders at service station prices, which are the same rates offered to the general public. Moreover, the terms and conditions for accepting payments via these cards, as agreed between OLP and PTC, are consistent with those between PTG’s fuel service station dealers and PTC. - LPG prices at which the Group supplies PTGLG are in line with those charged to other customers. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from fuel purchases made by vehicles within the PTG Group at OLP’s service stations, with payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - The Company also reconised revenue from the sale of LPG products supplied to PTGLG, WG, PUN, and PBN for operational purposes. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and LPG Wholesale) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Accepting payments via the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card is consistent with normal business practices, whereby sellers provide multiple convenient payment options to customers. Additionally, the sale of LPG to PTGLG and sale of cooking gas to WG, PUN, PBN for internal operations are part of the Company’s ordinary course of business. The payment terms for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as well as the LPG pricing, are comparable to those offered to unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.03 · - In the event that the Group incurs damages as a result of transportation services provided by PTGLG for example, damage to cooking gas cylinders during transit. The Group will seek compensation for such losses from the respective logistics providers. - The compensation charged is in accordance with the terms and conditions mutually agreed upon between the Group and each service provider. · Description: - The Group has other income from compensation collected from transportation service providers for damages incurred during transportation. · Nature of transaction: Other income · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and considers the arrangement to be appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. Transportation service providers have a duty to safeguard the goods entrusted to them throughout the delivery process. In cases where damage occurs during transit, it is appropriate that the service provider be held responsible. The compensation claimed by the Group is in line with the contractual terms and reflects standard commercial practice, under which logistics providers are liable for any damage arising from their services. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · - OLP currently does not own any oil transport trucks, as it lacks the expertise in fuel logistics and has no intention of investing in such assets. Given the availability of numerous qualified oil transport service providers, OLP has opted to outsource these services rather than manage transportation operations internally. - While there are many providers in the market, fuel transportation requires specialized knowledge, strict adherence to safety standards, and the capacity to accommodate OLP’s increasing delivery needs in line with business growth. The selection of PTGLG and AMA as transport service providers was based on their proven expertise and the scale of their fleets, which are well-suited to support OLP’s operational requirements. - However, following a shift in OLP’s business model transitioning to a licensing and station management arrangement OLP will no longer require oil transport services in the future. - The service fees and contractual terms offered by PTGLG and AMA were in line with those provided by other transport service providers engaged by OLP during the same period. · Description: - OLP uses transportation services from PTGLG and AMA to transport oil from refineries or designated oil receiving points to OLP’s service stations. · As of yesteryear: 47.02 · Nature of transaction: Cost of services – oil transportation · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transactions and is of the opinion that they are appropriate and in the best interests of the Group. The engagement of PTGLG and AMA for oil transportation services was conducted under normal commercial terms. The service rates and conditions offered were comparable to those extended to OLP by independent third-party providers. · As of year before yesteryear: 80.9 · - The outstanding liabilities arising from the use of oil transportation services are in line with the credit terms agreed upon by the Company with PTGLG and AMA. - The credit terms the Company receives from PTGLG and AMA are similar to those applied with other parties under comparable conditions. - However, following the shift in the business model to granting rights for fuel distribution and managing fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future trade payables arising from the use of oil transportation services. · Description: - The Company has trade payables, part of which consists of amounts not yet due for transportation services related to the delivery of fuel to its service stations. · Nature of transaction: Trade payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 8.41
0.03 · Necessity: - The Group and PTG Group have agreed to offer employee benefits, including discounts for purchasing products and services from both groups. Each party is responsible for the actual expenses incurred by their employees on a monthly basis. - When determining the discount for employees, the Company considers the benefits employees will receive and the appropriateness of the discount. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from oil sales arising from employee benefits. - According to the agreement, each company is responsible for the discount based on employee usage. The prices of products and services sold by the Group to PTG Group employees will be the same as those sold to the general public. The Company group is only responsible for welfare expenses corresponding to discounts used by its own employees. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from the discounted on the retail prices of LPG and oil arising from LPG and oil refueling by employees of PTG group at OLP's service stations, which PTG Group is responsible for reimbursing OLP for these discounted amounts. · As of yesteryear: 0.06 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations) · Audit committee opinion: - After consideration, the Audit Committee believes that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Company group. Offering discounts to employees is a common form of employee welfare that most companies provide. It enables employees to purchase quality products and services at a price lower than that available to the public, and also fostering a sense of pride in the Company they work for. Additionally, since each company is responsible for the discount based on its employees' usage, the employee welfare costs reflect the extent of benefits provided within each company. As a result, this transaction is similar to dealings with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.07 · 0.08 · Necessity: - OLP has agreed to allow vehicle users refueling with LPG and oil at its service stations to pay using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, both managed by PTC. This arrangement increases OLP’s sales opportunities, while PTC, as the card program operator, is responsible for collecting payments from cardholders and remitting the proceeds to OLP. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - Moreover, the Company sells LPG to PTGLG for its business operations, specifically for testing the gas tanks of transportation truck. The Company also sells cooking gas to WG, PUN, and PBN. - OLP sells LPG and oil to Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card holders at service station prices, which are the same rates offered to the general public. Moreover, the terms and conditions for accepting payments via these cards, as agreed between OLP and PTC, are consistent with those between PTG’s fuel service station dealers and PTC. - LPG prices at which the Group supplies PTGLG are in line with those charged to other customers. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from fuel purchases made by vehicles within the PTG Group at OLP’s service stations, with payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - The Company also reconised revenue from the sale of LPG products supplied to PTGLG, WG, PUN, and PBN for operational purposes. · As of yesteryear: 0.33 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and LPG Wholesale) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Accepting payments via the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card is consistent with normal business practices, whereby sellers provide multiple convenient payment options to customers. Additionally, the sale of LPG to PTGLG and sale of cooking gas to WG, PUN, PBN for internal operations are part of the Company’s ordinary course of business. The payment terms for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as well as the LPG pricing, are comparable to those offered to unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.54 · 1.02 · Necessity: - In November 2021, the Company launched its own line of gas catridge products, made available at its service stations and cooking gas retail outlets. This initiative was aimed at expanding the Company’s product portfolio and enhancing overall profitability. - To further broaden distribution channels, the Company began wholesale sales of gas catridge to third parties. This includes supplying the PTG Group for resale through its fuel service stations, Max Mart convenience stores, and Punthai Coffee outlets, as well as through PTG’s network of petroleum product dealers operating service stations. - The pricing and commercial terms offered to the PTG Group for these gas catridge products are determined using the same principles and methodology applied to third-party customers. · Description: - The Company recognised revenue through the sale of gas catridge to various entities within the PTG Group, including: • PTG distributes gas catridge to its network of dealers. • PTC distributes gas catridge at service stations and Max Mart convenience stores. • PUN distributes gas catridge at Punthai Coffee shops. • BPTG distributes gas catridge through its service station network. · As of yesteryear: 0.18 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - gas catridge · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and concluded that it is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The sale of gas catridge products helps generate additional revenue, while the pricing and commercial terms are aligned with those offered to external customers. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.04 · 42.31 · Necessity: - The leasing of commercial area within OLP’s service stations enhances OLP's revenue, allowing the Company to better utilize its existing assets at these locations. It also enables the service stations to better meet the needs of motorists. OLP provides the opportunity for the general public, including PTG Group, to lease commercial space within its service stations for business operations. - The rental rates and terms that OLP offers to PTG Group are identical to those provided to other tenants leasing commercial area in OLP’s service stations. Similarly, these rates and terms are consistent with those PTC offers to external parties leasing commercial space at PTC’s service stations. · Description: - OLP recognised the rental income from commercial areas within its service stations as follows: • PTC leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Max Mart convenience store). • PUN leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Punthai Coffee shop). • SAB leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Automotive service and maintenance center under the “Autobacs” brand). • PTGLG rents for truck parking and warehouse of medical oxygen cylinders at the Phutthabucha 4 service station. • GFA rents to operate a retail store and services within the service station (Coffee World shop). • GS rents to operate a retail store and services within the service station (food and beverage shop “Subway”). • PBN leases within service stations to operate retail shops for goods and services (Food and beverage shop “Punthai Boat Noodle”). - The revenue from assets for lease consisted of rental fee and service fees on commercial area ,as well as utilities charges. · As of yesteryear: 28.6 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from assets for lease and other services · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and determined that it is appropriate and beneficial for the Group. Leasing commercial space generates additional income for OLP and increases the opportunities for motorists to utilize the service stations. Furthermore, the rental rates and lease terms agreed upon between OLP and PTG Group are comparable to those offered to third-party tenants. · As of year before yesteryear: 16.59 · 7.1 · Necessity: - To ensure a unified standard of attire for employees working at service stations and gas shops operating under the "PT" brand, the Group has established a policy requiring all employees to wear uniforms that adhere to a single standard design. - Generally, OLP purchases employee uniforms directly from manufacturers. However, for certain types of uniforms (such as maternity dresses) or special sizes (e.g., extra-large or smaller than standard sizes), where the demand volume is relatively low unlike the PTG Group, which has a larger workforce and thus higher demand for all uniform types the Group is unable to purchase these specific items directly from manufacturers. Consequently, it is necessary for the Group to purchase such uniforms from PTC. - In this regard, the purchase price of uniforms from PTC is calculated based on cost plus administrative expenses to cover PTC's sourcing and operational costs. Such purchase price is considered comparable to the price at which OLP could source directly from the suppliers of said goods - Regarding employee welfare expenses arising from providing discounts on goods and services within the Group and the PTG Group, the transaction complies with a mutual agreement stipulating that each party shall be responsible for the actual discount amounts utilised by their respective employees on a monthly basis. - Additionally, a portion of employee welfare expenses arises from the purchase of food, beverages, and medical supplies for the Group’s employees. In this regard, the prices and commercial terms received by the Group from PTC, PUN, GS, and MVT are consistent with those PTC, PUN, GS, and MVT offer to other customers. · Description: - The Group incurs employee welfare expenses regarding the purchase of staff uniforms. - The Group also incurs employee welfare expenses arising from employees utilising discounts to purchase goods and services from the PTG Group. Consequently, the Group is required to reimburse the discount amounts to the PTG Group. - The Group incurs employee welfare expenses regarding the purchase of food and beverages for employees attending various training courses organized by the Company. - The Group also incurs employee expenses regarding the purchase of medical supplies for employees. · As of yesteryear: 0.49 · Nature of transaction: Employee Benefits Expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. This is because purchasing low-demand uniforms from PTC alleviates the Group’s burden of maintaining excess inventory. Furthermore, the purchase prices and conditions are comparable to those the Group would agree upon with suppliers. Therefore, the transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. - Additionally, providing discounts on goods and services is a standard form of employee welfare adopted by most companies. It enables employees to purchase quality goods and services at prices lower than the general public, while also fostering a sense of pride in the organization they work for. In this regard, the fact that each company assumes responsibility for the discount costs based on actual employee usage ensures that the welfare expenses of each entity accurately reflect the volume of benefits provided to its employees. Consequently, this transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. · 0.05 · Necessity: - From “The We Will Get Through This Together” “Taxi Fights COVID” campaign is an initiative aimed at alleviating the financial burden on taxi drivers. As part of the program, participating drivers agree to display public awareness messaging on COVID-19 prevention, along with advertisements, both inside and outside their taxis. In return, each driver receives an E-voucher valued at Baht 1,200 and discount coupons totaling Baht 1,800 sponsored by OLP. The e-vouchers can be redeemed for fuel or LPG at PT service stations, or used to purchase products and services within the PTG Group network. The discount coupons are specifically designated for LPG refueling at PT service stations. - OLP is responsible for the costs incurred when the E-vouchers are used to purchase products or services at PTG’s retail outlets, including Punthai Coffee shops, Max Mart convenience stores, PTC serivce stations, and authorized petroleum product dealers at service stations. · Description: - OLP incurs other expenses from using E-vouchers for taxis participating in the “We will get through this together project” and “Taxi Fights COVID campaign”, allowing discounts for purchasing products or services at PTG stores. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Other expenses · Audit committee opinion: - After reviewing the matter, the Audit Committee concluded that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Providing E-vouchers to taxis participating in the “We Will Get Through This Together” “Taxi Fights COVID” campaign is a corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiative that helps enhance the Company’s public image. It also aids in raising awareness of the Company’s LPG service stations among taxi drivers. The expenses incurred by OLP from the use of E-vouchers for purchasing products or services from PTG outlets will be equal to the actual value of the E-vouchers used. · 0.41 · Necessity: - The Group set up a Punthai Coffee booth at an event for its customers and business partners. The pricing and commercial terms provided by PUN to the Group are consistent with those offered to other customers. - The Group distributes coupons to customers during events to serve as discounts for product purchases. - The prices and commercial terms received by the Group from PUN, GFA, and GS are consistent with those PUN, GFA, and GS offer to other customers. · Description: - The Group set up a Punthai Coffee booth at events for customers and business partners of the Group. - The Group distributes discount coupons to customers during events held at oil and LPG service stations, to be used as discounts for the purchase of products from PUN, GFA, and GS. · As of yesteryear: 0.06 · Nature of transaction: Other expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is both appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The setup of the Punthai Coffee booth and distributing discount coupons for product purchases at events for the Group’s customers and business partners help foster good relationships with said customers and business partners. Furthermore, the prices and commercial terms received by the Group from PUN, GFA, and GS are consistent with those PUN, GFA, and GS offer to other customers. Therefore, the transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.05 · 0.25 · Necessity: - The Group purchased various products from PTG Group to be given as New Year gifts to its customers and business partners. These products include Pavitree items, Premium Max Card luggage, and Punthai gift baskets, among others. - The prices and terms offered to the Group by its affiliated companies are consistent with those provided to other customers of the affiliated companies. · Description: - The Group purchases products from PTG Group to use as New Year gifts for its customers and business partners. · As of yesteryear: 0.34 · Nature of transaction: Other Expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and concluded that it is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Providing New Year gifts to customers and partners is a standard business practice that fosters strong relationships with the Group’s clients and partners. The prices and terms received by the Group from the affiliated companies align with those offered to other customers. Therefore, this transaction is consistent with transactions conducted with third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.11 · 0.0 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms regarding the discounts on LPG and fuel prices granted to PTG Group employees are comparable to those the Group extends to employees within the PTG Group. - However, following the change in the business model to granting the rights to distribute fuel and manage fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables resulting from fuel sales with employee discount benefits. · Description: - OLP has other receivables, part of which is accrued income from providing discounts on LPG and fuel sales to employees of PTG Group who refill and use their benefits at OLP service stations. PTG Group is required to reimburse OLP for these amounts. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Other Receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01 · 6.01 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. In this regard, the credit terms for the leasing of large billboards and advertising space on taxis, as agreed upon by OLP with PTG, are comparable to those the PTG Group receives from other providers of large billboards and taxi advertising area. · Description: - OLP has other receivables from accrued income arising from leasing commercial area, including water and electricity charges at OLP service stations. · As of yesteryear: 2.87 · Nature of transaction: Other receivables from related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.03 · - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for fuel sales to PTG Group vehicles utilising Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise cards are consistent with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. - The credit terms for outstanding receivables arising from the sale of fuel to PTG vehicles using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as provided by the Group to PTG, are similar to those established between PTG's petroleum product distributors at its gas stations and PTC, the card administrator. - However, following the change in the business model to granting rights for fuel distribution and managing fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables arising from fuel sales through the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. · Description: - OLP has trade receivables, part of which is accrued income from selling fuel to vehicles of PTG Group that refuel at OLP service stations using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.07 · 0.01 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of gas cylinder to PTC are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of LPG and Gas cartridges to the PTG Group are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. · Description: - The Company has trade receivables, which include outstanding revenues from the sale of LPG, bottled cooking gas, and gas cartridges, used in business operations and for retail purposes at cooking gas stores, fuel stations, Max Mart convenience stores, and Punthai Coffee Shop. · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted. · 1.78 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of consumable materials used at the service stations, payment of utility expenses, transportation and communication costs on behalf of the Group, as well as the awarding of PT Max Card points to PT Max Card members purchasing products from the Group, the use of E-vouchers by participating taxis, fuel purchases and payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, and employee welfare discounts are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and PTG. - The credit terms received by the Group from PTG are similar to those offered by PTG to other parties under comparable conditions. · Description: - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the purchase of supply used at the service stations from PTC, as well as utility, transportation, and communication expenses. Moreover, there are expenses related to the PT Max points awarded when PT Max Card members purchase products from the Group, and expenses incurred from the use of E-vouchers for taxis participating in the “We will get through this together” “Taxi Fights COVID” program, which provide discounts for purchasing products or services from PTG - The Group also has other payables for fuel purchases and product payments made using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from employee discounts for purchasing products from PTG. · As of yesteryear: 0.49 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · - The Group set up a Punthai Coffee booth at an event for its customers and business partners. The pricing and commercial terms received by the Group from PUN are the same as those offered to other customers. · Description: - The Company has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from organizing Punthai Coffee Shop booths at events for customers and partners of the Group. · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and believes that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group, as providing the Punthai Coffee booth at the event helps strengthen relationships with the Group’s customers and partners. The pricing and commercial terms the Group received from PUN are consistent with those provided to other customers. Therefore, the transaction is in line with those typically made with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.12 · - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of products from the PTG Group for New Year gifts are in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. - The credit terms received by the Company from the PTG Group are similar to those the Group provides to other customers. · Description: - The Group has other payables for expenses related to purchasing products from PTG Group to be used as New Year gifts for the Company's customers and business partners. · As of yesteryear: 0.36 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01
20.74 · Necessity: - If equipment at OLP's service stations is damaged, OLP must hire a service provider capable of performing repairs and maintenance, as OLP lacks the expertise to inspect and repair the stations. - OLP has agreed to engage ESS for the repair and maintenance services at its service stations, as ESS specializes in maintaining and repairing equipment at service stations and has a nationwide network capable of delivering these services. - The service fees and terms that OLP has negotiated with ESS are comparable to those provided by other repair and maintenance service providers to OLP. · Description: - OLP uses repair and maintenance services for its service stations from ESS. · As of yesteryear: 17.06 · Nature of transaction: Service fees · Audit committee opinion: - After reviewing the matter, the Audit Committee determined that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The use of ESS for repair and maintenance services is a standard business practice. Furthermore, the service fees and terms OLP has agreed to with ESS are similar to those it would receive from other external service providers. · As of year before yesteryear: 28.55 · 3.69 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from repair and maintenance services for service stations are in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and ESS. - The credit terms granted to the Company by ESS are comparable to those offered by the Group to other parties under similar conditions. · Description: - The Company has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the repair and maintenance services for service stations provided by ESS. · As of yesteryear: 2.76 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 4.7
0.96 · Necessity: - For the repair and maintenance of the fuel dispenser control equipment at OLP’s service stations, OLP needs to hire a specialised contractor, as the repair of such equipment differs from that of other equipment within the station. - OLP has engaged INA to provide repair and maintenance services for the fuel dispenser control equipment, as INA is the supplier of this equipment to OLP. - The service fees and terms that OLP has agreed upon with INA are comparable to those provided by other repair and maintenance service providers to OLP. · Description: - OLP uses repair and maintenance services for the fuel dispenser control equipment at its service stations from INA. · As of yesteryear: 0.86 · Nature of transaction: Service fees · Audit committee opinion: - After review, the Audit Committee determined that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Using INA for the repair and maintenance of the fuel dispenser control equipment follows standard business practice. The service fees and terms OLP has agreed to with INA are consistent with those typically offered by external service providers. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.81 · 11.28 · Necessity: - Previously, OLP purchased Point of Sale (POS) equipment from a manufacturer for installation and use at its service stations. In addition, OLP had to cover additional repair and maintenance costs whenever the equipment became faulty. - However, OLP has since determined that leasing the equipment along with maintenance services would help reduce overall expenses and ensure the equipment remains in good working condition for uninterrupted operation. - As a result, OLP has agreed to lease POS equipment, including fuel dispenser control systems, from INA, as INA is the supplier of the POS equipment and also provides repair and maintenance services for the fuel dispenser systems at OLP’s service stations. - The rental fees and terms OLP has agreed to with INA are comparable to those OLP receives from other service providers. · Description: - OLP leases equipment for the Point of Sale (POS) system from INA. · As of yesteryear: 9.97 · Nature of transaction: Equipment rental - point of sale (POS) system · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed and determined that this transaction is appropriate and beneficial for the Group. Leasing the POS equipment and associated maintenance services is a standard business practice. The rental fees and terms, along with the repair and maintenance services OLP receives from INA, are consistent with those typically offered by third-party providers. · As of year before yesteryear: 7.09 · 1.2 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from services related to the repair and maintenance of the control equipment for fuel dispensers at service stations and the rental of tools and equipment used in the point-of-sale (POS) system are in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and INA. - The credit terms received by the Group from INA are similar to those applied by the Group to other parties under comparable conditions. · Description: - The Company has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the repair and maintenance services for equipment controlling the operation of fuel dispensers at service stations and the rental of tools and equipment used in the Point of Sale (POS) system from INA. · As of yesteryear: 1.03 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.89
- As part of its participation of the PT Max Card membership program, the Group has agreed to allow PT Max Card and PT Max Plus members to earn reward points when purchasing products from the Group. Members may redeem these points for discounts on Group products including exclusive promotions offered through the PT Max Card program. - The Group is responsible for funding the reward points earned by members who purchase its products. Conversely, the Group receives reimbursement for points redeemed and discounts used by members. These transactions are managed through PTG Group companies that oversee the loyalty program. (PTC performed this role until June 2021, followed by MAX from July 2021 to September 2022, and MMC from October 2022 onward.) - In addition, the Group receives compensation related to discounts and added benefits offered to card members from PTG Group companies that own the membership cards and oversee member privileges. (PTG served as the card issuer until June 2021, after which MAX assumed the role from July 2021 to September 2022, and MMC from October 2022 onward. Responsibility for managing additional member benefits rested with PTG until April 2021, then transferred to MSS from May 2021 onward. PTG further appointed MAX to manage these benefits from July 2021 to September 2022, followed by MMC from October to December 2022.) - Participation in the PT Max Card system enables the Group to expand its customer base by accessing cardholders who are already familiar with and loyal to the “PT” brand. It also allows the Group to leverage an existing membership platform for marketing and promotional activities without the need to invest in or manage the membership system internally. - The value of reward points provided to members of the Group (which the Group pays to the point system administrator) is equal to the value of points redeemed as discounts (which the administrator reimburses to the Group). For any additional benefits offered to members, the entity authorising those benefits is fully responsible for covering the related costs. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from fuel sales related to membership discounts and benefits. - The terms under which the Group participates in the Max Card program are aligned with the standard agreements PTG Group has in place with its petroleum dealers operating service stations. · Description: - The Group recognises revenue from sales through product discounts offered to loyalty card members, with PTC and/or MAX and/or MMC acting as program administrators. - Additional revenue is generated from value-added benefits provided to loyalty card members under programs managed by PTG and/or MSS. The Company charges the corresponding value of these benefits to PTC and/or MAX, as well as PTG and/or MSS and/or MMC, respectively. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and Gas shops) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. Participating in a loyalty program managed by a third party is a common and effective business strategy. It supports the Group’s marketing efforts by encouraging customer retention and repeat purchases. Furthermore, the participation terms are consistent with those applied to third-party petroleum dealers within the PTG network. As such, the nature of this transaction is comparable to transactions made with unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.74 · Necessity: - OLP has agreed to allow customers refueling with LPG or gasoline at OLP service stations to pay for products using the Max Enterprise card issued by MAX. This arrangement provides OLP with greater sales opportunities, as PTC will collect payments from Max Enterprise cardholders (specifically for Postpaid customers) and reimburse OLP. - Additionally, MAX, as the issuer of the Max Enterprise card, will collect payments from the cardholders and transfer the funds to OLP. - However, following the change in business operations to granting the rights to sell and manage fuel distribution at OLP service stations, OLP will no longer charge additional fees for customers paying for fuel with the Max Enterprise card in the future. - Both PTC and MAX charge a fee based on a percentage of the transaction amount, which is the same rate applied to petroleum product distributors at PTG’s fuel stations. · Description: - OLP pays fees for the use of the Max Enterprise Card to PTC and MAX for the sale of LPG and fuel at service stations to customers who pay for products using the Max Enterprise Card. · As of yesteryear: 4.25 · Nature of transaction: Other Financial Expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Accepting payments for products and services via the Max Enterprise card is a standard business practice, as it allows businesses to offer customers a variety of payment options for added convenience. Additionally, the fees associated with using the Max Enterprise card are consistent with those applied in similar transactions with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 7.35 · 0.91 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for fuel sales to PTG Group vehicles utilising Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise cards are consistent with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. - PTG The credit terms for outstanding receivables arising from the sale of fuel to PTG vehicles using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as provided by the Group to PTG, are similar to those established between PTG's petroleum product distributors at its gas stations and PTG. - However, after the business model transition to granting rights for fuel distribution and managing fuel sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future outstanding receivables from fuel sales made through the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. · Description: - OLP has trade receivables, part of which consists of accrued income from the sale of LPG and fuel to customers who paid using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, which is managed by PTC. - In addition, OLP has trade receivables, part of which consists of accrued income from the sale of LPG and fuel to customers who paid using the Max Enterprise Card issued by MAX. As the issuer of the Max Enterprise Card, MAX is responsible for collecting the payment from the Max Enterprise Cardholders and reimbursing OLP. · As of yesteryear: 0.97 · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted. · As of year before yesteryear: 14.63 · 0.0 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of gas cylinder to PTC are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of LPG and Gas cartridges to the PTG Group are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. · Description: - The Company has trade receivables, which include outstanding revenues from the sale of LPG, bottled cooking gas, and gas cartridges, used in business operations and for retail purposes at cooking gas stores, fuel stations, Max Mart convenience stores, and Punthai Coffee Shop. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted. · 0.07 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of consumable materials used at the service stations, payment of utility expenses, transportation and communication costs on behalf of the Group, as well as the awarding of PT Max Card points to PT Max Card members purchasing products from the Group, the use of E-vouchers by participating taxis, fuel purchases and payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, and employee welfare discounts are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and PTG. - The credit terms received by the Group from PTG are similar to those offered by PTG to other parties under comparable conditions. · Description: - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the purchase of supply used at the service stations from PTC, as well as utility, transportation, and communication expenses. Moreover, there are expenses related to the PT Max points awarded when PT Max Card members purchase products from the Group, and expenses incurred from the use of E-vouchers for taxis participating in the “We will get through this together” “Taxi Fights COVID” program, which provide discounts for purchasing products or services from PTG - The Group also has other payables for fuel purchases and product payments made using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from employee discounts for purchasing products from PTG. · As of yesteryear: 0.06 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.12
- The Group purchased various products from PTG Group to be given as New Year gifts to its customers and business partners. These products include Pavitree items, Premium Max Card luggage, and Punthai gift baskets, among others. - The prices and terms offered to the Group by its affiliated companies are consistent with those provided to other customers of the affiliated companies. · Description: - The Group purchases products from PTG Group to use as New Year gifts for its customers and business partners. · Nature of transaction: Other Expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and concluded that it is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Providing New Year gifts to customers and partners is a standard business practice that fosters strong relationships with the Group’s clients and partners. The prices and terms received by the Group from the affiliated companies align with those offered to other customers. Therefore, this transaction is consistent with transactions conducted with third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01 · - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of products from the PTG Group for New Year gifts are in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. - The credit terms received by the Company from the PTG Group are similar to those the Group provides to other customers. · Description: - The Group has other payables for expenses related to purchasing products from PTG Group to be used as New Year gifts for the Company's customers and business partners. · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01
- OLP has agreed to allow vehicle users refueling with LPG and oil at its service stations to pay using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, both managed by PTC. This arrangement increases OLP’s sales opportunities, while PTC, as the card program operator, is responsible for collecting payments from cardholders and remitting the proceeds to OLP. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - Moreover, the Company sells LPG to PTGLG for its business operations, specifically for testing the gas tanks of transportation truck. The Company also sells cooking gas to WG, PUN, and PBN. - OLP sells LPG and oil to Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card holders at service station prices, which are the same rates offered to the general public. Moreover, the terms and conditions for accepting payments via these cards, as agreed between OLP and PTC, are consistent with those between PTG’s fuel service station dealers and PTC. - LPG prices at which the Group supplies PTGLG are in line with those charged to other customers. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from fuel purchases made by vehicles within the PTG Group at OLP’s service stations, with payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - The Company also reconised revenue from the sale of LPG products supplied to PTGLG, WG, PUN, and PBN for operational purposes. · As of yesteryear: 0.07 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and LPG Wholesale) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Accepting payments via the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card is consistent with normal business practices, whereby sellers provide multiple convenient payment options to customers. Additionally, the sale of LPG to PTGLG and sale of cooking gas to WG, PUN, PBN for internal operations are part of the Company’s ordinary course of business. The payment terms for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as well as the LPG pricing, are comparable to those offered to unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.23 · 2.72 · Necessity: - The Group distributes palm oil, purchased from PPPGC and PTG, to restaurant customers and service station patrons. This is to fulfill the needs of the Group’s customer base, specifically: the restaurant segment, which requires both gas cylinder and palm oil for business operations; and the service station customer segment, which requires palm oil for household cooking. - The purchase prices and terms offered to the Group by PPPGC and PTG are consistent with those provided to other customers. · Description: - The Group purchases palm oil from PPPGC and PTG for resale to restaurant customers and customers utilising the services at OLP’s service stations. · As of yesteryear: 3.32 · Nature of transaction: Cost of goods sold - palm oil · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transactions and considers them appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The sale of palm oil contributes to the Group’s revenue generation. Importantly, the purchase prices and conditions offered by PPPGC and PTG are equivalent to those extended to their other customers. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.08 · 0.21 · Necessity: - The outstanding expenses not yet due, arising from the purchase of palm oil, are in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and PPPGC. - The credit terms granted to the Group by PPPGC are comparable to those offered to other buyers. · Description: - The Company has trade payables, part of which consists of amounts due for the purchase of palm oil from PPPGC, intended for resale to restaurant customers. · As of yesteryear: 0.07 · Nature of transaction: Trade payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.39
0.46 · Necessity: - The Company has leased land from TUNCHAD in Phatthalung Province to establish the filling plant. This strategic move enables the Company to strengthen its distribution network to gas shops and expand its market presence in Southern Thailand. It also supports broader brand awareness and recognition of the “PT” brand across all regions. - The rental rate agreed with TUNCHAD was determined based on market benchmarks for comparable properties in the surrounding area. · Description: - The Company leases land from TUNCHAD to open an filling plant in Phatthalung province. · As of yesteryear: 0.35 · Nature of transaction: Property rental expenses - filling plants · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and in the best interests of the Group. The establishment of the filling plant enhances the Company’s distribution capabilities and supports its regional market expansion strategy, particularly in Southern Thailand. This initiative contributes to building nationwide recognition of the “PT” brand. The rental rate agreed with TUNCHAD aligns with prevailing market rates for similar properties, indicating that the transaction was conducted on fair and arm’s-length terms. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.46 · 3.8 · Necessity: - The Group engaged services for landscape improvements within the Nakhon Chai Si 11 oil and LPG service station to enhance the image and create a positive impression for customers utilising the station’s services. - The service rates and conditions received by OLP from TUNCHAD are comparable to those OLP receives from other service providers. · Description: - The Group utilises landscape improvement services within the Nakhon Chai Si 11 oil and LPG service station. · Nature of transaction: Landscape improvement expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is beneficial to the Group. This is because utilising landscape improvement services from TUNCHAD constitutes a general commercial transaction. The service rates and conditions received from TUNCHAD are comparable to transactions made with third parties. · 1.53 · Necessity: - The lease of land from TUNCHAD in Phatthalung Province to establish the Company’s LPG filling plant assists expand distribution channels to LPG retailers and extends the market into southern Thailand, aiming to create and increase brand recognition of “PT” across all regions. - Furthermore, the prepayment of the land lease upon signing the agreement and the annual lease payment terms are standard commercial conditions for property leases, particularly for land leasing. · Description: - The Company leases land from TUNCHAD to establish an LPG filling plant in Phatthalung Province, with a one-time prepayment for the land at the start of the lease agreement, along with annual rent payments as per the lease terms. · As of yesteryear: 1.6 · Nature of transaction: Prepaid rental expense - Filling plant · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Company. The establishment of the LPG filling plant enables the Company to expand its distribution channels to LPG retailers and extend its market into southern Thailand, which is crucial for building and increasing the recognition of the “PT” brand across all regions. Additionally, the lease terms agreed upon with TUNCHAD are standard commercial conditions for property leasing, especially land leasing. Therefore, this transaction is consistent with transactions conducted with third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.65 · - The lease of land from TUNCHAD in Phatthalung Province to establish the Company’s LPG filling plant assists expand distribution channels to LPG retailers and extends the market into southern Thailand, aiming to create and increase brand recognition of “PT” across all regions. - Furthermore, the prepayment of the land lease upon signing the agreement and the annual lease payment terms are standard commercial conditions for property leases, particularly for land leasing. · Description: - The Company leases land from TUNCHAD to establish an LPG filling plant in Phatthalung Province. · Nature of transaction: Accrued rental expense - Filling plant · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Company. The establishment of the LPG filling plant enables the Company to expand its distribution channels to LPG retailers and extend its market into southern Thailand, which is crucial for building and increasing the recognition of the “PT” brand across all regions. Additionally, the lease terms agreed upon with TUNCHAD are standard commercial conditions for property leasing, especially land leasing. Therefore, this transaction is consistent with transactions conducted with third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.39
0.11 · Necessity: - To ensure a unified standard of attire for employees working at service stations and gas shops operating under the "PT" brand, the Group has established a policy requiring all employees to wear uniforms that adhere to a single standard design. - Generally, OLP purchases employee uniforms directly from manufacturers. However, for certain types of uniforms (such as maternity dresses) or special sizes (e.g., extra-large or smaller than standard sizes), where the demand volume is relatively low unlike the PTG Group, which has a larger workforce and thus higher demand for all uniform types the Group is unable to purchase these specific items directly from manufacturers. Consequently, it is necessary for the Group to purchase such uniforms from PTC. - In this regard, the purchase price of uniforms from PTC is calculated based on cost plus administrative expenses to cover PTC's sourcing and operational costs. Such purchase price is considered comparable to the price at which OLP could source directly from the suppliers of said goods - Regarding employee welfare expenses arising from providing discounts on goods and services within the Group and the PTG Group, the transaction complies with a mutual agreement stipulating that each party shall be responsible for the actual discount amounts utilised by their respective employees on a monthly basis. - Additionally, a portion of employee welfare expenses arises from the purchase of food, beverages, and medical supplies for the Group’s employees. In this regard, the prices and commercial terms received by the Group from PTC, PUN, GS, and MVT are consistent with those PTC, PUN, GS, and MVT offer to other customers. · Description: - The Group incurs employee welfare expenses regarding the purchase of staff uniforms. - The Group also incurs employee welfare expenses arising from employees utilising discounts to purchase goods and services from the PTG Group. Consequently, the Group is required to reimburse the discount amounts to the PTG Group. - The Group incurs employee welfare expenses regarding the purchase of food and beverages for employees attending various training courses organized by the Company. - The Group also incurs employee expenses regarding the purchase of medical supplies for employees. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Employee Benefits Expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. This is because purchasing low-demand uniforms from PTC alleviates the Group’s burden of maintaining excess inventory. Furthermore, the purchase prices and conditions are comparable to those the Group would agree upon with suppliers. Therefore, the transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. - Additionally, providing discounts on goods and services is a standard form of employee welfare adopted by most companies. It enables employees to purchase quality goods and services at prices lower than the general public, while also fostering a sense of pride in the organization they work for. In this regard, the fact that each company assumes responsibility for the discount costs based on actual employee usage ensures that the welfare expenses of each entity accurately reflect the volume of benefits provided to its employees. Consequently, this transaction is considered to be on terms comparable to those made with third parties. · 0.08 · Necessity: - The Group purchased various products from PTG Group to be given as New Year gifts to its customers and business partners. These products include Pavitree items, Premium Max Card luggage, and Punthai gift baskets, among others. - The prices and terms offered to the Group by its affiliated companies are consistent with those provided to other customers of the affiliated companies. · Description: - The Group purchases products from PTG Group to use as New Year gifts for its customers and business partners. · As of yesteryear: 0.05 · Nature of transaction: Other Expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and concluded that it is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Providing New Year gifts to customers and partners is a standard business practice that fosters strong relationships with the Group’s clients and partners. The prices and terms received by the Group from the affiliated companies align with those offered to other customers. Therefore, this transaction is consistent with transactions conducted with third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.02 · 0.0 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of consumable materials used at the service stations, payment of utility expenses, transportation and communication costs on behalf of the Group, as well as the awarding of PT Max Card points to PT Max Card members purchasing products from the Group, the use of E-vouchers by participating taxis, fuel purchases and payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, and employee welfare discounts are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and PTG. - The credit terms received by the Group from PTG are similar to those offered by PTG to other parties under comparable conditions. · Description: - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the purchase of supply used at the service stations from PTC, as well as utility, transportation, and communication expenses. Moreover, there are expenses related to the PT Max points awarded when PT Max Card members purchase products from the Group, and expenses incurred from the use of E-vouchers for taxis participating in the “We will get through this together” “Taxi Fights COVID” program, which provide discounts for purchasing products or services from PTG - The Group also has other payables for fuel purchases and product payments made using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from employee discounts for purchasing products from PTG. · As of yesteryear: 0.05 · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · 0.09 · Necessity: - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of products from the PTG Group for New Year gifts are in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. - The credit terms received by the Company from the PTG Group are similar to those the Group provides to other customers. · Description: - The Group has other payables for expenses related to purchasing products from PTG Group to be used as New Year gifts for the Company's customers and business partners. · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.02
- OLP has agreed to allow vehicle users refueling with LPG and oil at its service stations to pay using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, both managed by PTC. This arrangement increases OLP’s sales opportunities, while PTC, as the card program operator, is responsible for collecting payments from cardholders and remitting the proceeds to OLP. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revenue from the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - Moreover, the Company sells LPG to PTGLG for its business operations, specifically for testing the gas tanks of transportation truck. The Company also sells cooking gas to WG, PUN, and PBN. - OLP sells LPG and oil to Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card holders at service station prices, which are the same rates offered to the general public. Moreover, the terms and conditions for accepting payments via these cards, as agreed between OLP and PTC, are consistent with those between PTG’s fuel service station dealers and PTC. - LPG prices at which the Group supplies PTGLG are in line with those charged to other customers. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from fuel purchases made by vehicles within the PTG Group at OLP’s service stations, with payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - The Company also reconised revenue from the sale of LPG products supplied to PTGLG, WG, PUN, and PBN for operational purposes. · As of yesteryear: 0.63 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and LPG Wholesale) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Accepting payments via the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card is consistent with normal business practices, whereby sellers provide multiple convenient payment options to customers. Additionally, the sale of LPG to PTGLG and sale of cooking gas to WG, PUN, PBN for internal operations are part of the Company’s ordinary course of business. The payment terms for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as well as the LPG pricing, are comparable to those offered to unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.48
0.04 · Necessity: - In November 2021, the Company launched its own line of gas catridge products, made available at its service stations and cooking gas retail outlets. This initiative was aimed at expanding the Company’s product portfolio and enhancing overall profitability. - To further broaden distribution channels, the Company began wholesale sales of gas catridge to third parties. This includes supplying the PTG Group for resale through its fuel service stations, Max Mart convenience stores, and Punthai Coffee outlets, as well as through PTG’s network of petroleum product dealers operating service stations. - The pricing and commercial terms offered to the PTG Group for these gas catridge products are determined using the same principles and methodology applied to third-party customers. · Description: - The Company recognised revenue through the sale of gas catridge to various entities within the PTG Group, including: • PTG distributes gas catridge to its network of dealers. • PTC distributes gas catridge at service stations and Max Mart convenience stores. • PUN distributes gas catridge at Punthai Coffee shops. • BPTG distributes gas catridge through its service station network. · As of yesteryear: 0.02 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - gas catridge · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and concluded that it is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The sale of gas catridge products helps generate additional revenue, while the pricing and commercial terms are aligned with those offered to external customers. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01 · 0.01 · Necessity: - The Group requires employees who use company vehicles for work purposes to pay for fuel using a Corporate Card, as both the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card function similarly to Fleet Cards. These cards are primarily intended to control and monitor employees’ fuel usage in accordance with company policies. - Furthermore, since OLP has agreed to accept payment for products at its service stations via the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, employees using the Group's vehicles are able to refuel at OLP’s service stations. - The service fees and terms of use for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card agreed upon between the Group and PTC are the same as those offered to other users of these cards. · Description: - The Group incurs travel expenses arising from the Company’s vehicles refueling at PTC-operated service stations and paying for products using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Other expenses – travel expenses · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and is of the opinion that it is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The use of the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, which are mainly intended for controlling employee fuel usage, is in line with normal business practices. These cards function similarly to Fleet Cards, which are commonly used for monitoring employee fuel consumption. - Moreover, the service fees and terms of use for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card are consistent with those applied to other users. Therefore, this transaction is considered to be on the same basis as transactions with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01 · 0.0 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of gas cylinder to PTC are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of LPG and Gas cartridges to the PTG Group are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. · Description: - The Company has trade receivables, which include outstanding revenues from the sale of LPG, bottled cooking gas, and gas cartridges, used in business operations and for retail purposes at cooking gas stores, fuel stations, Max Mart convenience stores, and Punthai Coffee Shop. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · - The outstanding liabilities arising from the purchase of consumable materials used at the service stations, payment of utility expenses, transportation and communication costs on behalf of the Group, as well as the awarding of PT Max Card points to PT Max Card members purchasing products from the Group, the use of E-vouchers by participating taxis, fuel purchases and payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, and employee welfare discounts are in line with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and PTG. - The credit terms received by the Group from PTG are similar to those offered by PTG to other parties under comparable conditions. · Description: - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from the purchase of supply used at the service stations from PTC, as well as utility, transportation, and communication expenses. Moreover, there are expenses related to the PT Max points awarded when PT Max Card members purchase products from the Group, and expenses incurred from the use of E-vouchers for taxis participating in the “We will get through this together” “Taxi Fights COVID” program, which provide discounts for purchasing products or services from PTG - The Group also has other payables for fuel purchases and product payments made using Corporate Cards and Max Enterprise Cards. - The Group has other payables, part of which consists of expenses that have not yet due, arising from employee discounts for purchasing products from PTG. · Nature of transaction: Other payables to related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
- From “The We Will Get Through This Together” “Taxi Fights COVID” campaign is an initiative aimed at alleviating the financial burden on taxi drivers. As part of the program, participating drivers agree to display public awareness messaging on COVID-19 prevention, along with advertisements, both inside and outside their taxis. In return, each driver receives an E-voucher valued at Baht 1,200 and discount coupons totaling Baht 1,800 sponsored by OLP. The e-vouchers can be redeemed for fuel or LPG at PT service stations, or used to purchase products and services within the PTG Group network. The discount coupons are specifically designated for LPG refueling at PT service stations. - As part of the arrangement, the PTG Group leases advertising on the participating taxis to promote the PT brand and products within the PTG Group portfolio. OLP bears the cost of redemptions made through the e-vouchers and discount coupons used by participating drivers. - The advertising rental rates and conditions agreed upon with OLP are aligned with prevailing market rates offered by other advertising service providers. · Description: - OLP recognised the revenue by leasing advertising space on taxis participating in its program to companies within the PTG Group. · As of yesteryear: 4.99 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from assets for lease and other services · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and in the best interest of the Group. The leasing of advertising space on taxis forms part of a Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) initiative that not only supports the taxi driver community but also enhances the Company’s public image. Additionally, it serves to increase awareness and familiarity among drivers with the Company’s LPG service stations. Furthermore, by allowing the PTG Group to lease advertising space on participating taxis for brand awareness campaigns and the promotion of PTG Group’s products and services, the Company is able to maximize the value and utility of available advertising assets. The rental rates and terms for advertising space on taxis under this program are comparable to prevailing market rates offered by other advertising providers. Therefore, the transaction is considered to be conducted on an arm’s-length basis and comparable to a transaction with an independent third party.
0.03 · Necessity: - OLP has agreed to allow vehicle users refueling with LPG and oil at its service stations to pay using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, both managed by PTC. This arrangement increases OLP’s sales opportunities, while PTC, as the card program operator, is responsible for collecting payments from cardholders and remitting the proceeds to OLP. - However, following the change in the business model to granting of oil distribution rights and the provision management services for the oil retail sales at OLP service stations, there will be no future revnue from the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - Moreover, the Company sells LPG to PTGLG for its business operations, specifically for testing the gas tanks of transportation truck. The Company also sells cooking gas to WG, PUN, and PBN. - OLP sells LPG and oil to Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card holders at service station prices, which are the same rates offered to the general public. Moreover, the terms and conditions for accepting payments via these cards, as agreed between OLP and PTC, are consistent with those between PTG’s fuel service station dealers and PTC. - LPG prices at which the Group supplies PTGLG are in line with those charged to other customers. · Description: - OLP recognised revenue from fuel purchases made by vehicles within the PTG Group at OLP’s service stations, with payments made using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. - The Company also reconised revenue from the sale of LPG products supplied to PTGLG, WG, PUN, and PBN for operational purposes. · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales - petroleum products (Service stations and LPG Wholesale) · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and considers it appropriate and beneficial to the Group. Accepting payments via the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card is consistent with normal business practices, whereby sellers provide multiple convenient payment options to customers. Additionally, the sale of LPG to PTGLG and sale of cooking gas to WG, PUN, PBN for internal operations are part of the Company’s ordinary course of business. The payment terms for the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card, as well as the LPG pricing, are comparable to those offered to unrelated third parties. · 0.03 · Necessity: - The leasing of commercial area within OLP’s service stations enhances OLP's revenue, allowing the Company to better utilize its existing assets at these locations. It also enables the service stations to better meet the needs of motorists. OLP provides the opportunity for the general public, including PTG Group, to lease commercial space within its service stations for business operations. - The rental rates and terms that OLP offers to PTG Group are identical to those provided to other tenants leasing commercial area in OLP’s service stations. Similarly, these rates and terms are consistent with those PTC offers to external parties leasing commercial space at PTC’s service stations. · Description: - OLP recognised the rental income from commercial areas within its service stations as follows: • PTC leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Max Mart convenience store). • PUN leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Punthai Coffee shop). • SAB leases to operate a retail store and services within the service stations (Automotive service and maintenance center under the “Autobacs” brand). • PTGLG rents for truck parking and warehouse of medical oxygen cylinders at the Phutthabucha 4 service station. • GFA rents to operate • a retail store and services within the service station (Coffee World shop). • GS rents to operate a retail store and services within the service station (food and beverage shop “Subway”). • PBN leases within service stations to operate retail shops for goods and services (Food and beverage shop “Punthai Boat Noodle”). - The revenue from assets for lease consisted of rental fee and service fees on commercial area ,as well as utilities charges. · Nature of transaction: Revenue from assets for lease and other services · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the transaction and determined that it is appropriate and beneficial for the Group. Leasing commercial space generates additional income for OLP and increases the opportunities for motorists to utilize the service stations. Furthermore, the rental rates and lease terms agreed upon between OLP and PTG Group are comparable to those offered to third-party tenants. · 0.02 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. In this regard, the credit terms for the leasing of large billboards and advertising space on taxis, as agreed upon by OLP with PTG, are comparable to those the PTG Group receives from other providers of large billboards and taxi advertising area. · Description: - OLP has other receivables from accrued income arising from leasing commercial area, including water and electricity charges at OLP service stations. · Nature of transaction: Other receivables from related parties · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties. · 0.03 · Necessity: - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of gas cylinder to PTC are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. - The accrued income incurred is in accordance with the credit terms agreed upon between the Group and the PTG Group. Specifically, the credit terms for the sale of LPG and Gas cartridges to the PTG Group are comparable to those the Company extends to its dealers. · Description: - The Company has trade receivables, which include outstanding revenues from the sale of LPG, bottled cooking gas, and gas cartridges, used in business operations and for retail purposes at cooking gas stores, fuel stations, Max Mart convenience stores, and Punthai Coffee Shop. · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables from related parties - petroleum products · Audit committee opinion: - The Audit Committee has reviewed the matter and concluded that the transaction is appropriate and beneficial to the Group. The establishment of the credit terms with partners follows standard business practices, and the commercial terms are similar to those applied to external parties with whom transactions of a similar nature are conducted.

Policy & Future Trends

Policy, Measures & Approval Process

The Company is committed to adhering to the regulations governing related party transactions as set forth by the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET), the Capital Market Supervisory Board, and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). To ensure compliance and transparency, the Company has established the following criteria and procedures for executing related party transactions:

  1. The Company applies the same pricing and contractual terms to related party transactions as it does to transactions with third-party customers. Any provision or receipt of financial assistance must be necessary, reasonable, and conducted under fair terms and conditions to maximize benefits for the Company.

  2. If a reference price is unavailable, the Company will compare the pricing of goods or services with prevailing market rates under similar conditions.

  3. For significant related party transactions, the Company may engage an independent appraiser to assess and validate pricing. This measure ensures that transactions are conducted on reasonable terms and serve the best interests of the Company and its subsidiaries.

  4. Directors, executives, or related persons may only engage in transactions with the Company or its subsidiaries after such transactions have been approved by a resolution of the Board of Directors and/or the Shareholders' Meeting (as applicable). However, this does not apply to commercial transactions conducted on terms similar to those a reasonable person would offer to an unrelated party in similar circumstances, where bargaining power is not influenced by the individual's status as a director, executive, or related person. Such transactions must be commercially reasonable and either pre-approved by the Board of Directors or adhere to principles already established by the Board.

  5. If the Company enters into related-party transactions or other transactions that fall under the regulations of the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET), the Capital Advisory Board, and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the Company must fully comply with all relevant regulations.

  6. The Company is required to disclose information regarding transactions that could present conflicts of interest or related-party transactions, or intercompany transactions, as per the guidelines set by the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET), the Capital Advisory Board, and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Such disclosures should be included in the Company’s annual report, annual filings, or any other relevant report. Related-party transactions must also be disclosed in the notes to the financial statements, as audited by the Company’s external auditors, in line with accounting standards.

  7. Related-party transactions must be reviewed in accordance with the audit plan by the Internal Audit Department, with the findings reported to the Audit Committee.

Prevention of Conflicts of Interest

The Company places great importance on ensuring that transactions with related parties or entities are conducted properly and transparently. It is committed to disclosing relevant information in a sufficient and beneficial manner for the Company. Therefore, the Company prioritizes the prevention of transactions that could potentially result in conflicts of interest, related-party transactions, or intercompany transactions, guided by the following key principles:

1. The Company requires directors and executives to disclose any relationships or related transactions that could give rise to a potential conflict of interest.

2. Directors and executives must avoid entering into related-party transactions that could create a conflict of interest with the Company. In cases where such transactions are necessary, they must be presented to the Audit Committee for review and recommendation prior to seeking approval from the Board of Directors and/or the Shareholders' Meeting (as applicable). This must be in accordance with the related-party transaction guidelines established by the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET), the Capital Advisory Board, and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), as well as with the principles of good corporate governance.

3. Executives and employees must adhere to the Company’s policies and business ethics, which are essential for maintaining the trust and confidence of all stakeholders. The Company will ensure that these practices are communicated effectively throughout the organization, fostering a clear understanding among all employees.

Future Trends in Related Party Transactions

Following the Group’s change in the business model for fuel sales at service stations — whereby PTC was granted the right to sell fuel in the fuel retail section of OLP’s service stations, while OLP was contracted to manage the fuel retail section at the stations it had granted rights — the Group will no longer have intercompany transactions related to fuel sales in the future. The significant intercompany transactions of this nature include:

  1. Revenue from Sales – Petroleum Products (Item 2 in the table above), which refers to revenue generated from PTG Group vehicles refueling with LPG and oil at OLP service stations and making payments using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card. Following the change in the fuel retail business model at service stations, the Company no longer sells fuel at service stations. Therefore, the Company will no longer have intercompany transactions related to revenue from the sale of “fuel” paid for using the Corporate Card and Max Enterprise Card.

  2. Revenue from Sales – Petroleum Products from gas service stations and gas shops (Item 3 in the table above), which refers to revenue collected by the Company from the PTG Group, which manages the Max Card program. This is because Max Card members utilize discounts or benefits associated with the Max Card to purchase products from the Company. Following the change in the fuel retail business model at service stations, the Company no longer sells fuel at service stations. As a result, the Company will no longer have intercompany transactions related to revenue from the use of discounts and benefits for purchasing “fuel” at service stations.

  3. Revenue from Sales – Petroleum Products (Item 5 in the table above), which refers to revenue generated from OLP’s sale of fuel stored in reserve tanks at service stations where OLP granted distribution rights to PTC. This intercompany transaction occurred only once as a result of the change in the fuel retail business model at service stations. Therefore, the Company will no longer have such intercompany transactions going forward.

  4. Service Costs, which refer to transportation service fees for fuel charged by PTGLG and AMA to OLP. Following the change in the fuel retail business model at service stations, OLP will no longer use such transportation services. Accordingly, the Company will no longer have such intercompany transactions.

  5. Service Expenses, which comprise various costs incurred by the Company for services provided by the PTG Group. These include fuel storage fees at PTG’s oil depots and royalty fees for the use of the “PT” trademark in connection with fuel sales. Following the change in the fuel retail business model at service stations operated by OLP, the Company will no longer incur service expenses related to fuel storage or the use of the “PT” trademark for fuel sales.

  6. Other Financial Expenses, which arise from the PTG Group, as the administrator of the Max Enterprise Card, charging transaction fees when customers use the Max Enterprise Card to purchase products from the Company. Following the change in the fuel retail business model at service stations, the Company no longer sells fuel at service stations. Therefore, the Company will no longer have intercompany transactions related to fees for using the Max Enterprise Card to purchase “fuel” at service stations.

Contents